what kind of dog is GOOD for me?
@sabbathandruth (567)
Canada
November 29, 2007 1:04pm CST
I have time to walk a dog but not ALOT of time, i have a 2 year old and planning on more in the future, i dont really want a small dog nor a huge dog, and my husband is slightly allergic, i want a dog that will train easily, and listen to me(unlike my past dog) what kind of dog is good for us?
i do love golden retrievers ( but alot of fur) or maybe a labrador retriever? are there any hypoallergenic dogs?
1 person likes this
6 responses
@houndsgood (774)
• United States
29 Nov 07
If your husband is slightly allergic, I would have an honest assessment of the situation. One of the top reasons people give up dogs is allergies. If something should happen and the husband has an allergic reaction, would you be willing to stick it out with the dog? That is what you have to ask yourself. But if he is just slightly allergic, some people find that preventing the dog from being in the master bedroom and eliminating carpet where you can helps.
Everyone wants the dog that you want - perfectly trained, listens to you, not big, not small. The truth is that that dog isn't born, its made. You have to take the time to train the dog and show him/her what is acceptable and what is not acceptable. And you have to take the time to gain the dog's trust and establish yourself as pack leader.
The best thing to do would be to apply with a rescue and help them counsel you about the most apropriate individual dog.
A good dog for you would be a standard or the medium sized poodle. They are hypollergenic, they are intelligent and are typically good with families/children. It is a larger dog, but not giant. There are lots of poodle mixes in the shelters too that may be perfect for you. Schnauzers are hypoallergenic but they are probably too active for your 2 year old. Wheaten Terriers would also be a good choice.
There are other dogs like the bichon, maltese and the toy poodle but they may be too small. Also, few shelters or rescues would adopt out a tiny dog to someone with small children.
The absolute best dog though may be one of the many medium sized, mixed breed dogs that come into shelters every single day - between 25-45 lbs. You just have to watch for a mix of one of those breeds and look at the hair.
3 people like this
@houndsgood (774)
• United States
29 Nov 07
I am also going to have to agree with the other respondents about maybe its not the right time to get a dog - but as far as the walking goes - you might want to consider a little bit of an older dog that would be content with just one long walk a day. Not all older dogs are good with kids if they hadn't lived with kids before but they are out there.
2 people like this
@wahptb (188)
• Canada
29 Nov 07
I was always under the impression that poodles were not very good with children. From what I have learned male poodles are the fiercest most dominant dogs. They are more dangerous than any other breed. Of course a pitbull that has been mistreated will be more dangerous than a poodle that has been well treated but apparently the poodle has the most killer instincts.
2 people like this
@UnselfishShellfish (1306)
• United States
29 Nov 07
Hounds, you are my new best friend.
"The truth is that that dog isn't born, its made."
I spent nearly 6 or 7 months patiently teaching one of my labs proper social skills. He wanted to jump and pee on everyone and it took me nearly a year to break him of that habit. He is a very well trained dog, but he's still spastic at times and does NOT know his own strength.
He also has a very powerful jaw. He doesn't mean to bite, but if I have a toy in my hand and he thinks I didn't throw it fast enough, he might try to bite or if he drops it, if I'm not quick enough, he thinks it's a game of keep away and lunges for the toy as well.
To the OP: Now imagine your child bending over to pick up that toy. I'm 30 years old. My bones are set. Your 2 year old's bones are not. That dog could *easily* snap that kid's wrist or arm and cause *severe* damage.
2 people like this

@wahptb (188)
• Canada
29 Nov 07
You might want to try a dog with short hair. He might not be as allergic, they usually shed quite a bit less than longer hair dogs. I guess it also depends on your budget. If your adopting a dog from a shelter you pretty much can choose what they have there. If you are going to buy a pure bread dog then there are lots of options. All dogs need exercise so whatever breed you get you need to give them exercise every day. If you don't have a backyard that they get exercise in then walking them daily is essential with any size dog. I like boxers my experience with boxers and children has always been positive, but they have a lot of energy. I also like bulldogs and any type of sausage dog.
2 people like this
@houndsgood (774)
• United States
29 Nov 07
Its not the length of the hair - its the dandar and type of hair. People can be just or more allergic to a short hair dog as a long.
2 people like this

