So Who Really Killed Spencer
By stealthy
@stealthy (8181)
United States
June 26, 2007 11:23pm CST
I don't think Marty did it, but I think she saw it happen. So who could have killed him that seeing them do it would cause Marty to block it out and then when she started getting partial memories of it, think she had done it? Spencer when he turned around said "you?", so he knew them and was suprised. I'm sort of thinking it might be Miles, but I don't know why except that what he found Spencer doing caused him to do it. Spencer certainly would have had that suprised remark if it was Miles. But Marty probably wouldn't have blocked that out since she didn't know Miles then. So who do you think did it, Starr, Cole, Paige, ???
1 person likes this
1 response
@texasclassygal (5305)
• United States
27 Jun 07
I still think it was Asa that did it ... we know it was not Paige and it is definitely not Marty, although the jury is still out on Todd, which would have loved to do it, but since he is injuried in Chicago we will never know if he is even a suspect, which there seem to be so many.
1 person likes this
@stealthy (8181)
• United States
27 Jun 07
Was Paige totally ruled out, I don't remember? I thought Todd had been cleared. I thought of Asa and it is hard to say if he could have since he is supposed to be so sick; Phil Carey who plays Asa was very sick in real life and I was suprised when he looked as good as he did when he came back to the show, but I heard somewhere he is leaving the show (health?), so they may have him be the killer, but then he would never have intended to pay David for taking the blame. Again I come back to why would Marty suppress the memory unless it was someone who meant something to her? I can see her doing it over Paige or Starr but not Asa.
@stealthy (8181)
• United States
27 Jun 07
Well they really opened the suspect list up to almost anyone with the Marty knocked on the head memory today. Almost anyone except Starr who is not big enough to drag Marty off the on-call room and Asa who was not healthy enough besides which he would have waited for David to do it.
