Religious blackmail
By speakeasy
@speakeasy (4171)
United States
June 25, 2007 4:42pm CST
Once again the Catholic church is trying to blackmail it's members.
In 2004, the Catholic church was trying to tell John Kerry that if he supported his non-Catholic constituents right to decide for themselves whether they should have an abortion or not; that he would not be permitted to take communion and risked excommunication.
Now, in 2007, the Catholic Church is once again threatening one of it's members, Guiliani, with this same threat. This time Pope Benedict XVI and the Vatican are backing the local bishops on this issue.
A Vatican spokesman has stated that "politicians who vote for abortion rights should exclude themselves from communion".
The Pope himself, when he recently talked about Mexico's vote on abortion rights, stated "Catholic legislators in Mexico who had recently voted to allow abortion had effectively excommunicated themselves from the church".
Politicians who have stated that they personally do not believe in abortion; but, will not deny others the right to decide this issue for themselves, should not be bullied or blackmailed by religious leaders.
We are supposed to have separation of church and state here in the US. Some foreign religious leader, who is not even the leader of the religion of the majority of people in our country, should have no right to blackmail his followers for doing their job (representing the people who elect them to office).
If the Catholic church wants to behave in this manner; then ALL Catholic churches in the US should forfeit their tax exempt status. If they want to involve themselves in American politics; let them pay the price.
Personally, any religion that has to bully and threaten their members earns no respect from me.
1 response
@Juanamomof5 (429)
• United States
25 Jun 07
Having grown up Catholic, I find it sad the the church acts this way. I don't go to the Catholic church because of this and other reasons. The churches should not have anything to do with polictics,but they are involve. If they were really seperated do you honestly think that abortion would be questioned.
@speakeasy (4171)
• United States
25 Jun 07
Actually, I do think that abortion would still be questioned if church and state were truly separated.
The reason is that so many individuals have so many different viewpoints on this topic. Some of the questions would still be; whether it should be allowed at all; whether the government should pay for it; what date should be the cutoff for deciding; under what conditions is it allowable or not permitted; etc.
Individuals have voices and opinions too. Speaking them and then trying to resolve differences is what good government is all about.

