can a woman ask a man to marry her?

Australia
November 22, 2007 5:59am CST
What is your opinion on women asking men to marry them? My boyfriend wants me to ask him when we eventually get engaged. I find that a bit odd being a bit old fashioned. I think I would like to be asked. What do you think?
5 people like this
17 responses
@nkhanna (922)
• India
27 Nov 07
hi. i think it really does not matters as to who asks first about the marriage.though traditionally it was only guy who was supposed to do this.but i think that it really does not matter as as to who asks?today many girls directly ask a boy if they have feelings for him. and i really think its good since girls should also have the gutts to ask and accept the acceptance or rejection.atleast they will confess not like the olden days where a girl was ont supposed to tell all this to a man.and they just had to keep thier feelings inside their heart only.
1 person likes this
• United States
24 Nov 07
Yeah but of course, if the woman wants to ask more power to her. But, if you prefer him to ask then you tell him how you feel. This is not what is can and can not do. It is how you feel and what you want to do. What decisions you make in life changes who you are and how you are with one another. If he wants you to do it and you don't then compromise. You tell him I will get the flowers and pick out my ring, then you can get on your knee while holding the flowers and ring and ask me for my hand. Just my opinion. Good luck.
1 person likes this
@diannebcrs (1549)
• Philippines
26 Nov 07
well, no. anyone may call it an old fashioned way when a guy asks a girl to marry him, but that's just how the way it is, right? a man is designed to be the initiator, the one who leads a relationship. a woman then is designed to be the one who'll accepts and then submits. well, that's how i think it is. if a man is, indeed, a man, he should be the one who'll have to ask the woman to marry him.
• Philippines
10 Dec 07
i didn't mean it that way. i didn't mean that women should succumb to slavery... i mean it's not the role of the women to make the first move and lead the relationship, because men should be the initiators. women accept and submit only to the man of their CHOICE. i didn't mean that women should always accept and submit to a man whom they don't like... if a man leads a woman to a direction he likes, it is up to the woman if she WANTS to accept the proposal. if a man tells what he wishes, it is up the woman if she WANTS to submit to his wishes.. that's what i mean by a woman's ROLE... she's not the initiator of the relationship. my idea here is that no matter how a woman may already want to marry, she should wait until the man proposes.. if the man still doesn't propose, the woman can bring the idea or talk about marriage - but she doesn't propose because that's the man's job. if the idea appeals to the man, he'll find his way into proposing to the woman he fancies to marry.. hehe.. well, that's my own opinion of it. have a nice day.
• Australia
26 Nov 07
a woman submits... Does that mean that the woman does whatever the man wants? I don't agree! A marriage is about 2 people working together. The woman needs to have their life too and that means have their say. If that means rejecting what the man is saying because it is against your values then you reject it on those grounds. A woman should never be forced to be a slave to a man. I am not a feminist but I see marriage being 2 people that compliment eachother but are equal. Sure, compromise is important in making things work but submitting is a totally different game!
• New Zealand
23 Nov 07
In my own opinion, I still want the guy to ask me to marry him but it really depends to a person's personality and situation...=)
1 person likes this
22 Nov 07
Hey,friend! i don't think it's odd ,but you can ask him to marry you as now it's new times when femail has the rights mail has. wish you best
@klaudyou (501)
22 Nov 07
It's not odd. If she has "the idea" first, then what's the problem? If you look at it as a tradition, yes... it wouldn't be nice for a woman to ask the man to marry her, but if you treat it as a PROOF OF LOVE, then it's one of the best things to do. Asking a man to marry you the first time it's surprise; the second time is conviction; the third time is persuasion...and so on...and finally, the last time he'll do it!
