Who is the real hero? The Story Writer, the Director,or the Actor in any film.

@humbleme (1004)
India
November 10, 2007 1:49am CST
Hello friends, The person who creates different situations,characters and creates a story or the director who understands the story well , rates it according to its market acceptability, then creates all characters emotions, situation, expressions and finally a male or female actor performs the role on the exact tunes and guidence of the director and a film is either hit or a flop. According to you who is the real hero (be it a hit or a flop film), the story writer or the director or the actor?
9 responses
• India
10 Nov 07
Of course a movie is a combined effort,but i think director has a biger role to play.A director is a person who directs the making of a film. A film director visualizes the script, controlling a film's artistic and dramatic aspects, while guiding the technical crew and actors in the fulfillment of his or her vision. However, film directors do not in all countries have absolute artistic control. The director can also be selected by the producer. The producer can in this case have veto power over everything from the script itself to the final cut of the film, often in anywhere from slight to extreme opposition to the director's vision.A film director is responsible for overseeing every creative aspect of a film. They develop a vision for a film, decide how it should look, what tone it should have, and what an audience should gain from the cinematic experience. They are responsible for hiring a strong, creative team of people to work with production, lighting, cinematography, and costumes. Film directors are responsible for approving every camera angle, lens effect, lighting, and set design. They coordinate the actors moves, determine camera angles, and may be involved in the writing, financing, and editing of a film. The director works closely with the cast and crew. They listen to the cast and crew, take some suggestions, and give out some of their own. They meet with the cast before each scene to do a run through. This tells them how the actors are going to play the scene, which enables them to make changes accordingly
@humbleme (1004)
• India
10 Nov 07
Hello varunkrishna007,thanks for your response and a very good answer.Intentionally I didnot included the role of a producer cause most of the time a producer is not actually involved in anysort of creativity he is the financer and only interested in financial profits.If there are plenty of vegitables,fruits,spices,but no one to cook it or no gas cylinders inside my kitchen still then I suppose I will not die cause in this necessity I will eat raw vegitables and fruits adding salt and spices on it,but if I know to cook also I have gas cylinder but no vegitables fruits etc then dont you think I have to die starving?Then who is the real hero the vegitables/fruits etc or the cook or the gascylinder ?
@MGjhaud (23171)
• Philippines
14 Nov 07
In this case, I’d appreciate the talent of the writer first then the director and lastly the actor. Usually my logic of how the movie went great is like that – because of the writer’s creativity. I like movies with good plotting as I appreciate some spy novelists.
@chamberd1 (240)
• United States
11 Nov 07
None, the film is irrelivant.
• India
11 Nov 07
well i guess each have a vital role to play all together make a good film imagine if all are good like a good story,good actors good finance but not a good diector-there goes the movie in the garbage again all is good and the actore is not able to carry his role well..then no audience...alll is well other than the storyline...no ratings...alll is welll then no budgetr....hahaha....i guess it will become a documentary.. ;)
• India
11 Nov 07
Well i think the screenplay writer is very important to a movie. he creates the situations. Next comes the director who actualizes the screen writer's situations
• India
10 Nov 07
I think the most important is the acting and the story line...Even if the acting is good is story is weak then it will be boring.. But the credit goes each and every person as there is combined effect...
@williamjisir (22819)
• China
10 Nov 07
Hello dear friend humbleme. This is an interesting discussion. Well, I think that the relationship among the three is very important to one another, none of which can be ignored as to who is the real hero.
@dilmeet (55)
• India
10 Nov 07
I believe first the movie being market on the base of the cast and then the director comes to the picture who present the story in the best way. And the storywriter is only gives the story. The director has to be careful for the cast and the story to present the story.
• Brazil
10 Nov 07
The writer. why is he who created everything, he is a real hero because to be writer has to be very creative ansd think of the most unusual situations.