Dieting
By worldwise1
@worldwise1 (14885)
United States
September 3, 2007 7:01pm CST
I was just thinking about the misery we go through when dieting. I feel that the fact that you have to deny yourself certain foods is directly related to the bad rap that diets get. I mean, no one can feel upbeat when they know their choices of food is limited to unappealing bland stuff. That is why I have decided not to forego anything that I really want badly even when I am on a diet. I believe that you feel so great when you have had something that you really want, that it is not such a big sacrifice to continue your diet once you've had that special something. Agree or disagree?
8 people like this
12 responses
@Shaun72 (15959)
• Palatka, Florida
4 Sep 07
I agree I mean you can start back on your diet after you have failed. I am on a low starch diet. Once I mess up like tonight I had some chex mex tommorrow. I will go back to getting just meat,vegtables and fruits.
@laydee (12798)
• Philippines
4 Sep 07
I agree. There are many forms of diet. Some think that in order to lose all that fat, they need to skip a meal or stop eating.
It's actually wrong to stop eating because as humans we 'crave' for this things.
I agree with you naty because the best way for one to be on a diet is to eat 'little' portions of the food but not to starve yourself or restrict yourself from eating them.
As per my doctor recommends. Small portions and eating these portions more times a day is still better with skipping meals and eating one meal with everything on it.
Here's a part of an article that I'd like to quote:
Problems with Restrictive Dieting
When you restrict calories too low in an effort to lose weight very quickly, several negative
things happen that can be disastrous to your weight, health, academic success, and social life:
? Your metabolism slows down. Your body slows down in order to adapt to the lower calorie
intake (so it can function with less fuel). And, it actually begins holding on to every calorie
you eat and storing it as fat (since it’s not sure you will feed it later). This is why people who
diet, usually gain back their weight (and then some!) once they start eating normally again.
? When you cut calories too low, you lose mostly water and muscle, not fat. Without enough
calories and protein from food, your body starts breaking down its own muscle protein for
fuel. When you lose muscle, you slow your metabolism down even more!
? Poor concentration, and low energy. After all, your brain, other vital organs, and muscles are
deprived of fuel.
? Terrible mood. Starvation often results in increased depression and irritability.
? Food preoccupation. Your body is starving so your thoughts become consumed with food.
? Increased risk for binge eating. Your body wants to hoard as much food as possible in case
it’s forced to starve again.
? Rapid weight regain, usually in the form of fat.
Source:
http://209.85.165.104/search?q=cache:xQMJ7p3_digJ:www.snac.ucla.edu/pages/Resources/Handouts/HODodietswork.pdf+do+diets+work%3F&hl=en&ct=clnk&cd=1&gl=ph&client=firefox-a
@sigma77 (5383)
• United States
4 Sep 07
I think you can still eat a lot of things you love. I have been able to lose over 20 pounds over the last 9 months just cutting out excess snacking, adding some exercise and reducing portions. I think most diets are a waste of time. It is a long term proposition and life choice. You don't need to crash diet, just maintain a steady routine to get to your desired weight whether it takes a few months or a few years. And I think a few treats here and there can help.
@samtaylorskykierajen (7976)
• Canada
4 Sep 07
I agree with this !! Just because one is on a diet doesn't mean they should have to restrict themselves completely from everything they love and if eaten in moderation it shouldn't matter a bit . More often then not when one goes on a diet they lose the weight only to put it right back on again as soon as they start eating the way they always did and then are more depressed that they were not able to take the weight off . If one eats in moderation and can maintain a healthy diet , then the weight that is lost should stay off and eventually one will either lose the weight or won't but as long as they are happy with themselves , that is all that truely matters .
@recycledgoth (9894)
•
4 Sep 07
To be honest I have completely given up on diets and dieting, they made me miserable and depressed. Now i enjoy life and my food, the only concession is to have smaller amounts of food on the plate.
@anniepa (27955)
• United States
4 Sep 07
I couldn't agree more! I've had the good fortune to be able to eat what I please for years because I was a mail carrier and I walked for 8-9 hours a day. Now that I'm not doing it anymore, all of a sudden it's catching up with me and I've put on some weight. I'm sure not doctor or dietitian but it seems to me "moderation" is the key and trying to get some exercise. I've been trying to allow myself to eat my favorite junk food on certain days and to promise myself to eat "healthy" the rest of the week. It's definitely no good to deny yourself the foods you really love!
Annie
@laydee (12798)
• Philippines
4 Sep 07
Yeah, I agree. It's the movement that keeps one lean and healthy. It's not only what we eat. Regardless of how much we don't eat, if we just sit and do nothing all day, nothing will ever happen.
I have a friend who started to go dieting. While I, on the other hand, didn't really go for the diet too much but am going to the gym everyday. Well, at this point in time, she lost some weight, but she looked haggard and had flabby looking figure, while I look refreshed and tight. Well, same with you, because of the walking, it gave you the freedom to eat anything, but of course, in moderation.
