National ID Card On The Way!
By anniepa
@anniepa (27955)
United States
January 12, 2008 2:43pm CST
I guess whether we like it or not the National ID Card is on its way with the goal being to have everyone 43 years old and under switched over by 2014 and the rest of us by 2017. Of course, it's in the name of "Homeland Security" and if you happen to live in a state where they choose not to participate you'll need another form of identification to board an airliner. Which is fine for world travelers who have a passport but many of us don't have a passport and have never really had a need for one. Any thoughts on is? Does this fit right in with the predictions of "Big Brother" watching our every move? It sure does worry me more than a little bit.
Annie
4 people like this
14 responses
@4ftfingers (1310)
•
12 Jan 08
We will have National Identity Cards here too and to be honest I support the scheme. At first I was skeptical, but I think it will bring many benefits.
It will solve a lot of the problems you hear people grumbling about on a day-to-day basis - identity fraud, benefit fraud, illegal immigration etc. I personally don't care that much about illegal immigration, everyone wants a better life good luck to them, but at least I won't have to listen to everyone complaining about it. Although I'm sure they will have something else to complain about, it won't stop fuel prices rising for example.
I doubt it will have any negative impact on my life personally because out of 60 million British people, I don't think I am really that interesting enough for anyone to want to monitor me. I think anyone that paranoid about being stalked by the state needs to get a grip, you really are not that special!! (I don't mean you anniepa, you are great :D) But the only people who should be paranoid are the criminals who are doing something wrong and so if that is the case then the scheme is working swimmingly.
The only thing that really annoys me about it is that we will have to buy the cards. One report said that the cards will be up to £500, almost $1000. Making something like this compulsory but then saying we will have to buy them, at such an expensive price, is ridiculous. Yet too typical.
4 people like this

@4ftfingers (1310)
•
12 Jan 08
Yeah you're right I think food is always going to win for me hands down, theres no contest!
That was what one report said. Although I think it is more likely to be between £170 - £300, which is still a lot, between about $333 and almost $600.
A lot of people won't be able to afford that, if they want everyone to have it they should think of a way to make it dirt cheap, you can't make people hand over money they don't have.
But this country's on its a*se. The members of Parliament want to give police officers a pay rise bellow the rate on inflation, while they have just voted to give themselves a pay rise at 2.8%, which is above inflation. I wish I could vote on my own pay rise :D
2 people like this
@anniepa (27955)
• United States
12 Jan 08
$333 or more for the card? That means I'll have to skip filling up my gas tank once or twice?
Seriously, that's another good point; people can't afford to pay that kind of money. I wasn't even thinking about having to pay for this card but that we do have to pay for a passport and I can't really afford to do that when I don't really need one. I think the 2% figure for people with passports is pretty high, too. My brother has one because he's been going to England pretty often ever since he was there while in the Army and he loved it so much but he and my sister-in-law are the only Americans I know personally who has one.
BTW, I'm not a criminal but I do have a problem with being watched. I just value my privacy and I fear that once they take that "inch" the "mile" won't be far behind.
Annie
1 person likes this
@morgandrake (2136)
• United States
12 Jan 08
Oh my God! That much for an ID? That is outrageous. You could buy a computer for that much, or a whole lot of food. There is a choice I won't want to make: food or an ID card.
3 people like this

@mkirby624 (1598)
• United States
12 Jan 08
Vote for Ron Paul then. He opposes the National ID Card along with the other controlling policies of our nation.
4 people like this
@sarahruthbeth22 (43143)
• United States
13 Jan 08
They can try but there will be many of us that will never get this card.There are many that never travel on planes.And I think they will try to make the wrong person get this card and they will sue the government. Unless the AClU beats them to it.What happens if you don;t have this i.d.? Do they put you in jail? If so where are they going to find all this jail space? do they get deported? Where do you deport a native, a person born here for many generations? To Europe? To Africa?To Asia?And if there isn't any jail room or they won't deport people, will they put these "undocumented" people in Ghettos? If so, this sounds familiar. Poland and Eastern Europe in the 1930's.
2 people like this
@Adoniah (7512)
• United States
14 Jan 08
You know Americans keep saying "Well, they won't get away with doing that here"' and then of course they do. How many things have you seen change since 911? How many freedoms have we lost? "They" will do whatever "They" want because we as a people no longer have the gumption to do anything about it except whine or write about it toughly on mylot!
