To give alms or not to give alms.

India
January 18, 2008 12:10am CST
When someone approaches me with an extended palm, I am in two minds. If the person is really old or disabled, then its ok, but if the person is young and able, I feel why. Maybe, he is really unable to get a job and his family is hungry. Then again, they make so much by begging, it becomes a habit to be lazy and not work. I have read articles which claim they are not only rich, they even have flats to let out. But how can I know of their circumstances? If I dont give alms, maybe he will sleep hungry. If I do give alms, am I encouraging him to be lazy?
1 person likes this
4 responses
@secretbear (19448)
• Philippines
19 Jan 08
if you see a beggar and you think that he is able and strong, then don't give him alms. yeah, i think giving alms to an able but lazy beggar would encourage him to go on living like that. i don't give alms to beggar that are able and capable. i seldom give alms to disabled beggar. some disabled beggars still find work like giving massage, selling candies, etc. and i don't give alms to mothers who take along their children to streets just to beg. its just unacceptable. sometimes i give alms to little children but only food and not money. i prefer to give food because i know they don't have a choice but to eat it. but if i give them money, who knows what they might buy. that's why i get more suspicious when a beggar refuses food and demands for money. there are beggars like that. and those kinds don't deserve any pity.
• India
21 Jan 08
Yes, you are absolutely right. In fact I ask the able bodied beggars to come and work for me, just to test them. They will walk away, and that shows they are after easy money. I have heard a sad case here in India where the little girl was drooping with sleep, but was not allowed to sleep till she collected some desired money. When I enquired with her why she was not asleep at this late hour, she shocked me with this info. Its a sad world. I gave the the child the required money only so that she could sleep. Its sad, what with the syndicates dictating terms.
1 person likes this
@raijin (10345)
• Philippines
18 Jan 08
Some people are either this or that they are handled by some syndicates, the best thing to do is say "NO" to them. Don't give them any but if you want to, give them foods or clothings and not any monetary denominations. If you really want to help these people, there are institutions that'll provide them shelter where you can also offer your help to support through giving them foods and clothings..
• India
21 Jan 08
Guess you are right. No monetary help. In my country there are no institutions for the beggars, so its all the more difficult to help or judge a person.
@nengs10 (3180)
• Philippines
18 Jan 08
Giving alms often bother me as well. It really depends who is asking from you. I look at the person and stare at him. I would also talk to him or her for a while. And then, I will decide if I will give him or her alms. I don't encourage them to stay lazy. That is why I talk to them for a while.
@danzer (2723)
• Philippines
18 Jan 08
Yea you're right. Therefore, I learned from my pastor to help those who are poor and needy. These are people who will accept anything you can offer. My pastor related a story of buying something for someone who is begging only to be turned-off because that person wants money and not food.
• India
21 Jan 08
Actually your pastor is very right. I sometimes ask the beggar who is able bodied to come and work for me. He will just walk off. This shows they want easy money. Its a sad state of affair.