A mother who left her 5 small children. . . ..

children - happy children
Philippines
September 14, 2007 8:09am CST
I have a friend who is a mother of 5 small children. Recently, she and her husband had a fight. Because of that fight she did not go home one night. She left the house leaving behind her youngest son who is only 5 months old. and the eldest is only 8 years old. If you are in your right senses for sure you won't leave 5 small children. What are the possible instances/reasons if ever you'll leave behind your children?
8 people like this
34 responses
@sunshine4 (8703)
• United States
14 Sep 07
Hi dorisday~ I have no idea what would ever posess a mother to leave her children. There is a friend of ours in my town who did the same thing. She left her husband and children for a boyfriend. We can't understand it. I can see leaving your husband, but I would never leave my children.
1 person likes this
@sunshine4 (8703)
• United States
16 Sep 07
I don't think that her children will ever forgive her for leaving them either.
• Philippines
20 Sep 07
The eldest has hurt feelings sometimes. But the younger ones don't know anything about it yet. I just hope the eldest will forget about it. It would be more difficult more the mother if her child will not forgive her for what she did.
• Philippines
14 Sep 07
Hi sunshine4! I agree with you. I can imagine leaving a husband but not children. Before she left, i already advised her not to leave her children but still she did. if I'm the husband I can't forgive her for what she did.
1 person likes this
• United States
14 Sep 07
My partner and I have actually had a huge argument over this topic. I was upset and (foolishly) stated that WE (our son, my son, and myself) were leaving. He got highly upset! If it came down to it I would take my kids with me. Who's going to watch our son while he works? The only way I would even think about leaving him behind is if I had no way to pay for necessities. I know my partner is perfectly capable of taking care of him. Of course it would hurt me to no end to not have him with me though.
• United States
16 Sep 07
I'm not going anywhere. I was just upset and opened my big mouth without thinking. Actually things are better between us as I don't get to see him much now due to his new job. I miss him really bad, don't get me wrong. God bless you too hun!
• Philippines
20 Sep 07
That's better. As the saying goes, absence makes the heart go fonder. That's why you miss him. Good luck and have a happy life.
• Philippines
16 Sep 07
Hi there! Better not think about leaving. A happy family stays together. I just hope things will always be alright. God bless!
• Malaysia
20 Sep 07
To me I wouldn't blame the woman. She must have a severe heartbroken that's why she left the house without giving a second thought on her children. Why didn't the husband blamed for not taking care of the children? I don't think the woman should be given more pressure by blaming all the things on her shoulder. Forgive me, but this is only my opinion. I don't agree if during a fight the wife is blamed for not taking care of the children. When the first fault of the fight is surely comes from the husband who is in most cases being irresponsible. I would very like to give the responsibility to the husband and blame him if he left the house with five kids. See how about that.
1 person likes this
• Philippines
21 Sep 07
I always tell my friend that whether she's at fault or not, she will always be blamed. Wives are always being blamed for the break-up of the family. I don't understand why! Even if it is obviously the husband who started messing up, the poor wife is being blamed for everything.
1 person likes this
@slickcut (8141)
• United States
14 Sep 07
She is teaching her husband a lesson,thats why she did it...He probably was telling her she did not do enough or he was not appreciating her,so she took off and left the kids with him,to teach him how much she does around the house..I am sure she will be back,in fact he will probably be hunting her down wanting her to come back home...You can be sure he will be sorry for whatever he did,and he with learn a lesson about how he talks to her.It gives a man a good lesson to leave him the full responsibity of 5 children..She is letting him get a good taste of how it is to care for 5 small children...
• Philippines
14 Sep 07
You're right! According to my friend, she is teaching her husband a lesson. But I still don't agree. Why would she let her children suffer and take the consequences of their marital fight? At least she is back.
1 person likes this
• United States
15 Sep 07
If it was only one night then I think they're fine. I don't see anything wrong with a woman taking a break and from the sounds of it she really needed one. :)
• Philippines
20 Sep 07
The break was not in the right time I guess. I know she really needs that precious "break" but she should have waited till morning comes. Our husbands don't realize that we also need take a "day off" from our children. But it should be done at the right time. and that's when there are other people who are present to take care of our children.
@mamasan34 (6518)
• United States
15 Sep 07
We don't really know the whole story with this situation. Quite obviously she was so upset that she left him with the kids. It is not like she left the kids alone to fend for themselves. Maybe she wanted to give him an idea of how it is to be alone with 5 kids and no break. No one knows why she left for the night. Sometimes people come to a breaking point and need that few hours to clear their heads before they make a decision that will affect their family. I can't make a judgment on this woman, that is not my job to do, I just hope that her husband and she have made amends and are doing better.
