Could you ever forgive someone who murdered your child?

United States
October 28, 2006 12:21pm CST
Two years ago in my community, a drunk driver killed a teenager. The teenager's family says they have forgiven the man, and they are actually fighting in court to get his sentence shortened because they say the remorse he feels has been punishment enough. I have very conflicting emotions about this, because while I believe forgiveness helps everyone move on and heal in the end, I do not believe I would ever be able to forgive someone for taking my child's life, especially a drunk driver. What are your thoughts?
5 people like this
64 responses
@dellion (6698)
• Malaysia
28 Oct 06
I don;t I can even face it if that was happended to my family and for the rest of my life I don't think I can really forgive it.
2 people like this
• United States
6 Nov 06
It is even hard to imagine, isn't it? Hopefully we will never have to face such a dreadful thing, ever.
• United States
7 Nov 06
No, that is something I could never forgive.
1 person likes this
• United States
7 Nov 06
Thanks for commenting.
• United States
6 Nov 06
I would never forgive. Everyone knows that drinking and driving is wrong and it risks the driver's life, passengers and every single person out on the road with him/her. This person knowing that it was wrong went out and drove and killed that teenager. He should punished and live with it on his conscious for the rest of his entire life. For example, I dont drink much, But If I decide to have a few drinks, I am going to hand my keys to someone else, and or call a cab or a friend for a ride or walk home or even wait the drunkeness off. I'm not sure why the family feels so terrible about someone who went driving drunk and killed their child. Maybe they feel that forgiving the person will make them feel better and add some sort of closure to the issue. In my opinion, I feel that by the family forgiving this man. they are saying it's okay that he did that.
2 people like this
• United States
7 Nov 06
Yes, that could be true.
@wavelander (1526)
• Portugal
9 Nov 06
It depends! if he really meant to kill, i wouldn't! but if it was by neglicence with time i'd probably forgive! i don't know, only passing by that experience
1 person likes this
• United States
9 Nov 06
It is something none of us would ever want to experience. Thanks for your response.
@sbeauty (5865)
• United States
28 Oct 06
I would like to say I could, but I don't know. That would be the most devastating thing that could happen to me. I admired the Amish people who said that they had already forgiven the man who killed 5 of their children. That takes real strength of character, and I believe they have it if anyone does. For me it would also depend on the circumstances. If it was premeditated murder or a serial killer, or something like that, I'd have a harder time forgiving than if it were an accident. One thing I would always want to remember is that the killer's family is grieving, too. I'd never want to be as vengeful as some of the people I see on the news. Hurting that other family isn't going to bring your child back.
2 people like this
@mshenzi (246)
• Kenya
6 Nov 06
I can forgive him if he lets me kill him and not report this matter.
2 people like this
• United States
6 Nov 06
Wow. That's a little harsh! But again, I have no idea how I would respond. I would certainly have moments I would wish to kill the person, but hope that I would not, because I do not think we can ever recover from taking someone else's life. And if I was the one who had drank, drove and killed, especially a child or teenager, I do not believe I could live with the guilt and remorse. There are just some things that cannot be forgiven. This is a tough discussion matter . . .
1 person likes this
@jmintuck (114)
• Canada
10 Nov 06
No way in HELL would I forgive someone who killed my child or ANYONE in my family! I would be so frickin' IRATE that I,d be all too happy to see them go to jail for a LOOONG time. I cannot even begin to BELIEVE when people say they actually FORGIVE whoever has killed a loved one!I,m sorry, but I don,t. They,ve got to be better Christians than I , or depressed, or simply mad.I cannot fathom myself beginning to forgive people who do that sort of thing.Maybe it,s because I,ve always been an angry type of person all my life. Hmm. A drunk driver? No, frankly an icecube,s chance in hell I,d forgive! I hate drunk drivers more than anything.I don,t know why they don,t just increase the punishment for those sort of people.I am ALWAYS scared of drunk drivers. I was walking home from a nearby restaurant, and I have to go down a one-way street to go home. I saw a drunk driver ZOOM down the one way the WRONG WAY! I SAW him ENTER the one way at the wrong end. I could have been trying to cross that street and would have got hit if he came down 5 minutes later than he did. I was sooo mad I would have laughed at him if I heard a crash after he went down it the wrong way.I would NOT have called 911 for help for him either.
1 person likes this
• United States
13 Nov 06
Well you certainly got my attention on this comment! I understand where your emotions stem from; I, too, have a very hard time forgiving irresponsible people who cause others harm, and those who take lives, well, who can condemn us for saying we could not forgive them?
