Would You Want to Adopt Kids Your Spouse Had Before your Relationship?

United States
January 4, 2008 1:22pm CST
Men - Assume that there are 3 children that do not have a father but have until recently (within the past year) called another man dad. Now that person has lost all parental rights to these children and you are about to marry the kids mother. Would you want to adopt those 3 children and make them yours and take full responsibility for them or would you feel better off just being their step-parent and why? Women - if you were about to marry a man who had 3 kids to a previous woman who abandoned them and lost all their rights to them would you want to adopt them when you married their father or would you just want to be a step-mom and why?
1 person likes this
8 responses
• United States
8 Jan 08
I think it might depend on the ages of the children involved to some extent. Afterall, these children have known another man as their father. That may not change just because the courts have taken away his rights. But, assuming the children were of yound enough age that they would accept such a situation, and desire such a relationship with the "new" man, then yes...I would. If you love the children and they love you, then that is a natural progression. Of course, there are many factors involved and I think each situation will present it's only unique circumstances that can only be addressed knowing all of those factors.
1 person likes this
@SViswan (12051)
• India
5 Jan 08
I would want to adopt the kids (especially if the mother isn't in the picture). I think it will make it seem more like a family and I like kids and if I married their father, I would be their mother. I know it's tough and might take some time to come to terms with (for the kids) but I would be willing to give it the time and would personally want to be considered their mother and not their step-mother. Now if the biological mother was an active parent...seeing them often and there was no problem for the kids on that front (it's just that the mother and father couldn't get along) - then I think it wouldn't be fair to the kids to compete with their mother. So, I would then stick to being a step-mother and try to have a cordial relationship with their mother (try and not to make it hard on the kids).
• United States
5 Jan 08
Yeah in this scenario there is no mommy. I would be the same way if this were reversed. I've been in situations where I have loved a mans kids more than I even cared about him. Those never ended well. My oldest has a step mother and this woman is constantly saying "This is my daughter" in reference to my kid and it really makes her mad. My daughter got to the point that she told her step mom that she has a mother and she would appreciate it if her step mom could respect that.
1 person likes this
@SViswan (12051)
• India
7 Jan 08
Yes, that is what I meant. Just because I am a step-mother doesn't mean that I try to break the bond with the biological mother (if she is in the scene). If they have a good relationship, I can never take the mother's place. But I can be a nice step-mother who respects the mother.
@crystal8577 (1466)
• United States
6 Jan 08
It would depend on their age & what the kids would want. Older kids sometimes only want you to be thier step parent. If the kids were small & wanted me to be their mom then I am all for it. I would have no problem adopting someone else's kids.
• United States
7 Jan 08
Women just have bigger hearts and bigger brains than most men (I have to say most to keep my sweetie and loungeact in a class all by themselves). At any age I would ask the children what they wanted if they were old enough to have an opinion. My boys can't wait til my honey gets to be their new daddy. They have even started trying to pick dates to move up the wedding they are so excited.
1 person likes this
• United States
10 Jan 08
I would do this in a heartbeat. If my husband had kids before our relationship, I would be happy to care for them and adopt them if their mother abandoned them. They need a mom in their lives.
• United States
10 Jan 08
Very well put. Thank you for your comment.
@cher913 (25782)
• Canada
4 Jan 08
sure why not? the kids need to know that they are accepted by you as the step parent and they need a parentel figure that is a woman as well.
• United States
4 Jan 08
Very good. I think maybe some people though might not want to take on the responsibility that comes with being the "real" parent over the step parent. I'm sure someone will say this sooner or later.
1 person likes this
@lightningd (1039)
• United States
6 Jan 08
Having seen another angle on this one, I do not think it would be wise to adopt the children until the children were old enough to have a say in the matter. If the children already know their biological parent, and know that you are wanting to make them your own child, I would get thier input. I know a woman who had a child right after high school, didn't tell the father of the child, because in her eyes, he was worthless and had a bunch of kids already and he would be a bad influence. She then married a man, who was around the child from shortly after birth. When they got pregnant with a child together, she decided that she wanted the first child to assume the step-dad's last name so that the two children would have the same last name in school so she wouldn't be embarassed. Rather than go through the proper channels, and notify the real father, she applied for an amended birth certificate, lied to a judge, said the child was his, and got the child's name changed. Move ahead 6 years, she divorced the guy, and he got stuck paying child support on the kid, and she knows as well as he that the child is not his, and she continues to lie to the court when it is brought up in child support issues. The child has since found out by accident that he is not actually the child of this man, and now the child wants nothing to do with the man who has been paying child support on him for the last 8 years, and blames him for the lie his mother continues to perpetuate. For anyone considering adopting a child of a current spouse, please be sure that you are fully aware that you will be considered as far as the courts are concerned, that child's parent should you ever get divorced, and regardless of the mother or father refusing to let you see the child after the divorce because they say "He/she isn't yours anyway so you aren't going to see him/her." You have to look at all possibilities. I myself had a step dad that wanted to adopt me when I was in 6th grade. He had been my step dad for 3 years already. I didn't want to give up my last name so I said no, and it was dropped. My mother and step father divorced when I was a senior in high school. Although he never adopted me, he is still my dad as far as I am concerned, and I his daughter as far as he and the rest of his family are concerned, including my step-brother, I'm his little sis. Adoption isn't necessarily the answer. Love is. Last names mean nothing. If you love the child and you want to leave them an inheritance, then by all means, make out a will, leave them a percentage as you would your biological children. Blood is thicker than water, but love is thicker than blood.
• United States
7 Jan 08
The man who inspired me to write this post is an attorney so I doubt there is anything he doesn't know about what he is getting into. That was actually a big concern of mine. 10 years from now if we separate is he going to abandon the kids because they aren't biologically his and is he going to whine and moan each month when it comes time to pay the child support. He's a bit more of an optimist than I am so he is sure we will never separate but has reassured me that even if we do he will still love these children just as much as he does now and would expect to be responsible for them after the divorce as long as I don't go psycho and try to use the "they aren't biologically his" as a reason he shouldn't have partial custody. It took us a while but we got all the what if's worked out and we are both very comfortable in what is going to happen after we get married. It is women like you mentioned in your scenario that make what I asked harder and harder for men all the time. *sigh* I'm just one of the lucky one I guess.
1 person likes this
@Rtlsnk316 (1197)
• Mexico
7 Feb 08
Hi, As a man, I would dare to say that I may take the step parent role, for a while before deciding to take legal custody. I believe it pretty much depends on the particular situation, the relationship with the kids, can I afford to be completely responsible for the children? Is it in me to be a parent?
@dania_elm (421)
• United States
7 Feb 08
i would want to adopt them and be their mom. all kids deserve a warm loving family. and if i had a chance to provide that for other kids i would. they wouldnt have to be my hubbys with someone else. if they were his then they are a part of him. i love my hubby with all my heart and dont know what id do without him.