1 person likes this
@mamasan34 (6518)
• United States
17 Sep 07
that is a shame to come to that point. I really hope that she and her husband can come to some type of mutual terms that they will both be happy.
1 person likes this
• Philippines
16 Sep 07
I guess she reached that point where she can no longer to decide what is good and what is bad.They are still not in good terms. But she back home. I just pray things will be alright.
2 people like this
@kitty1234 (1476)
• United States
14 Sep 07
For me there would never be a reason to leave children. but you did not mention if the father was a t home with them. If she left them alone, there is no excuse, but if dad was home she knew they were being taken care of. But if I left the bundles of joy would be right by my side. she probably needed some time to cool off!
• Philippines
20 Sep 07
Precisely! That was the worst part. She should have not left the house until after she was sure her husband was home. What if the husband didn't come home that night? Poor little children! They will be left alone.
• Philippines
14 Sep 07
Hi kitty1234! The father came home late that night! She went out to look for her husband and when she found out that he was drinking, she never went home. it's still different if the children are being taken cared of by the mother.
1 person likes this
@lilybug (21107)
• United States
15 Sep 07
If he was out drinking then it was even worse that she did not go home that night. How did she know that he would come home? She could have left her kids home alone for the whole night.
@magikrose (5429)
• United States
14 Sep 07
There is NEVER a reason to leave 5 small children at home alone like that. I am a mom of 4 and the only of my 4 I would leave at home is my 12yr old and it would only be long enough to do a short pick up at the store. The max I would leave him home alone is 1hour and not a minute more. As far as for my younger kids NO WAY will I leave them home alone at all. Either I bringthem with me or I dont go out at all.
1 person likes this
• Philippines
14 Sep 07
You're correct! I can't figure out what valid reason she has to leave her 5 small children. If I can't leave 1 child, how can I leave 5 children? Isn't she being irresponsible?
1 person likes this
@cutepenguin (6431)
• Canada
14 Sep 07
To me it kind of depends - I mean, obviously I couldn't imagine abandoning my children, but leaving them with my husband for one night would not be too big of a deal. Leaving them home alone would never happen. But I could envision leaving the kids with my husband for a night or at least a couple of hours. I don't think this is how I'd respond, though. If it was because he wasn't respecting my contributions to the household, I might. But otherwise, if it was over something else, I'd probably ask him to sleep on the couch or something. My husband doesn't think I'd even leave him with the kids, much less a babysitter or leaving the kids by themselves.
1 person likes this
• Philippines
20 Sep 07
Great. We have the responsibility to take care of our children. It's part of our instinct to protect our children. We can leave our husbands but not our children. God bless.
@mgmagana (3618)
• United States
14 Sep 07
never! i would never leave my kids unless they were with someone who would take good care of them and i knew i could come back for them!
1 person likes this
• Philippines
14 Sep 07
Hi mgmagana! you're right. Mother's instict. Never leave our children. I don't why some mothers dare to leave their children.
1 person likes this
• India
16 Sep 07
I think the mother did the right thing so that his husband could realize how much he is in need of her.But my doubt is how could she stay outside without seeing her own kids..
1 person likes this
• Philippines
16 Sep 07
She was so upset when she left. That's why she did not go home that night. She was literally very angry with her husband to the point that she forgot her responsibilities to her children. Too bad, the children are the ones suffering.
1 person likes this
@maximax8 (31053)
• United Kingdom
14 Sep 07
The lady must have had a really bad fight with her husband. If he hit her she did right to leave but she should have taken her children. A better way of doing things would have been to get him to go. I think that 8 year old must have been very sad. However he or she is at least old enough to walk and talk. A 5 month old baby is totally dependent on his parents. I guess that his dad is really finding it difficult to look after 5 children without his wife around. If something terrible happened to my house I think I would take my children and myself to move into my sister's house for a while. If was was being hit by my partner I would contact the police. I would not ever leave my children behind.
1 person likes this
• Philippines
15 Sep 07
No, he didin't hit her. She just over reacted. She was too jealous, I guess. Something must be wrong with her that time.