Here's a part of an article I have also read about the topic:
When you diet, your body goes into “starvation mode” and holds onto the calories you do consume as fat for energy stores. So while you are trying to lose fat, your body is holding onto it for the fuel it needs to carry out normal daily activities and body functions. Also, your body begins to break down muscle for fuel. Muscle is metabolically active and burns calories and fat to maintain itself even at rest. It plays a key role in metabolism and decreased muscle mass leads to decreased metabolism of fat and calories. Again, this actually makes it harder for you to shed that weight you are trying so hard to lose while dieting!
Restrictive eating can also lead to decreased concentration, poor judgment, irritability, low energy, depression, hair loss, and changes in liver function. Also, studies have shown that 90% of people gain back the weight they lose (and then some!) within five years. Most people want to lose weight quickly, but if this is done, the body loses muscle instead of fat and once normal eating habits are resumed the weight is regained as fat and you end up with a higher percentage of body fat than before you started dieting. This makes it even harder to lose weight if you attempt dieting again.
Some more tips:
* Start your day with a healthy breakfast to kick start your body’s metabolism
* Eat in a healthy and non-restrictive manner. If energy intake is too low or important food groups are omitted, your body may not be getting the nutrients it needs.
* Set realistic goals and break long-term goals into short-term goals and you will feel a sense of accomplishment.
* Drink at least 8 cups of water a day as thirst can often be mistaken for hunger.
* Indulge in treats you like, but in moderation. Depriving yourself of the foods you like can lead to binge eating.
* Contact a health care professional, such as your physician or a dietician, before beginning any major diet.
* Throw away the scale! If you are eating a balanced diet and engaging in regular physical activity you may notice your clothes getting loser but your weight going up as you gain more muscle mass. The scale can be misleading and discouraging.
* Remember that you have a unique and natural size, shape, and personality and your self-esteem depends on accepting yourself as you are!
Source:
http://www.mcmaster.ca/health/hwc/Student%20Writers/do_diets_work.htm
@vega83 (6340)
• Bahrain
4 Sep 07
I like to think of myself as anti-diet. Of course that doesn't mean that I would binge on fast food the whole time, even though that might happen sometimes. But I totally believe that when it comes to losing weight, eliminating something completely from your diet might get you your desired weight, but it makes it all the harder to maintain that always. After all, how long can you diet for? Not forever. There are whole classes of food, carbohydrates, protein, fat, vitamin etc. and they are all meant for something and are all needed to sustain a healthy diet. That is healthy according to me, not freaking out that you had some white bread, ha ha.
I actually went on this seven day diet, that was interesting once. It was fruits the first day, vegetables the next and so on, of course you had to feel full and not starve yourself. Let's just say, I got to the third day and puked my guts out. I need my carbs and my meat, ha ha.
According to me, people should concentrate more on an active lifestyle and incorporate exercising into their lifestyle and I'm sure people will say they don't have time, but 10 minutes a day is all you need and everyone has that. It's healthier to concentrate on working out than obsessing about food or dieting or depriving yourself of a certain food.
@pyewacket (43903)
• United States
4 Sep 07
My mother was never a happy woman...all her life she was, well, shall we say, fluffy?? LOL She went on one crazy diet after another after another..don't ask..the water diet, the grapefruit diet, the broccoli diet--whatever fad diet was around she'd be on it...she even went to a diet doc who gave her glorified amphetamines...that was back in the days when no one realized how dangerous and addictive they were. I was the complete opposite of her...rail thin..took after my father's side of the family and one time my mom took me to the doc to get medicine to gain weight...think she was teed off at me that I didn't gain weight--LOL. At various times though, I have gained a significant amount of weight...but then I was just plain eating all wrong...Three BIG meals a day, plus a lot of snacks in between...I found the best way for me to lose weight was to cut back and not eat so much...I do nibble all day/night long but not large portions...I don't deny myself anything to eat, but there are just some foods I don't eat or drink any longer and haven't missed them...like sodas..they're out...high fried and fatty foods..they're out...and I just don't miss them. Giving up some really favorite food however, is never the answer..as sometimes it only makes you crave it all the more and then when you do have it you virtually pig out on it...LOL
@Feona1962 (7526)
• United States
4 Sep 07
I know when I was on diets, I hated having to be told that I couldn't have certain foods. If I wanted them, I ate them. I do believe it takes 3500 calories to gain a single pound. 3500 calories is alot of calories...I don't eat anywhere near that now. I am lucky I get in about 500 calories a day. You can get right back to dieting even if you eat something you are not "supposed" to have..
@Malyck (3425)
• Australia
4 Sep 07
I hate the whole idea of dieting, personally.
I believe in a balanced meal and balanced exercise, and it's always worked for myself and my friends.
As a matter of fact, I seem to lose more weight/look & feel better and more in shape when I allow myself the foods I want to eat as a reward for my good health and fitness =]
I believe very strongly in our own attitudes having a very real affect on our lives and happiness - if one feels that a diet isn't working, or isn't for them, I think they can actually limit its effects (if it has any at all =P)
I've never dieted and never will, if it means that I have to give up things I enjoy simply to look 'better' =D
Great post.
@khazeemee (288)
• Philippines
4 Sep 07
eat moderately and healthy food, that's the best way to have healthy lifestyle and body!













