Would you tell a friend or girlfriend a dress wasn't flattering?

By Amy
Abernathy, Texas
October 30, 2007 3:55pm CST
How honest are you with opinions? Are you honest when asked - or do you offer it up yourself? Do you tell friends that clothes or hairstyle isn't flattering or about the spinach stuck in their teeth?
4 people like this
13 responses
@SweetTrix (1071)
• United States
30 Oct 07
I tell my friends and family members the truth about what they wear or if they have stuff in their teeth. I would want someone to tell me if my eyeliner was running and I looked like a raccoon, I'm sure they wouldn't want to walk around with raccoon eyes. I always tell my fiancee when he has something in his teeth because I don't want him to start talking to someone and all the person can pay attention to is the thing between his teeth, lol. When I am with my sister and cousin we are always letting each other know if something looks bad on us or if our makeup looks dorky, we got each other covered.
2 people like this
• Abernathy, Texas
6 Dec 07
SweetTrix, I admire you honesty. I too try to do the same. I think its not only polite but its almost mean not to - almost an insult to keep the information to yourself. Have fun!
1 person likes this
30 Oct 07
I'd definitly tell a friend if she had some embarrassing thing going on, like the spinach for instance, thats easy to fix. If a friend met me somewhere in an outfit i deemed bad, i don't think i'd say anything. If she can't do anything about it, it'll we'll just cause her upset. I might later say something, but hopefully in a positive way, like maybe she could wear this like that, or with this etc. A hair cut would have to be really bad for me to say anything, cos at the end of the day it's whether she likes it really isn't it.
1 person likes this
• Abernathy, Texas
6 Dec 07
What a great friend you are. You are diploment as well as empathetic to their situation. Its so true - if you're already out and about - why upset her? If you're not already a manager, you'd likely make a great one. Its important to be positive when giving criticism. In fact you can mention something they are doing well,then go on to tactfully talk about the areas that need work. I like complimenting something in a friend, you're hair is such a great colour, I really loved the way you had it styled the other day. Sounds like you're a great friend.
1 person likes this
• United States
30 Oct 07
I would never lie to a friend. I would tell you that I don't like the dress and then help you find a better dress. You are my friend and I want you to look your best.
• United States
5 Nov 07
When you become rich, fly me in and I'll help you shop for the your new wardrobe.
• Abernathy, Texas
6 Dec 07
I will do that - give me a few months!
1 person likes this
• Abernathy, Texas
30 Oct 07
Great answer, want to move near me, when I get rich, I'll hire you as a personal shopper. :)---
1 person likes this
• United States
31 Oct 07
Hi Art, As importatnt as it is to some of us when we are out in public trying to look nice, I definately tell my friends if something isnt working out. Even if they really do feel that its looking great, I will say it, in a VERY nice way though. Im never sarcastic or mean to my friends. I dont want to hurt their feelings, but I do want them to not look terrible in an outfit! Cos if someone else says it, and they turn to me and say you said it looked great! They would know that I lied. :( And I dont want to lie to my friends, sure dont want them lying to me about some clothing, as terrible as I am with choosing clothes. LOL Bay Lay Gray xx
• Abernathy, Texas
6 Dec 07
Wow, I need to take you shopping with me Bay, I need that kind of honesty and I bet you have a great eye! BTW - just to be random - I'm using my husband's computer - laptop, and I only just remembered the mouse attached - I've been using the 'mouse' on the keyboard and kept accidently erasing my entries! Hope you're doing well - we've moved yay!
1 person likes this
@new_waver (198)
30 Oct 07
Friends don't let friends walk around with spinach in their teeth! ;) As for giving my opinion on how they're dressed, I'll give an honest answer if I'm asked for my opinion. Or if it's something monumentally hideous, I suppose I'd volunteer my opinion without being asked--although, most of my friends have decent fashion sense, so I'm spared having to do it. But I'll be honest because I expect them to be honest in return. Even if I'm asking my brother's opinion of my clothes, he knows it's best to just tell me if something doesn't work, because I'll do the same for him.
1 person likes this
• Abernathy, Texas
6 Dec 07
New_waver, thank goodness for friends with good fashion sense. Which doesn't necessarily mean ALWAYS following the trends but balancing it out with classic styles as well. I'm glad your friends and your brother also give you the same courtesy of honesty that you offer them!
