Are You Getting The Best Medical Care?

United States
July 17, 2007 8:51pm CST
Have you heard the new report that the U.S. News & World Report has published a 2007 list of America's best hospitals? They are listed in the order they were chosen. In some cases there was a tie between two hospitals. In this case, both are listed one right after the other. 1. Johns Hopkins Hospital in Baltimore 2. Mayo Clinic in Rochester, Minn. 3. UCLA Medical Center in Los Angeles 4. Cleveland Clinic 5. Massachusetts General Hospital in Boston 6. New York-Presbyterian University Hospital of Columbia and Cornell in New York 7. Duke University Medical Center in Durham, N.C., and University of California, San Francisco Medical Center 8. Barnes-Jewish Hospital/Washington University in St. Louis 9. Brigham and Women's Hospital in Boston 10. University of Washington Medical Center in Seattle 11. Hospital of the University of Pennsylvania in Philadelphia 12. University of Pittsburgh Medical Center 13. University of Michigan Hospitals and Health Centers in Ann Arbor, Mich. 14. Stanford Hospital and Clinics in Stanford, Calif., and Yale-New Haven Hospital in New Haven, Conn. 15. Cedars-Sinai Medical Center in Los Angeles, and the University of Chicago Medical Center I am not surprised that John Hopkins Hospital in Baltimore is the number one hospital. It has a great reputation for having advanced medical technology as well as well educated staff. However, I have never been to any of the hospitals on the list. The hospital ranking was based on several different factors including hospital quality in the following 16 medical specialties: cancer, digestive disorders, ear-nose-throat (ENT), endocrinology, geriatrics, gynecology, heart, kidney disease, neurology/neurosurgery, ophthalmology, orthopedics, psychiatry, rehabilitation, respiratory disorders, rheumatology, and urology. U.S. News & World Report also sent surveys to more than 850,000 U.S. doctors, asking them to rank the top five hospitals in their specialty for difficult cases, regardless of location or expense. The rankings are also based on hospital death rates in Medicare patients with certain conditions, the number of patients and nurses, hospital credentials, and the availability of advanced medical technology. Are you surprised at the list? Do you use any of these hospitals? Do you feel that you get excellent care when you go to one of these hospitals verses a hospital that is not on the list?
3 people like this
9 responses
@AmbiePam (85314)
• United States
18 Jul 07
Well my doctor tried to get me into number 2, but the insurance wasn't having it. But I've been to number 8! Yeah me! I crossed states to get there too.
1 person likes this
• United States
18 Jul 07
My neorologist was sending me to John Hopkins. I filled out all the necessary paperwork and my Dr sent my records but that is as far as it got. They never even called me or made an appointment. I have no idea what happened. I imagine it was my insurance too. We have terrible insurance but at least we do have some. That is a bonus.
@AmbiePam (85314)
• United States
18 Jul 07
Before I was accepted to disability, my parents were paying for my medical care. If not for several churches within our denomination that knew my dad, my parents would have had been in deep financial debt. I had an HMO, and that was why I was denied the Mayo Clinic. They did sent me to Barnes, number eight, I cannot remember the full name. It was an improvement over my regular hospital because it was larger and had more specialties. And these people were investigators, they weren't playing around. The first thing they did was take 15 vials of my blood for various tests. Now that I am on disability, I don't even get that good of care, but I am so thankful I have the basics. But that is a reason to remember God. He has never let me down and I don't see that happening any time soon. Did your doctor ever follow up on why you never heard anything? Surely they would know how to get to the bottom of it? Not like you haven't already thought of all this. They couldn't possibly expect you to deal with all the logistics. I am very sorry to hear that didn't work out.
@_hope_ (3902)
• Australia
18 Jul 07
I do not live in America but John Hopkins is known world wide as a reputable hospital and leads the world you are licky to have such great facilities in your country .Where i live the services are limited and we need to travel 300km for better health care .To me that isn`t very good considering that i`m suppose to be living in the lucky country .lAST YEAR I TRAVELLED OVER 800KM FOR SURGERY TO BE DONE BECAUSE OF WHERE THE SURGERY WAS DONE THIS MAJOR CITY HOSPITAL WAS THE ONLY PLACE THE SURGEON WOULD DO IT
• United States
18 Jul 07
I am so sorry that better health care is not available for you at a closer area. I dont know how far 300km is but I imagine it must be quite a distance. I wish every country would have available health care. In our country we have it available if you have the money to pay for it. It is very expensive.
