What do you think about the Television's Writer Strike? Fair or NOT to writers?

United States
November 7, 2007 9:18am CST
Is it fair that the writers make so little for the work they do with TV scripts? (No rights unlike everyone ELSE!) SHOULD or SHOULDN'T the writers make a little money when their words go to DVD, pod casts, and syndication? What do you think about the Producer's Group saying the writers were 'irresponsible'? Do you agree? How should this be fixed? What should happen? Is there anyone being unreasonable? Are the writers? The producers? The Studio people? Who??? What IS a writer's worth when it comes to television shows? Without a writer, what IS a show? Not much, I think. I think that the writers are RIGHT for striking! They DESERVE MORE!!!!!!!
1 person likes this
8 responses
• Mexico
9 Nov 07
I think it is totally fair. Being a writer is creating and idea, even if it only is a TV script, it involves a creation process that must be rewarded. It is not fair that producers and channels or even big companies when producinga a movie become billionare with someone elseĀ“s creativity and the reward is not shared. It is offensive the salaries the actors and actresses can make while writers, the true heroes, the ones that come with the whole idea are not getting their share. Good for them, I wish them good luck!
1 person likes this
• United States
8 Dec 07
To Armywife. You may not see reruns because a lot of shows are taped well in advance and most network shows have scripts that'll last them till February 2008. Some shows are even completed already for scripts and production. I've heard that negotiations were strong as recently as yesterday and that the Writers Guild of America gave into one demand. I'm thinking that the strike should be over by March at the latest. The last one lasted 5 months. This one will probably last shorter than that, but I could be wrong.
• United States
10 Nov 07
I agree. Writers ARE artists and fair IS fair. Isn't it funny how they writers seldomly get any credit, even when the project gets BIG time attention? Hmm... Though I am going to hate seeing re-runs, I support the writers completely. It's not like they are asking to break the bank, they just want a piece of what they have written!
1 person likes this
• United States
9 Nov 07
After touring their web site and examining the issue it would seem they should share in the benefits as do the others envolved (producers, etc...)
• United States
10 Nov 07
:} I am tickled to see most people agree and side with the writers on this one. I don't think they are being unfair at all. Thanks for your comment!
1 person likes this
• United States
8 Nov 07
I agree they do deserve more. I need to follow this more closely to give better response to this heated topic . . . sharing the light, Miss Erica Hidvegi, the Enlightenment Advisor,B.A. Psych (spclztn in Child Dvlpt & Abnrml), M.A. Transpersonal Psych Studies- Cnslng/ Author, Artist, Photographer, Entrepreneur & Freelance extraordinaire www.enlightenment-psych.net
1 person likes this
• United States
10 Nov 07
Thank you for your comment, Miss Erica!
1 person likes this
@ersmommy1 (12588)
• United States
7 Nov 07
I think they are correct as well. But as with the strike in 1988 it may go on a while. They currently receive 4cents per dvd sold..they are asking for 8 cents. TV is fast becoming the only means of entertainment for a lot of families, what with the prices at the theatre climbing like gas prices. I don't know if anyone is being truly unreasonable. I know that when big money is involved, it becomes more difficult for them to compromise.
1 person likes this
• United States
10 Nov 07
I totally agree-- writers should get more! They are only asking for 8 cents? Wow! As much as some of those collections are--WTH?! You'd think they were asking for the firstborn child or something! lol TV is the cheapest entertainment available! You are very right. It's definately cost effective to stay at home, save your gas, and watch a good show. Theaters really have a sense of humor on what they ask for tickets these days too! For my family of five, I can buy two or three DVDs for what they want for us to get into see it there! Did you know it took them 22 weeks to come to an agreement in 88? Wonder how long it will take them this time...
1 person likes this
• Philippines
8 Nov 07
I support their cause! All the profits that those shows get and you can't even justly compensate the writers?? Good writers are extremely hard to find, unlike actors or other crew members which I think could be hired anywhere in Hollywood.. They could make or break a show, so all they're asking for is some support for their families and for a more stable future, I guess, what with all that's going in the US right now.. In fact, it's not even millions, which some shows give to actors for just appearing on the show.. I hope that the producers listen to their demands.. On a light note, it is great that the actors, and talk show hosts like Ellen DeGeneres are really going all out in their support for the writers.. :) I think it's a great way to use their fame, to help those with no voice..
• United States
10 Nov 07
I agree! It IS the script that makes or breaks a show. There can be a school of talented actors/tresses but without the words, what then? The only ones that I can see who'd be able to pull of success are those who are used to stand-up and/or improv! That knocks out LOTS of people! I hope so too!~ (that it will end soon!) It is heartwarming to see so many stars who DO support the writers. I think they know what it's like to have a good and a crappy script! I have my fingers crossed in hopes that it will take less then the 22 weeks it did in 88. That's just crazy!! Guess the DVD sales will increase when it's nothing but re-runs!
1 person likes this
• China
8 Nov 07
i love tv
1 person likes this
• United States
10 Nov 07
Me too.
1 person likes this
@Transformed (1259)
• United States
8 Dec 07
A lot of writers depend on residuals and as such really need royalties from DVDs as well as any other sales of their words. Sometimes writers spend years in between jobs. Those with less than $30000 in royalties can't qualify for health insurance. As such, the writers feel that if they could get 2.5% of royalties, they'd be able to make enough to qualify for health insurance. In the creative industry, it is tough to find work, so residuals are the "bread and butter" of writing assignments. New media, ie. the Internet is largely unregualted, as such, many writers are missing out on the dollars that can help them and their families. As an aspiring novel writer and actor, it pains me to see the industry struggling with the strike. The writers need the studios to make money and the studios need the writers to write the products that will make the studios money. The actors (some of whom have walked off even though Screen Actors Guild's clauses prevent them from striking in the event of another strike) struggle because they can't make any episodes and thus get paid. The crew struggles and some crews have been laid off. I think the way for it to be fixed is to have all parties sit together and realize money won't be made if they don't cooperate. The producers and the writers need to make some concessions and just get back to work. I'd hate to think what could happen if the entertainment industry shut down. The Directors and SAG contracts run out in July. Then, it could lead to collective bargaining on a much larger scale, which could render any talks irrelevant. Please let the strike be over. Actors, writers, studio and crew need to work and need money. Aspiring actors need to have shows to aspire to get on!
• India
25 Nov 07
i think its not fair