Should C.C. Sabathia or Fausto Carmona win the AL Cy Young?

United States
October 11, 2007 4:50pm CST
Based upon their performance this season should one of these guys get that award? I would have to honestly say they deserve it due to performance and how they've come through for Cleveland. I believe on ESPN, especially C.C., he's getting considered and called a potential Cy Young Winner. Both men won 19 games without question. There's other at the moment that could get it but I only hear them as possible candidates. I think it would be interesting and would be the 1st Cy Young Winner in Cleveland since Gaylord Perry back in 1972. As far as AL Manager of the year, I will cover that but I think it should go to the Cleveland manager. I don't think there's any other manager that deserves it more than him. Discuss and give your thoughts on that.
1 person likes this
2 responses
arcidy
@arcidy (5005)
• United States
11 Oct 07
I really think josh beckett should win the cy young. He has been the best pitcher in the american league. He has won more games then fausto carmona and c.c Sabathia being 20. I think he has had a lower era then those two. So I think Josh beckett should win the american cy young award which he really deserves because hes been amazing all year. What a change he has made from the previous year when he wasnt all that great.
gradyslady
@gradyslady (4054)
• United States
11 Oct 07
They're both really really good. C.C. has always been good, but Fausto was like a big surprise. No one really expected Fausto to come out and be as great as he has been. To me it's pretty much a coin toss, they're both amazing, and have both shined this year.