1 person likes this
• United States
7 Dec 07
I'm honest and up front. I'd expect a friend of mine to do the same for me. Whether the dress is just butt ugly or if it displays a part of my body too much, I would want to know rather than go out somewhere wearing it and look like an idiot.
• Abernathy, Texas
16 May 08
I can totally understand that, I'd want to know as well. I'd rather have honest friends. Even if them telling you a dress is butt ugly - its better then going out in it. And if they're honest if a dress is awesome - they'll tell you so - and you'll know its the truth!
@mimpi1911 (25464)
• India
8 Nov 07
Yes, I do tell my very close friends and I know for sure that they take it as a gesture to make themselves look better. And they even do the same when it comes to my hair or a lipstick or anything that is not so good. I feel, true friends are for pointing out our faults and not just to share sugary talks all the time. Having said this, I have only afew very close friends.
• Abernathy, Texas
6 Dec 07
mimipi, better a few close friends then dozens of shallow ones! I did giggle at that though. I bet your a great friend though - there's a lot to be said for honesty.
@suspenseful (40193)
• Canada
6 Dec 07
I would tell them, but in a nice way. I do not like them to feel hurt so I would say well it is not your color, and ask them why they are not wearing the red one or whatever? I doubt that anyone would be that honest with me. I have worn clothes that I know made me look like crap, but they just saw, "nice dress" as though I was a mannequin and did not see that the color was all wrong for me. The same for hair. I look at the front of the hair so even if it is wonderful at the back and looks unflattering at front, I will tell them that they look good in bangs, etc. Mind you no one has ever asked me how they looked.
• Abernathy, Texas
6 Dec 07
I would be honest with you. I think honesty is a gift shared between friends. Its evident that you're a good friend.
@Aurone (4755)
• United States
2 Nov 07
On most things I am honest. I like by the policy if you don't wanna know, don't ask.
• Abernathy, Texas
6 Dec 07
Aurone - so true. Some people just want the empty compliment - I'd rather have the truth thanks! Happy holidays!
• Pakistan
1 Nov 07
Flattering is an art. The artists of flattering could get much and more than those who are strait forward. It is no doubt that honesty is the best policy. But I saw that the people honest with there opinion could not move forward. They keep freeze them self at zero point. If you want to get some thing, or if you want to make happy your friend, you should learn the art of flatter. This would prove the key of success.
• Abernathy, Texas
16 Nov 07
So you would let your friend go out with horrible makeup or an ugly dress that is unflattering - to say an important interview or a date - just for the sake of er - flattering them?
@peanutjar (5198)
• Canada
6 Dec 07
Hi artemis:) I only tell my boyfriend this and he tells me.I do not tell other people,i cannot.I'm not like that and have a hard time to be,only if they ask me but then i still will say something else.Im too afraid of hurting someone's feelings maybe,haha.But when it comes to food in the teeth,i will tell them so they will not become embarassed of someone else sees it there and not just me. Peanutjar:)
• Abernathy, Texas
6 Dec 07
peanutjar, you sound sweet. Its true, its hard to think you might hurt a friends feelings. Sometimes though, I feel hurt if I look in say a longer mirror and see that something I have on is all wrong and a friend didn't tell me. However, its not really their place, some might say, we are accountable, ultimately for our own choices. I love your new avatar by the way. so pretty.
@tryxiness (4544)
• Philippines
17 Nov 07
When I know that as friends I only want the best for them, I am quite honest and frank to them. I tell them constructively what I think. :)
• Abernathy, Texas
6 Dec 07
tryxiness, that's the way to do - constructively. Honesty is so important in a relationship, but there is a way to do that is tactful. You must be a good friend. :)
@nkhanna (922)
• India
6 Dec 07
well i am very frank person.i have the habit of telling the truth on the face.i dont mind whether it hurts the other person.because i believe that truth should be told and being her friend i need to show her the right path.i guess it will not her if i tell her that her dress or makeup is not good.rather she will take it as feedback and get it rectified.however it will really hurt her if other person tell her that her dress is not goood however i out of shame told her that it was good knowingly that it was not.
• Abernathy, Texas
6 Dec 07
It sounds like you care about your friends feelings - in the long run - because she might be hurt in the moment - but she will be saved from a huge embarrassment if a stranger tells her!!!