Does tightening your belt financially mean you do less for others?

United States
January 26, 2008 1:02pm CST
I mean, are the causes that need our support, the ones you believe in, being harmed by our perception that we can't afford to help? So many have already become paralyzed by the scale and complexity of problems like world hunger and human rights violations and all the other needs in the world. And now with our country facing a recession are we giving less help to those whose needs are growing? Even with a recession we are the wealthiest country in the world and COULD give more than most countries. But when we are scared by the media's hype about how hard the economy is going to be on us we are likely to close our fists over our finances. I'm not talking about government aid here. I mean personal giving. I'm wondering if the fear of poverty on our part only makes the economy even worse than it is. Most of us could afford to live on much less. But would we do that to help those who must live on a dollar a day? It is a tough thing to do. How many of us are willing to go without what we are used to having and doing in order to end world hunger, fight AIDS in Africa, etc.?
1 person likes this
4 responses
• United States
26 Jan 08
What precious little my husband and I have to share with charities, which becomes less and less every year, we share with in our own community. Its a big world out there, our small penance would not offer much in the big picture, but in the smaller closer to home setting it does. Beside I know exactly where my dollar goes when I give at home.
2 people like this
• United States
27 Jan 08
"The world" is everywhere, even in your own community. Good for you for making a difference. Everything we do effects the world at large for good or ill. You are making choices for the good.
1 person likes this
@MsTickle (25180)
• Australia
28 Jan 08
Is tightening our belts and giving of what we have the answer? I think for those of us that are concerned about managing our own finances and lives are not the ones who should be worrying. Why don't the rich people give...they would certainly notice it less aand the amounts might have more impact. I can remember 50 years ago as a little kid being made to give my pennies to the missions. Money isn't the answer...we've been giving money for a bloody long time and the situations still exist. People are still bringing children into the world and abandoning them to a life of starvation, poverty and ill health. One would think that by now, enough schools would have been built, enough teachers are teaching these kids, enough hospitals have been built to educate and look after all these starving individuals but no...it seems there is never enough. That doesn't make any sense to me I'm afraid.
• United States
29 Jan 08
There is so much we can do to solve the world's problems but we don't do it because we think what we have to offer won't make a difference. While money isn't the only answer it certainly helps with the solutions. For instance, third world countries that don't have enough doctors or medical supplies get help from developed countries when their doctors spend a month in the places they are needed. But someone has to pay the way, buy supplies, etc. So while some people can't be much help in delivering needed services they can help support the ones who can. And there is so much that can be done here in the U.S., in our own towns and counties and states. Today I saw on t.v. an eleven-year-old who was working to change a law in Florida that would permit restaurants to give leftover food to homeless shelters. It was his idea and he's making the contacts to make it happen. Eleven! Imagine!
1 person likes this
• United States
27 Jan 08
I don't like to give money to blind charities. I feel that my money doesn't reach the people who need it. I give money directly to a needy. I would go out to shelters and give money to people I feel need it rather than giving to middleman.
1 person likes this
• United States
27 Jan 08
It is hard, in this day and age of graft and dishonesty, to trust what we don't know for sure. But there are ways to change the world where you are - like giving to help local shelters, food banks, etc. I also like The Box Project because you give directly to an impoverished family in the U.S. and get to know them by exchanging letters. It really is fun to find new or gently used items that you know that they need and to send it directly to them. Then you get mail from them telling you that they received it. There were also some deployed military who where receiving items from people in the U.S. for the people in Afghanistan or Iraq. It is possible to change the world without even giving money or items. We can influence our legislators and corporations to use fair and save conditions for workers in the U.S. and abroad. And to pay a living wage is another way to change the world. Public opinion is powerful if we unify our voices.
• United States
26 Jan 08
I grew up in the 80's era. I was always in fear of being homeless, not having money, etc. I remember the early days in my mother hood, scraping pennies to buy diapers. Now I am dealing with sending my oldest off next year, full of dreams and pray he makes it. I have been separated for a year and a half now, and I find I worry less about finances than i did the first 16 years of marriage. I still stress. I however, believe in the pay it forward system. If someone needs gas money, shoes for their kids, a medication, or whatever the case may be, I will share what little bit I may have in my pocket. When I pull up to a street corner, sometimes something has pulled at my heart, to give the homeless person $. I dont question its purpose once it is in their hands. I will donate pennies at gas stations in the penny holder for someone who might need it. It isnt up to me to save the world, our country, our county, our town or my neighbor hood.Sometimes I wonder if I can save myself..I know that I have everything I "need" and so many "wants".. we are not necessarily going to find the answers to world hunger, aids and other deadly diseases..the causes and cures, at least in our lifetime. But if we do things better now than what has been done, we will make a huge impact on the next generation. We are teaching each other, a tool, knowledge, whatever it may be, to recieve and give help. In turn, the pay it forward system, will reach millions. I have taught 3 children to give of themselves of what they are able, as long as they are able. Somedays, even though money would make a huge difference, a simple smile, hug, card, vision of natures beauty, etc. is all i need to replenish and be able to help someone else. I also believe what goes around, comes around. Money is just paper, easily destroyed. Love, humanity, spirituality, kindness, knowledge, caring, cannot...ever ... be destroyed...it is priceless..
• United States
27 Jan 08
Absolutely! I grew up in the fifties and sixties and I have a similar experience. I sometimes stress about money, now that I'm disabled and retired, but I remind myself that I've been poor and I've been not rich but comfortable and I prefer to avoid being poor. But I know I can do without a whole lot more than I do even now. So I'm not nearly as afraid to give what I have to those who need it more. I like paying forward, too. Once, when I was abandoned by my husband and father of my children and had zero income, someone gave me money on the condition that at some time in the future I would give as much or more to someone else with the same conditions. It keeps going and growing. And we do change the world with every choice we make. We really could end world hunger and all the other atrocities that are the result of human choices. And we will when we are willing to band together to make better choices. Sounds like you are making good ones.
1 person likes this