to be or not to be........ dad

United States
July 22, 2007 11:29pm CST
As you all know I recently got married, and I need to know how to, or even if I should ask the children if they want to call their stepdad dad or by his name like they always have. I am not sure if they would or not but I want them to be able to make their own decision aout it. I have two children ages 5 and 6 they are both boys and they love their stepdad to death. They really have told me that they don't particularly care for their real dad anymore because their stepdad treats them better. I have not let them stop going to their dads because they do not have the right to cut him out yet, according to the courts they are not old enough yet. So when they are by the courts old enough i sure will let them decide. This is my second marriage, and I am unsure how to approach my children about this issue.. Anyone know how to do this? Have you had any experience with this? How did it go?
2 people like this
4 responses
@butterfly39 (3904)
• Philippines
23 Jul 07
Well for me it would be nice if they will call him dad too...
2 people like this
• United States
23 Jul 07
I think he would like that, but I would like for them to decide.. thank you for posting.. I will not make them do anything that they do not want to do.
1 person likes this
• United States
23 Jul 07
I encountered a similiar situation when I married my husband. The difference is that my son's birth father was long since out of the picture. So, I didn't really know what to do. Matt(my son)started out knowing my husband as just Chris from our years of friendship. As he got used to our marriage, on a rare occassion he will call him Dad, but otherwise he just calls him Chris. I would let the kids make the final decision once they are old enough. I would talk with them and explain that they have a "DAD", but they are welcome to love their stepdad just as much if not more. And if they want to call him Dad, too, I guess that ok's, but might I suggest that they call him something like Papa and whatever his name is...it sounds silly, but they may want to use a slightly different version for him. That way, their birth father won't get "upset", not that he really has the right to, but I know it always upset Matt's birth father that someone else might be raising his son...but that's a whole other topic. I always told Matt that he could call my husband whatever he wanted to, as long as it was something nice:) Just go slow. Eventually, they'll do what the are comfortable with. Hope that helps! Good Luck and don't worry.
1 person likes this
• United States
24 Jul 07
Yes it does help. My friend that was remarried about 6 months ago has a daughter from a previous marriage and she calls her step father daddy james, so I had actually thought about this before, so I was just really wondering if I should approach them or just let them decide. Thank you for posting and blessed be
• Canada
23 Jul 07
I have a step-father named David (Dave) and a step-mother named Barbara (Barb) and I call them Dave and Barb. I have a Mom and I have a Dad, and I will not call their new spouces Mom and Dad. I would not do that even if one of my parents had passed on, because Barb and Dave are not my parents.
1 person likes this
• United States
24 Jul 07
See that is your choice, all I am doing is trying to give my kids the same choice. Thank you for posting and I respect that.
• United States
23 Jul 07
When I was young I called my step dad dad. But as soon as I grow up I now he was roy becoase he was not really a dad at all. I think that no matter what you want the child to call him the child will make up in there minds weathere they are a real dad or not. So its up to your new husband if he really wants to be a good dad the child will see that and see him is a loving dad. Hope this helps
• United States
24 Jul 07
Thank you for posting, and it does help a little. My youngest has already called him dad but he was at his fathers house when he did it and I am sure that his dad whipped him for it. I don't think it is right if he were to remarry I would let them choose what to call her, and the only way I would be upset is if they started calling me by my first name.