No child Left Behind
By estherlou
@estherlou (5015)
United States
November 18, 2007 9:03am CST
Since I don't have kids in school, I don't know a lot about this. Started in 2001, the law mandates all students become proficient in reading and math by 2014. A student already in school in 2001 would be out or almost out of school by 2014. And mostly it isn't working. There has been inadequate funding, local politics and uncertainty over federal remedies and failing schools. Federal auditors found that 4,509 schools (with more than 2 million students--or 8% of all federally funded schools) have failed to bring students up to their grade level for 4 or more years straight! Problems? Schools in lo-income or racial and ethnic-minority districts. State and local districts exploit the loophole in the federal law to use other remedies. Some are schools with students with learning disabilities or limited english skills. And because of the focus on the underachievers, the gifted students are being ignored and their programs are being cut. Some want teacher performance incentives while others say that would disqualify teacher of art and music, or librarians. With pressure to meet federal targets, some states have watered down their standards. Sounds like this is not working and we are graduating kids that don't meet the standards. This will seriously affect our next generation...think of the type of people going into the work force? What is the solution?
(Nov. 12 issue of USNEWS and World Report)
3 people like this
7 responses
@sarahruthbeth22 (43143)
• United States
18 Nov 07
They should stop the program and have a forum in each state where teachers, parents, and local officials get together and discuss what they really need in their schools.And when they have their list, each state's Congressman should bring in the list to the National Board of Education.Since every state is different, there will be some that need more money and others better school buildings.Then when all public schools have the resources, then you can set a basic test that all students need to pass.It will show that the student learned the math and English he/she will need. But if the student doesn't pass the test, the school doesn't lose money, instead the student gets a tutor so he/she can pass the second time he/she takes the test.
The way it is set up now, teachers are just teaching to the test.because the school can't afford to lose money, they are forgetting about teaching the student anything that isn't on the test.And the student isn't learning how to learn.
So in 5-10 years from now,we will have new graduates that don't know how to learn, a trait you will need to keep a job.
2 people like this
@UnselfishShellfish (1306)
• United States
26 Dec 07
"So in 5-10 years from now,we will have new graduates that don't know how to learn, a trait you will need to keep a job. "
That's happening now.
I was at Taco Bell the other night. Their registers were down and the girl was having to use a calculator to add up sales tax plus the items I ordered. I usually get the same thing every time I go so I know the total will be $4.36. She tried telling me that my total was $7.90 for a drink, a burrito and a tostada. She was adding the sales tax wrong. She was multiplying the sales tax by the total to get the amount she thought I was due.
When I was in 4th grade, we learned about sales tax. This girl had to be about 18 and she had no clue about how to do sales tax. Kids are far too used to using computers or calculators.
2 people like this
@sarahruthbeth22 (43143)
• United States
28 Dec 07
I am in between doing math in your head and the calculator generation. My mom wouldn't let me have a calculator until I knew my multiplication tables. I learned them but I still will use a calculator to be sure.
@teapotmommommerced (10359)
• United States
19 Nov 07
A friend of mine is a high school teacher and she tells me another problem is they do not give the parents any responsibility to make sure the children are doing their homework.
My friend just had to give out diffencies and mover half of the class if flucking because they do not do their homework. Most of the students today think they do not have to turn in their work.
Where are the parents when their children are getting a D or F in a class? What are the parents doing to make their child study or make sure the child is doing all their homework?
The highschool students today do not want to be involved in organizations, according to my friend the high school teacher.
2 people like this
@KrazyKlingon (5005)
• United States
26 Dec 07
I cannot remember where i saw this, but it's not just the regular schools that are cutting things like that. There was this plan a few years ago for colleges & universities are also cutting required electives out of their curricila, such as the majors that do not require it, mathematics & lab science course requirements are being reduced - courses of study like history (or some other social science) & arts/music or other humanities. Then in other majors like engineering & physics & mathematics, social science & humanities electives requirements have been reduced.
I can't remember where I saw & read this. I only remember "dumbing down" as the partial title of the report/article. I also don't know if this actually went into effect.
1 person likes this
@reinydawn (11642)
• United States
26 Dec 07
I thought it started before that... My kids graduated in 2002 and 2004 and I remember protesting it when they were in grade school. What they've basically done around here is "dumb" the schools down so that everyone is assured of passing. It really hurt my oldest who is pretty bright and applied himself. There was no challenge for him at all. And I guess if you think about it, it hurt my youngest too who didn't try any harder than he had to because he could skate by without having to think. I think it's a huge disservice to our children. If they had implemented it the way it was supposed to be designed it would be great! They were SUPPOSED to have extra programs for struggling children to get them up to speed. Instead they've just brought the standard down so everyone can meet it. We call it the "Every Child Left Behind" program.
1 person likes this
@Debs_place (10520)
• United States
29 Dec 07
I read somewhere recently that 70% of all kids who graduate from high school are not ready to go onto college. And that most kids spend between one and 2 semesters taking remedial courses, at great cost to the parents to learn what they should have learned in college.
The solution is the parents and teachers must work as a team, that means the parent must make sure that all work is done and the kids study and get enough sleep and are ready for school. The teacher must contact a parent as soon as there is a problem, not wait until the end of the marking period, the semester, the child is failing.
They must set goals and make sure the kids work to meet them. Unless everyone is committed it won't work. We have to find a way to motivate kids to work too.
1 person likes this
@kellys3ps (3723)
• United States
29 Dec 07
It is a poorly written law that ensures that all children will fall behind! They no longer worry about moving kids beyond what is adequate. Crazy!
1 person likes this
@ItTakesAllSorts (4096)
•
26 Dec 07
We have the same thing in the UK, Every Child Matters.
Yet again another government run scheme that places targets above the education of children.
The division between schools is growing as parents can choose which school they want their kids to go to instead of sending them to their local school which was the policy years ago. Now we have schools that the middle classes have taken over, while working class children are going to schools that are failing.
The emphasis is now on exam results which does not always reflect the diversity in alot of schools who may have a higher number of kids with English as an additional language or kids with special needs.
Most kids in the UK are being taught a government curriculum that is boring and their whole school learning is based around them being taught to pass a test instead of enjoying their learning and becoming critical thinkers, which we so need in our society nowadays.
Pressure is constantly being put on them, kids in the UK are the most tested compared to many other countries. We are letting our kids down with this system and there is a high percentage that are leaving school without the basic skills in reading and writing.
Teachers should be given back their power and the government should step back, this would make such a difference to the teachers morale and the kids..
I am training to become a teacher but I am thinking twice about it now as I hate the system the way it is. I do work in education and the incentives given out to teachers is laughable. They are not a respected profession like years ago and this is very sad.
For the sake of our kids future and that of the next workforce, something has to change, we are loosing a generation of scientists, artists and inspired adults.
1 person likes this