@urbandekay (18278)
•
29 Nov 07
Plenty of responsible breeders breeding them here and yes they are hypo-allergenic
all the best urban
1 person likes this
@Debs_place (10520)
• United States
30 Nov 07
Labrodoodles are not an official breed and their personalities can vary greatly. A friend of mine just got bitten by one on Thanksgiving.
It sounds to me like you are too busy for a dog at this time, any dog, no matter the breed can go bad if not given the proper care.
You might want to consider waiting until you have the time to devote to a dog, this would be better for your dog and your family.
And if your hubby is slightly allergic, bathe the dog regularly, This has helped in my house.
1 person likes this
@Seraphine (385)
• Finland
29 Nov 07
From a shelter or rescue only in that case. There are NO responsible breeders breeding such a mix and there are no guarantees that mix will be hypoallergenic. A purebred poodle is a much safer bet.
1 person likes this

@doubleloveyou (2466)
• United States
30 Nov 07
Ok I've read all the comments. They are getting closer near the bottom. Here is what you want. You love the golden retreiver. You need it to be non-allergenic. you don't want a small dog, but a medium easy to train dog. According to those requirements you need a Goldendoodle. That is the Golden retriever poodle hybrid. IT IS a true breed. It is one of the easiest to train dogs I have EVER dealt with. Wonderful around children. It has all the great traits of the retreiver (love of water, friendly to children, loves to play Yes they will play without being trained to play fetch) But it also has the best qualities of the poodle. No shed, hypo-allergenic, Smart (more so than any of the border collies I've trained) All around the Goldendoodle is hands down number one on my list. now you can literally find them from sizes that vary from 8-10 pounds up to 40-60 pounds. So you can decide what size you want. You can also choose what type of hair you want it to have. Either the curly poodle or the retreiver kinky straighter hair. All kinds are not shed (if you don't let them get matted)
One of the best traits is that these dogs have been breed to resist disease. A trait that most pure breds do not have anymore. I hope this helps.
@UnselfishShellfish (1306)
• United States
29 Nov 07
No offense, but I don't think you need one.
Labs are *very* energetic and require a LOT of work. I have 3 labs right now. 2 are mine and one is a rescue I am fostering and rehabilitating for the shelter here. My 2 labs I own are very energetic, love to run and play and can easily injure a child without knowing what they are doing. My niece is 3 and my dog is easily 90 lbs. You do the math.
Dogs take a LOT of hard work and with you having a small child plus wanting more, chances are the dog would be neglected because you'd put your kids first and not the dog.
@fineexistence (574)
• United States
29 Nov 07
Rottweilers should be good for you as they have short hairs. Contrary to the general belief that Rottweilers are fierce and dangerous dogs, I feel that they are very loyal and gentle especially towards elderly and young children. Get a puppy and grow up with it; that way, you won't find it too big at the first sight of it.
1 person likes this

@Seraphine (385)
• Finland
29 Nov 07
Rotties need someone experienced with plenty of time to exercise and TRAIN it. An untrained rott is nothing but dangerous, definately not a dog I would trust in a family with young children. A well trained rott can be a great companion for families with children once the children are a bit older.
Btw, I have never heard of a rott being hypoallergenic. It's not the hairs that is causing allergies. It's the dander.
1 person likes this
@houndsgood (774)
• United States
29 Nov 07
Many Rotties are big sweeties and great with kids that are a little older. However, they can accidentally knock a small child over with their massive heads if they are left unattended with the child. They won't even mean to do it. Plus they need the exercise. I wouldn't recommend a Rottie to someone who wasn't dog experienced who had a small child just because they wouldn't "anticipate" situations. (but that goes for any other dog too, but especially the huge ones). I do like Rotties a lot though :)
1 person likes this