23 Nov 07
hehe....i'm so sorry that it seems I made some mistakes on typing this response above last night. i think that"you can ask him" should be corrected to"you can be asked by him".hehehe.....sorry,my friend. then,what i mean is that it's not odd as a tradition and as a proof of love.but i also don't think it's a must for female to ask male to marry her since it has been the 21 century now. when it come to what you said ,buddy, i make full sense of your mean.yes,when the first time she does it,you feel surprise and sweet,but if the action is overmuch,then it will become so boring without attraction. yes, i agree with you,buddy.
@klaudyou (501)
23 Nov 07
Sorry saiwailaozei ... this actually was a post to the main topic :)...it was my first time here and i put a comment to the last response instead of putting a response :) See ya...by the way...thanks you agreed somehow!
@klaudyou (501)
22 Nov 07
Sorry...the comment above is actually a response to the discussion...i have to get used to the system....
1 person likes this
• Pakistan
25 Nov 07
Women have equal right to decide about their future. Marriage is not a game. It is a great and historic decision about the future of life of a woman and a man. If a lady likes and loves a man then she should not hesitate nor does waist her time to wait for telling or offering the man that she want to marry her with him. It is a bold step which would cause to build her better future, and she should not stay waiting for this courageous step.
@dramaqn (1990)
• United States
22 Nov 07
I'm back. It's just like the Sadie Hawkins dance thing. You know when the girl asks the guy to the dance. People wasn't so keen on that idea at first, but now it's no biggie. And that happened way back in the day. My 2nd husband asked me, if that's what you want to call it. And I look back now and wish I just would've done what I did with the first one and asked him. It was a terrible proposal. But I loved him so I said yes.
@dramaqn (1990)
• United States
22 Nov 07
Most definitely a woman can ask a man to marry her. Sometimes (especially in today's society), if we wait on a man to ask, we'll never get married. I asked my first husband to marry me. I didn't think about it, I just did it and he said yes. We were married for 6 years. He didn't think it to be odd, which was great, especially with him being a preacher's son. Being the one to ask, has it's advantages. What? Well it differs for each couple, but more importantly it shows the other that you are serious about being with only them and you truly ready to commit to the fullest.
@theprogamer (10534)
• United States
24 Nov 07
Yes of course she could. NOTHING (except bogus pre-conceptions) can stop her from doing it. I will say however, it should be a true proposal. I've seen events and cases where the woman doesn't propose, she threatens or gives a twisted ultimatum (anyone hear of a guy doing this in recent memory? I haven't). I find it disgusting.
@MagieL (266)
• China
10 Dec 07
maybe i think a woman can ask a man to marry her,but i won't do this.hehehehe...^^
@irene_27 (542)
• Philippines
10 Dec 07
Being old fashioned too that i am, i really find it quite odd if i'll do the asking to the guy. I just don't think i can ever do that even when i'm really dying to marry him. I think too that doing so will put pressure on him which i wouldn't want to happen at all. I want a man to marry me when he's ready so it is only right that he should be the one to ask me. About your boyfriend, maybe he said that to you because he's ready anytime but he feels that you're not yet. And in order not to pressure you, you just have to let him know when you finally feel the right time has come.
@monty24 (154)
• India
22 Nov 07
Hi friend, I dont think there is anything to being odd.If a man can ask a women then why cant a women?And your boyfriend has given u chance to make him happy so go ahead...Good luck..
• India
22 Nov 07
hi , yes ofcourse it feels odd if a woman asks man to marry her :) because its man's work :)
@sumitsonu (598)
• India
22 Nov 07
yea whats the problem in asking a boy to marry , when boys can ask girls I don't feel girls should feel shy to ask a boy .
@joahnna18 (368)
• Philippines
22 Nov 07
In my opinion it's very awkward to ask a guy to marry you. It's kind of pressuring him to marry you. But if he really loves you he will be the one to ask you to marry him. But if you want to try there's no problem of that at least you know the opinion of your boyfriend:) happy posting my friend:)
@Sharon38 (1912)
• Jamaica
22 Nov 07
Well it seems odd to me but not impossible. Well if you think he is the one and since he requested it go ahead and make his day!