300 or Troy?

June 19, 2007 4:09am CST
Which battle scenes did you prefer 300 or troy? I prefered 300, Troy was more realistic but the music of 300 made the battles cooler.Do you know other film battles that you think are better?
3 people like this
25 responses
• Trinidad And Tobago
19 Jun 07
I prefer 300 the fighting styles was excellent but i dont think 300 could be compared to Troy. Another great movie was Gladiator.
2 people like this
@sakana (260)
• Singapore
19 Jun 07
I didn't watch Troy but I don't think I want to. Heard the movie sucked :P I think the way 300's battles were shot also made it super cool. Frank Miller is a genius. I don't know any other film battles, but for fight scenes I'd strongly recommend Hero. It's a Chinese film set in the time of the Warring States.
19 Jun 07
Yeah, I've also seen that film and thought is was great! If you like that have you seen house of flying daggers or Seven swords? both the same style and very good in my opinion
2 people like this
@sakana (260)
• Singapore
19 Jun 07
I wanted to watch those but I had no time ): At the end-of-year holidays I'll definitely go on a movie spree!
1 person likes this
@Ryenjo (63)
• Brazil
19 Jun 07
I liked 300 more then Troy. 300 fighting scenes are way better...and i think that Troy went too much sentimental.
1 person likes this
19 Jun 07
Yeah, Troy did turn into a bit of a love story, plus Orlando Blooms character was such a girl it put me off
2 people like this
@jade1986 (567)
• India
19 Jun 07
Both 300 and troy were excellent movies. Troy would fair better among girls coz of brad pitt whereas 300 has raw blood scenes. But personally i prefer 300. I agree that troy was a bit more realistic but 300 battle action was awesome...
1 person likes this
@arjun999 (1004)
• India
25 Mar 08
In troy you can feel for the persons fighting the battle. You can feel the battle as it is happening infront of you . You can just admire the skills of Achilles evading the big guy at the last second in the first scene. I liked troy much better than 300.
@saierchok (1294)
• United States
19 Jun 07
I loved the 300, it was great, the story, the directing, it's just so simple but very nice!!!
1 person likes this
• India
22 Jun 07
yeah !!! -- u pointed out right.....the direction of 300 was superb !!!!
• Indonesia
21 Jun 07
i think the best movie between those two is 300, in 300 there are more affect and the story is amazing and spectacular..
1 person likes this
@ackars (1942)
• India
20 Jun 07
I too like 300 more than troy.Infact watched the movie yesterday night also.Battles are too good and are more realistic in troy but are definitely good looking with the nice music used just like you said.
@soujirou (27)
• Philippines
20 Jun 07
i prefer 300 as well.they really portraid how strong the spartans during that time.all the 300 soldiers had the body worked out to show all their muscles just like how it has been that time.imagine how much discipline they have to achieve that.
1 person likes this
@secretbear (19463)
• Philippines
20 Jun 07
I prefer both. ^__^;; I loved the battle scenes in troy coz it really looked so real. plus i've watched thr making and I saw that brad pitt and the others really trained themselves and trained hard for that movie. I loved the battle scenes in 300 too. it was so intense and yeah, the background music was good too. it was like you can feel their emotions. it was morbid but in an artistic way. plus, I loved their abs. ^__^;;
1 person likes this
• Jamaica
19 Jun 07
i will have to definately say 300!!!!!!!!!! i love this movie
1 person likes this
@federickp (607)
• India
19 Jun 07
I think i like 300 fights more than troy, but i think troy fights were real as there was no interfering of computer graphics. But as far enjoyment is concerned i like 300 more. 300 is also of moral values and also troy. Both are war movies. As far as other film battles are concerned i think BEN HER has good fights, also Ten commandments was good.
@chiyosan (30196)
• Philippines
19 Jun 07
hmm.. i liked alexander's battles too... but i prefer troy actually. :)
1 person likes this
• United States
19 Jun 07
Those were both excellent movies. 300 had better battle scenes but I like the story line of Troy better. This probably has nothing to do with it but Saving Private Ryan was a pretty good WW2 battle scene.
1 person likes this
@besthope44 (12141)
• India
29 Aug 10
Well 300, its a excellent movie and i loved the graphics and story. Its beautifully done and extraordinary movie.
• India
2 Sep 08
i prefer 300 as 300 is an absolutely terrific movie. the attitude, the valour the spartans display send a chill down my spine. so much to keep their honour. they challenged and even demured a person who projected himself as god. i think they were bogged down by the wrong priests who just had no respect for these warriors. my personal favorite line in the movie when the king says : SPARTANS NEVER RETREAT!!!!!!!!!!. the greatest sequence when the king as a young lad fights the beast and also , when he kicks the intruder into the well..
@chiyosan (30196)
• Philippines
24 Mar 08
I have watched both these movies but you are absolutely correct tht Troy's battles were more realistic than 300. With this i choose Troy. I like its story more than 300 too. 300 was a great movie but i choose Troy. :)
• Czech Republic
21 Mar 08
300 is better
@RAANARON (194)
• India
10 Dec 07
ofcourse troy ....for bradd pitt....he was awesome in his role...
• Brazil
3 Jul 07
obviously 300 troy was amazing too but 300 its better the history is coolest ;]
@devdevil (90)
• India
28 Jun 07
i would pick 300 over troy simply due to the graphic scenes shown in the movie.. the movie just had a great deal of impact than what troy had made..