@dhouston (417)
• United States
18 Jul 07
1 km = 5/8 mile; do the math Yes, it's a long way. I see Hope's in Australia, so it urprises me that she has this problem.
@kgwat70 (13388)
• United States
19 Jul 07
Fortunately I have not had any serious medical conditions where I have needed a hospital on this list. If I do have serious problems, I will probably go to Penn in Philly or the one in Baltimore since they are closer. I am not surprised at all by the list as they are all good hospitals. I think they have the more advanced technology plus have the better doctors and nurses.
@KrisNY (7590)
• United States
19 Jul 07
Great- Nope I don’t go to any of the above hospitals- I’m not close enough to go to them- I think size also matters on choosing the best hospital- We have 3 hospitals in the area- All 3 specialize in different areas- Cancer- Strong- etc. I wonder if the patients rank these as the best hospitals also.
@carpenter5 (6782)
• United States
18 Jul 07
My husband used to work for the University of Arkansas for Medical Science. They make some kind of list every year that lists the top 10 hospitals in each field, usually in several specialties. But, I will not go to their emergency room. Because, they are the only level one trauma center in our state, and the wait times for lesser emergencies, is sometimes hours.
@collstarx (1177)
• Indonesia
18 Jul 07
Yes, We must get the best for aou health, because health very important than money. best regards
@Willowlady (10658)
• United States
18 Jul 07
No one seems to question why we need all these hospitals. hmmmm The Cleveland Clinic is number 4 and one that is near me. There have been news stories about sultans and such coming here to the Cleveland Clinic for treatment. So it must be good. It is said that you can tell how healthy a city is by the size and number of hospitals in the town. We don't go to a a clinic or hospital unless it is unavoidable.
@dhouston (417)
• United States
18 Jul 07
Philadelphia is one of our nation's medical capitals given the number of hospitals and medical schools. The hospitals range from internationally renouwned major research institutions to little community hospitals in small neighborhoods. Major pharmaceutical firms are headquartered here. One of our hospitals is Pennsylvania Hospital, the first ever in the entirety of North and South America. It was founded by Benjamin Rush, a friend of Benjamin Franklin and the other Founding Fathers. HUP, as we call the Hospital of the University of Pennsylvania (the university itself was founded by Benjamin Franklin), is on your list, and is certainly a great hospital. (However, there are also "stories" about it that would make you want to go elsewhere.) Locally, however, we consider it the second hospital; Pennsylvania Hospital is the first. (Note that while the names seem similar to outsiders, they are totally different. Pennsy is at 8th and Spruce in the very old Society Hill section of the city, one of the first areas inhabited after the city was founded by William Penn in 1682, and HUP is at 34th and Spruce, not downtown but in West Philadelphia, in the area known as University City since both Penn and Drexel are there.) Almost 30 years ago, my late DH became gravely ill at work and was taken to a nearby community hospital that had a contract with his employer; he was there nearly 3 weeks. He had some serious problems during this time. He was a deacon and well loved and respected at our large downtown church. Numerous doctors were members, including a dear friend who was in our wedding and we in theirs. Another member was a man who later became US Surgeon General. Both visited him during his hospitalization and expressed concern aboout the hospital. Both wanted him to switch to Pennsy when he could. The future surgeon general waited until he was released so as not to cause problems mid-treatment, then gave him the name of a specialist at Pennsy he'd called about my DH and who was willing to include him on his patient list He was a nationally known specialist. As a result of the switch, my DH's future treatments were at Pennsy and he did very well, outliving expectations by more than 10 years That is still the hospital where my doctor is a member. DH got excellent treatment there many times. I have never been hospitalizd, but my doctor is outstanding. And there are no "stories" about Pennsy going around the city. Everybody seems to be very happy.
@maddysmommy (16230)
• United States
18 Jul 07
I have not used any of these hospitals before since I have only be in USA for almost a year now and have no reason to so far. I'll remember the one in Baltimore though as its not too far from where we live (we couple of hours drive but still, its nice to know its one of the best!)