if you were in my place, would you be honest about it?

Philippines
July 25, 2007 1:45am CST
months ago, i deposited P500 in my banco de oro card. but then when i checked my balance, it was P5,000! it's been, like, 6 months now. i never touched the money. i don't know what to do about it. should i just tell the bank that they made a mistake? or should i just keep it with me and let the rest take care of this mistake? i'm tempted to use to money already..
8 responses
@ryanphil01 (4182)
• Philippines
25 Jul 07
Well, honesty pays. It is worth your while to tell the truth, to report that there was a mistake in your account, and not to cheat or deceive. I remember the story of Abraham Lincoln who was said to walk back several miles to a store when he noticed he had been given one penny too much in change. That was a sense of being honest and not taking what doesn't belong to you. He probably received thanks from the store owner because of what he did. By telling the truth, you can at least hold your head up high that you did the right thing. It is a feeling you have about yourself. It is a feeling of pride and self-worth and character. Isn't that nice? Who knows the bank will thank you and give you rewards for your honesty? But of course, it isn't the reward that is important. Rather feel good about yourself for your own honesty. That is what counts.
1 person likes this
• Philippines
26 Jul 07
yeah, i get you.. anyway, i did not have to do anything. i neither lied nor told the truth. when i checked my card, the last zero of the p5000 has been removed. it's back to p500. but you know what? i felt good about it. but you have a point. honesty is the best policy.. always has, always will be. :) thanks!
• Philippines
27 Jul 07
thanks, too.. hehe.. :) God bless!
• Philippines
26 Jul 07
'twas your good intention and good heart that would have paved the way for the bank to see their mistake even without telling them. accept my deepest appreciation for the compliment.
1 person likes this
@Carmenn (23)
• United States
25 Jul 07
Do not be honest. Listen. You deposited this money 6 months ago. You haven't touched it since. You honestly don't remember how you got that much money, but you assume that it was because you worked hard and saved money. After all, you don't check your balance every day. In fact. Your plan was to just put money away every week and see how much you could save over the course of a year. its been 6 months. I think even if they did finally realize it, which they won't, you could still get away with it by playing dumb.
1 person likes this
• Philippines
27 Jul 07
haha.. a bit sly, yes. have you ever gotten away with a situation like that?
• United States
31 Jul 07
I've gotten an extra $20 and gotten away with it. It's not your fault if they made a mistake, only if you knowingly tried to hide their mistake. you simply thought you had saved it. stick to your story. they cant prove you lied.
@ssh123 (31073)
• India
25 Jul 07
First degree of honesty, one should inform the bankers about the discrepency. Even if you do not inform, the account gets corrected when try to detect where the extra amount (which is shortage for their account) has gone. It is a great pride and honour to inform the bank rather than waiting for them to detect it.
1 person likes this
@wisconsin26 (3859)
• United States
25 Jul 07
They made a mistake and they will soon find it and withdraw it from your account sooner or later.. I would be honest about it.. Things like that have happened to my accounts too and I don't believe in keeping something that isn't mine.. Just my oppion!
1 person likes this
• Philippines
25 Jul 07
true.. thanks a lot.
@maddysmommy (16230)
• United States
25 Jul 07
Sure i would. I would question anything to do with my bank account. I would feel sorry for the owner of the money if it was sitting in my account. If its a mistake on the banks behalf, i would let them know.
1 person likes this
• Philippines
27 Jul 07
wow. i admire you so much. thanks for sharing your thoughts.
@slowsin (41)
• Italy
25 Jul 07
hello I think it's better for you to be honest because if the bank has made a mistake they find it out soon and will correct it
1 person likes this
• Philippines
26 Jul 07
they did. i'm glad i didn't touch the money... or i'll be doomed. :) thanks
• Thailand
25 Jul 07
tell the higher positioned personnel and negotiate with them. Chances are you can keep the money and be silent to the public. Honest will in any positive situations be good. The bank have to pay for their mistakes. This can be a serious mistake if the bank did not find it and solve it before you notice them. Zero is nothing when being alone, but big thing when 7 or more digits in front of it.
• India
1 Aug 07
You should tell to bank that you made a mistake. It is better to tell before to get worst.