Universal Suffrage (Voting rights for every citizen). Is it good?

@eadward (140)
Brazil
June 19, 2007 9:36pm CST
I've been thinking, and I can't find a true good logical reason for anyone being able to vote. Should a welfare recipient, and unemployed teenager, an analphabet, or even a person who doesn't have a college degree, or doesn't earn much money from his or her job, be allowed to cast a vote on an ellection? Do their votes contribute to the well-being of their countries, or are they a manipulated mass keeping corrupt politicians in power?
2 people like this
3 responses
@Katagiri (426)
• Brazil
20 Jun 07
That's a tough one! You have a good point... do they really contribute? Can we take their rights as citizens? That's something to think about.
2 people like this
@judyt00 (3497)
• Canada
20 Jun 07
Anyone of legal age should be able to vote. that way, the whole country gets to choose the best candidates, not just the financially elite who generally have a different agenda then the poor and uneducated. if it wasn't for the poor and uneducated, you would still be forced to work 12 hours days for mere pennies and have absolutely no rights
1 person likes this
@Katagiri (426)
• Brazil
20 Jun 07
I got your point, but... here where we live, the poor sell their votes for food, dentures and other stuff. That's why we are discussing it. Do they really contribute if they only vote for who they're told to or for who gives them stuff? It's illegal but common, that's why it's hard to get those politicians.
1 person likes this
@Katagiri (426)
• Brazil
21 Jun 07
As I said... do we have rights to take the other's rights? How far they contribute? We have a big problem here.
1 person likes this
@gardengrrl (1445)
• United States
21 Jun 07
You can't imagine how relieved I was to check your profiles and see you are both not from the U.S.A.! It would bother me a lot if poor Americans were 'selling" their votes again, like they did during the Great Depression. Teenagers here don't get to vote until they're 18 years old, when they become legal adults. This seems to be a reasonable age for them to be given adult rights and responsibilities. A lot of them don't vote, though, which is sad. It bothers me that Americans take for granted a right that people in other countries have to fight and sometimes die for. Allowing all adults the right to vote is critical to a democracy's long-term survival. Without participation from all levels of society, politics will quickly become nothing more than a social outlet for the very rich. History tells us that this leads to revolution and mass bloodshed. Rather than deny voting rights to the poor and unemployed, it is far, far better to attack the social problems that cause such extreme poverty that people are willing to surrender their one chance to impact their government for a bit of money or something to eat. The poor WILL slip off the leash, it is only a question of when, and how? Brazil would be much better served if you can avoid the bloody revolution scenario. It would make your people an example for all nations to follow, if your society can figure out how to increase the free and informed participation of citizens at all levels, and increase individual freedom without going through a bloody civil war. Brazil is a beautiful country. I've alway been intrigued by the many similarities between Brazilian history and American. Both of our societies struggle with our history of slavery, and the racism that has come from it, and we also struggle with the proper place for the poor in today's society. I hope to be able to visit your wonderful land one day. Thank you for the interesting insight into one of the problems you folks are dealing with. Be well!
• United States
22 Jun 07
Thank you very much, I will! One other thing that has always intrigued me about Brazil is the language. I know it is because the first explorers were Portuguese rather than Spanish, but I still think it's cool that Brazil has kept the more relaxed, easy-going language as their own. Be well!
@Katagiri (426)
• Brazil
23 Jun 07
I'm glad you think like that! ^^
@Katagiri (426)
• Brazil
21 Jun 07
If you come here, make sure to tell us so we can show you around! Yes, as American Countries we have a lot of similarities , some good and some bad... Here, 16 years old kids can vote but can't be arrested and 14 years old children are stealing and killing. I hope, one day, our government sees that and reduces the criminal penalty age from 18 to at least 16 or 15.
1 person likes this