• United States
8 Nov 06
I know that the right thing to do is to forgive that person and move on, but I don't think I would be able to do that. I would be devistated if anything happened to my son, I don't know that I am a strong enough person to forgive someone for that.
1 person likes this
• United States
9 Nov 06
In understand what you are saying completely. Hopefully we will never see such an awful day.
@gsnarayanan (1704)
• India
9 Nov 06
See..! This is an emotional problem.One can never forgive such acts. But still there is a point ...! The circumstances. If it isfavorable to the murderer we can not help...!
• United States
9 Nov 06
You are right. Tough discussion.
@malcido (422)
• United States
8 Nov 06
After reading your question I spent a few moments gazing at my two boys. They are nine and four years old and are sitting on the sofa, next to one another, watching a movie. Watching them, I realize that this isn't a question that I can answer. In order to do so, I would have to contemplate a life without these two persons. I can't do that.
• United States
9 Nov 06
I understand. It is unimaginable, is it not? None of us would ever want to be in such awful situation. Thank you for your very thoughtful response.
@anushri (961)
• India
9 Nov 06
no i wont forgive
1 person likes this
• United States
9 Nov 06
Thanks for your response.
@JENRANKIN (132)
• United States
8 Nov 06
i would like to think i would be able to but ocen the life of my child has been taken the my life would be over i live for every moment with my daughter and without her i dont know what i would do.
1 person likes this
• United States
9 Nov 06
Again, it is unimaginable. And I understand completely the closeness you feel to your child.
@Zabeen (668)
9 Nov 06
No and never
1 person likes this
• United States
9 Nov 06
Thank you for stopping by.
@ashutoshgl (1443)
• United States
8 Nov 06
i do not think that i could ever forgive him or her.its a very brutal deed.
1 person likes this
• United States
9 Nov 06
You are right. Thank you so much for responding.
@dklowery (35)
• United States
8 Nov 06
Yes we (I) can and do forgive. 12 days ago my brother was struck by a car and killed. He was a pedestrian. Even as we grieve as a family, we (or at least I) have forgiven the driver (a 17 year old teen). We must remember that Jesus forgave us of our sins (if we repent). Even as he was on the cross he said "Father, forgive them for the know not what they do". If Jesus can forgive us of anything we have done, than we too must forgive. God Bless,
1 person likes this
@achilles7 (1276)
• India
8 Nov 06
This very respectable and has to be followed. We are in the world of crime and punishment.We must practice to forgive and do good to others.Almost all evil can be rooted out if we controll our short temper and pride. We will not forgive as we are pride and we think that we do not make any mistakes.The action from the part of the driver may accidental.Can the life be regained if he is sentenced? The family has given the right punishment by forgiving him and he is spending his life in repentence and he will not repeat it anymore.
1 person likes this
• United States
9 Nov 06
We humans are so complex that it is not easy to feel one way or another simple because we should or ought, or it is told it is the best for us. Thank you for your thoughtful response.
@grump0ne (979)
• United States
7 Nov 06
No I could never forgive them, and I would not expect his family to forgive me when the same was done to them...
1 person likes this
• United States
7 Nov 06
Again, thank you for taking the time to respond. I appreciate everyone's honesty on this difficult subject.
@msqtech (15074)
• United States
7 Nov 06
I would try but it would be hard God tells us to forgive
1 person likes this
• United States
7 Nov 06
He does tell us to forgive, but the instructions written on the heart are sometimes very difficult to decipher . . .
• United States
7 Nov 06
Reminds me of the Yada Yada Prayer Group books. As for my answer. I don't know. I hope that I would, eventually, but I cannot say for sure.
• United States
9 Nov 06
It is a very difficult thing to ponder. Thank you for stopping by.
@7nicole1 (1633)
• Canada
7 Nov 06
i don't think i could forgive either. having your child ripped from your arms and life is an unbearable thought. my prayers go out to all moms and dads who have had to go through this. i know if one of my three were all of a sudden gone i'd be devastated and can't see forgiving the person who took them away.
1 person likes this
• United States
7 Nov 06
Thank you so much for your heartfelt response. That seems to be the general opinion.
@ninjaxr (23)
• Italy
8 Nov 06
No, I don't!!! Even because I'll kill him!!!
1 person likes this
• United States
9 Nov 06
I would hope you did not. But many have before, and have lived to regret it, because it does not bring your loved one back, you have now taken another human life, and you will probably spend the rest of yours in jail. A hard subject to even contemplate.