What we need now is a new generation of hippys to rebel with some gusto. A few good rebellions and serious marches and sitins might get the point across to the jerks in power. I'm not sure that a bunch of 50 to 60 year olds is all that intimidating. I guess we could try. We'd have to wait til Spring for the Arthritis to calm down first!lol
2 people like this
@sarahruthbeth22 (43143)
• United States
14 Jan 08
What I see happening is the government sets all these rules and one third of the population won't know that the rules have changed because it wasn't in Spanish and another third will just ignore the rules. We Americans are known for just ignoring the rules. Isn't that how we became the United States by refusing to pay our taxes?I don't see a generation who prefers to chat online going out and protesting like their parents did in the 60's . But I do see them just disregarding the rules that they don't feel are fair.
@morgandrake (2136)
• United States
12 Jan 08
It is an issue of freedom vs. preventing terrorism. I am not sure what is worse. Basically, if you plan on flying anywhere in the next few years, it is probably best to just go get a passport. We have time to get one before the switch happens.
They are already watching our every move. Or would be if we were important enough to be watched. I think you and I are safe--what the worst that we can do? Annoy homeland security with our internet postings? *wink*
3 people like this

@morgandrake (2136)
• United States
12 Jan 08
Outside of a half dozen people from last semester's political science class (five of which just got them for the voluteer project that the professor was involved in), I know nobody with a passport. No, take that back, my sister, her husband and kids have passports. Still that is less than a dozen people in my circle who have them. 2% sounds really high--I doubt it is that many.
3 people like this
@theprogamer (10532)
• United States
13 Jan 08
Its not just Homeland Insecurity, its also the flapping heads at Capitol Shill, and other related clowns that are driving this (with others ignoring it). Even though the chip idea has been abolished for now, I don't think thats the end of it. You are kidding yourself if you dismiss the thought.
There are already enough identification practices and those are fine (well for the most part they are). Once we get into putting much more of our liberties toward supposed safety, we are really going to be paying for it (via privacy, free speech, neo-'patriotism', etc).
Isn't it interesting this hasn't come up in the 'debates'? I keep saying its a one-card monte and just a show of smoke and mirrors. There are only buzz issues for attention, but real legal and societal matters: attacks on free speech, power abuse, government ineptitude: are dismissed. Other social issues with vary ties to government are not given proper consideration either (marriage values, education quality, quality of government services, budget spending, etc). This is all complete madness and I only see it getting worse from here. Maybe it'll be slow, or it could be rapid, but things are occuring, and very few even notice it let alone are able to stop it.
2 people like this
@anniepa (27955)
• United States
13 Jan 08
I'm not kidding myself, I know you're right, Pro! Don't get me wrong here, I'm not subscribing to the conspiracy theories that the Bush Administration or any other government entity planned and carried out the 9/11 attacks but you've got to admit, 9/11 has sure provided the powers that be with a good excuse to take many of our liberties away, hasn't it? You're so right about the debates. So many of the questions they're asked in the debates for both parties I sit there like "And I should care about this because...?"
I do have to say, though, the Democrats have talked about education a little, but the ones who have raised that issue the most are now out of the race - Biden, Dodd and Richardson. The Republicans have raised the horrific issue of gay marriage and that's one of those where I have to say "My life would be negatively impacted by that because...?"
I was actually accused by a good friend of mine, an older lady in her seventies who is a staunch Bush supporter, of having something to hide because I mentioned I didn't want anyone listening in on my private telephone conversations, being privy to my medical records or keeping track of my spending or travel habits. I said WHEN I become a suspect in some terror plot or other crime then eavesdrop away; until then MYOB! I have my own big brother and even he knows his boundaries!
Annie
1 person likes this
@theprogamer (10532)
• United States
14 Jan 08
Fail.
I already know some of this and I know what you are talking about.
There is some privacy lost but still its my own choice. This ID card has stipulations that negate it as I've talked about.
1 person likes this
@Adoniah (7512)
• United States
14 Jan 08
Do you realize how much of your privacy you are giving up right now by being here on mylot. Do you think they pay you because of your cute little avatar? Everything that you are writing is being used somewhere somehow and your real name is attatched to it not the name on your avatar. If you really care about your privacy do some hard thinking about that!!
2 people like this

@Adoniah (7512)
• United States
12 Jan 08
I would rather have a National ID Card or a Passport than some of the other options they keep tossing around. Most of my life I have had a Passport. I just let it expire because I stopped traveling. I wish now I hadn't. They have tripled in price.
