Is Christianity polytheistic religion?
By alnilam
@alnilam (969)
United States
August 13, 2007 4:56pm CST
I have read a comparison on Koran and the Bible and I have noticed that God in the Bible refers himself in plural (god in Koran in singular) and also the Jesus in the Bible is the son of God and in the Koran just an ordinary prophet. And there is also the issue on the holly ghost and angels and stuff. So in Christianity there are more than one divine beings. That makes it a polytheistic religion, right?
4 people like this
6 responses
@Daelin (683)
• Brazil
14 Aug 07
I don't think so. In a polytheist religion there are many gods with different powers and origin. They usually don't communicate and when they do there isn't peace between them.
In Christianity there is only one God. He had a son, Jesus, who came to the Earth to speak in the name of God.
The angels would be only the messengers, the holy ghost is not a God himself, it is the spirit of Jesus.
When Christians pray they pray to God or Jesus in the name of God.
1 person likes this

@applecartronnie (1984)
• India
13 Aug 07
amazing discussion. i was just listning to somthing very similar today. there is this site. www.lightuponlight.com and this guy called yusuf estes says something similar about what you have started. you will find his downloadable video there. watch them they are all marvelous.
sensible, all the best ever, always here, apple.
1 person likes this
@applecartronnie (1984)
• India
13 Aug 07
also reading the Quaran is the best knowledge gained by one's self, 1st hand.
apple.
1 person likes this
@alnilam (969)
• United States
13 Aug 07
well do not know if it really is the best :D but it is OK. i think a lot of people are not aware that this book offers god morals (and is very similar to bible--although I did not read neither of them in whole, some fragments and a summary, lazy lazy-----but will finish reading them soon now--common knowledge and stuff)... because they connect Islam to bad things only...

@rogue13xmen13 (14402)
• United States
14 Aug 07
Actually, it kind of is. See, by Christians believing in the Holy Trinity (God the father, Jesus the son, and the Holy Spirit), Mary, Joseph, the angels, and the saints, that means that it is polytheistic. On the other hand, most Christians will argue with me by saying that they only worship Jesus and pray to Jesus, but that is not always the case.
1 person likes this
@kamran12 (5526)
• Pakistan
14 Aug 07
Hello alnilam!:-)
I shall not go much into detail but I would like to clear some points here, so that the perspective is very clear.
GOD does refers HIMSELF as plural, not only in Bible but also in Quran (Koran), Torah, Talmud etc. You will find plural pronouns not only for GOD but also for some other. Like, in Quran, there are several verses to this fact, for example, "We have descended this scripture and we are it's protector." We can see that a plural pronoun is used here, but there is a consensus that it is just in linguistic reverence terms rather than factual. Thus whenever a direct noun is used for GOD, Quran (Koran) always refer to it as a singular, which is peculiarity of Quran compared to Bible.
Muslims are the purest monotheistic religion. Not only Christians have a concept of "son of GOD" but also many Jews believe "Uzair" to be "son of GOD". In Islam, GOD is/can never be in human shape, form, attribute; HE is free from any human traits or attributes. But, let me also clear here that some muslim denominations have also over stepped on this concept. They believe "Ali" (cousin and son in law of Muhammad) to be God, though they are banished by their fellow believers.
Second point that I would like to address is that 'Jesus' is not just an ordinary Prophet in Islam or Quran. Quran, though speak of high respect for all Prophets and that belief in each of them is compulsory, yet there are categories and separate terms for Prophets depending upon their level of activity and function in divine system of guidance.
Some are called just 'Nabi', whose function is to just call people to righteousness as commanded by GOD. 'Nabis' had duties limited to just their family, some to extended family and some others to a little wider extent. Others are called 'Rasul', the messengers, whose function is wider and not only to receive the message through 'Gabriel' and deliver guidance but they are also given a script. Then there are 'Ulul Azm Rasul', whose function was much wider and they received 'Holy Books'. These 'Ulul Azm Rasul' (highly regarded messengers) are only five, namely Noah, Abraham, Moses, Jesus and Muhammad. So, 'Jesus' is not just an ordinary Prophet but has a special value and regard in Islam as well as in Quran.
I hope it clears some issues here!:-)
1 person likes this


@pyewacket (43903)
• United States
13 Aug 07
You might be opening a can of worms here...LOL... While I'm not Christian myself, though I haven't abandoned my Christian upbringing, it always did strike me that Christianity, especially Catholicism is polytheistic--Yes you have the belief in one God, but many Christians of course believe in Christ, and then there is the Virgin Mary..and then....all those saints!! And each saint usually represents some aspect--like St. Jude, usually considered the patron saint of lost causes..so this is almost like the equivalent of the ancient Gods and Goddesses of pagan times where they too represented some quality
1 person likes this
@Daelin (683)
• Brazil
14 Aug 07
The role of the saints is to be a messenger who will speak to God in your behalf. Like a lawyer.
They are not Gods. There is only one God in Christianity. This kind of doubt comes usually from people who are not Christian because they see only some aspects of this religion.
1 person likes this