@Gemmygirl1 (2867)
• Australia
18 Sep 07
I don't think she did the right thing, HOWEVER, if she left the children in the care of the father, then it's not as bad as everyone on here makes it out to be. A break from the kids (especially that many) is ok - i think she probably just needed a little space & since he's the father, he should be more than capable of doing what she does. Someone said she was teaching him a lesson & i wonder - did it work? Honestly, it's not so bad, there was an adult there to take care of the kids, it's not like she left them alone, it's also not like she dumped them & ran - never to return, it was only 1 night. Hopefully he's learnt his lesson & has a little more respect for her & all the things she does for her family! Might make him think a little about how he treats his wife & kids. :) Good on her for having the guts to do it, i don't think i could ever do it myself!
• Philippines
18 Sep 07
Thanks for responding. What happened was really very sad for those who care them, especially their children. i still talk to my friend and keep on reminding her not to do that again. Hope she would listen to my advice. I pity the children. . .
@tantal25 (838)
• United States
14 Sep 07
what a shallow reason for a mother to leave her children. its really not right. And even if that would happen to me, despite what happen between me and my husband and what ever may happen, i will never ever leave my children behind. I will stay by their side.
1 person likes this
• Philippines
15 Sep 07
Really very shallow! You're absolutely right.Your children should be your main concern. Forget about your problem as husband and wife but never forget your responsibilities to your children. God bless.
@laurika (4532)
• United States
14 Sep 07
It is really sad when mother leave the children and hard to figure it out why somebody would do that.But now on the news we can watch so many stories about mothers killing their child and hide them in the house.It s sad what all is society able to do.
1 person likes this
• Philippines
15 Sep 07
Hi Laurika! I don't dare to see those stories in the television because it breaks my heart. I pity the innocent one. I hate the mothers who do that.
@daphne009 (301)
• United States
14 Sep 07
Well, not knowing what the fight was about, who knows what posses these women to leave behind their children. I have a 5 year old and 9 month old and could never imagine leaving them.
1 person likes this
@chertsy (3798)
• United States
15 Sep 07
I scrolled down to see if there was a reason why she left. Leaving her kids with anyone that has been drinking isn't a good choice even if that person is there father. I do hope her husband came to his senses though over this. Your friend done what a lot of wives only dream of doing for fear of what people would think of her not coming back home to her kids. Some men need that harsh wake up call and stop taking there wives for granted. Now what she should of done was locked the doors and fixed it so his sorry butt couldn't get in without waking the neighborhood. You can tell her was it worth it? Did her husband learn his lesson? If not those two need to sit down and really talk to each other, if not it will only get worse before it gets better. For your question, I have left my children behind only to stay with my parents for 2 weeks. Well only my oldest actually. The first time my youngest has been away from me is now that she's going to school. For 11 years this is the first time I been by myself and it stinks. Leaving my kids behind would be like leaving part of myself with them. Your friend must of really took so much and snapped. One night isn't anything that will scar the kids unless her husband was a jerk and said she left them and was never coming back. Then she needs to kick his butt so bad that they will need a doctor to remove her shoe.
1 person likes this
• Philippines
14 Sep 07
Maybe because the father is there, someone who can look for their children for awhile. The mother is just trying to calm herself. If she doesn't come back, I think the mother is not on her right senses.
@psyche49f (2502)
• Philippines
15 Sep 07
If I were the one, leaving would only be temporary--at least for a few days. If I'm going for good, I'd bring all my children because it's my instinct to care for my children come hell or high waters....this mother may have reasons...one, she could not support her own children alone...second, she may have left without giving it a serious thought...I'm sure she may have already regretted for acting drastically amidst anger and pain...third...it could be a way of 'punishing' the husband by making him be the one to care for the kids....there might be other reasons, but the bottomline is: mothers never forsake their children, unless she has gone crazy she does not know what she's doing....
@wotfpatty (2065)
• United States
15 Sep 07
Absolutely nothing would make me leave my kids behind for any reason. They are older now at 21 and 17 and I wouldn't even leave now. I want to be near them and be a part of their lives as they grow into adulthood. When they were little, there was nothing at all that would have made me leave them. The only thing I can think of is if I was depressed or something and might hurt them. That never happened to me but, if a mother is unstable, then she should get help and leave the kids somewhere safe. Otherwise, I honestly can't figure out how any mom could walk out on her kids. If my marriage went bad, the kids would be with me even if it was tough going. Maybe I am obsessive but those are my kids and they need me, even now.
1 person likes this
@Dee351972 (743)
15 Sep 07
Hi, i am a mother of 4 chirldren.My oldest is 14 my youngest is 5 years. the 5 year old i adoptedand my youngest bio child should been 10. She passed away 3 years ago. I been through alot and i dont see why peple would do stupid stuff like leave their children alon. I dont think there is a reason that any kids under like 13 or so need to be left alone. Kids are to improtan.
1 person likes this