They are trying to force our kids to use their thumbprints to charge their lunches in school. They want to use retina identification for various things. People are getting their medical info injected into their arms in a scanable strip. Not me. They do not just put alergies and heart trouble on those strips. They put you SS# and other private info on there. Anyone with the right scanner can get that info at one of those scanner entrances to banks, schools, and security office buildings even Disney World does it now.
At Disney, you have to request to go in a separate enterance to keep from having your finger print scanned. Who do they think they are anyhow? I'm not applying for a job. I'm just going for a day of supposed fun.
3 people like this
@Thoroughrob (11742)
• United States
1 Feb 08
It does seem like a way for the government to know every move we make. That is totally scary. I do not know that this is a good thing.
@nangel78 (1454)
• United States
13 Jan 08
I do not like the national id card idea. It seems like a way to have more red tape involved in the process and for things to become more difficult. You already have to show an id before boarding the airplane. I know it is just a driver's license or state issued id, but flying in the country, I think that works fine. Who is not to say that fake national ids will not be made either, ya know?
2 people like this
@CraftyCorner (5600)
• United States
13 Jan 08
My income is about $1000 a month. If they expect all to have this wacky card, they would have a sliding pay scale for the slobs at the bottom of the income bracket because otherwise, we just couldn't get it. Thankfully, I will be turning 40 come April, and I am in one of the rebel states, Arizona.
*
As for the refusenicks, there are a whole bunch of camps that FEMA built that are standing empty but staffed all over America.
*
http://www.sianews.com/modules.php?name=News&file=article&sid=1062
@xfahctor (14113)
• Lancaster, New Hampshire
17 Jan 08
Well I live in one of the states that has refused to take part. I dont see where its any different than any other id. you get pulled over these days (or in days past for that matter) they run your license and there you are, and despite what one poster claims, they can see if you have warrants in other states, etc. Other than being nationalized, I really see no difference. We are not going to be restricted on traveling state to state, no checkpoints, fema camps are a myth ( I checked one out that supposedly was, pretty near to me, and its nothing more than an empty old pow camp, a tourist attraction and it's really not staffed either. I wasn't watched, wasn't hovered over by helicopters or chased off.
I'm all for watching our liberties and protecting them but for Christ sakes people, get a grip.
1 person likes this
@anniepa (27955)
• United States
27 Jan 08
Should those of us who are also against the wiretapping of our telephones also "get a grip"? Sorry, but I have a problem with "Big Brother" being able to access my personal business in any case but with an Administration such as the one we have right now I'm admittedly downright paranoid! There, I said it - I'm PARANOID! When you have the powers that be that are completely corporation friendly and totally consumer and employee UNFRIENDLY one has to be cautious when it comes to having access to all our personal info. Today it's a national driver's license to help keep us safe from terrorists just as wiretapping our phones was or being able to check up on our Internet or library habits. How soon will they also be able to check our medical records which could keep us from getting insurance or employment? Or simply detain us as "enemy combatants" if we're deemed to be anti-Bush Administration?
Annie
@palonghorn (5479)
• United States
13 Jan 08
The only thing that this really changes from what the system is capable of now,is that if you were to get stopped for say speeding, in another state, when they ran your driver lic. it would come back with a full report unlike now, where if you get stopped in pa with a texas lic, it will not show the pa cop any warrants, etc. from out of state. Also, it keeps someone that has a suspended license, from 'borrowing' say their sisters information, which you would know everything, and going and requesting a replacement license because you lost yours. It would have your picture but all your sister's information on it,and this does happen. So with the new system, your picture is in the system, and if you tried to pull this replacement scam, it wouldn't work.
1 person likes this
@anniepa (27955)
• United States
14 Jan 08
If it was only those things that you mention here, I guess we'd all be fine with it. I mean, who doesn't want criminals to be caught and to stop people to drive with suspended licenses or to be able to get fake licenses if they've done something serious like DUI or hit and run? But it's the idea that there will be much more information stored on these cards and the capability is unlimited once it gets implemented and everyone gets "used to it" and accepting that it's a necessity in this new world with the "War on Terror".
Annie
@janisspaggiari59 (656)
• United States
13 Jan 08
I better be able to make payments on it.
1 person likes this
@sdiaz411 (111)
• United States
15 Jan 08
I don't really know to much about the national card thing, but i am surely not going to be using it. this kind of reminds me of that movie demolition man, ever seen it? i don't want them knowing my every move that i make. guess i will be rebelling.













