Will you be watch American Idol tonight?

I am not watching because I have to study, but Simone is my favorite judge. Sure he is harsh at times, but he is also honest. He just doesn't sugarcoat it. If they can't sing he tells them so, but I admit sometimes he can be wrong.

Yes I will be watching American Idol tonight and I think Simon is my favorite judge because he tells it straight. I get tired of Randy calling everyone "dawg" and Paula is to nice to all of the singers. Unless of course they are horrible then they all 3 are honest about the performance.

I won't be watching it. The first season is the only season I've watched the whole way through. After that I would watch just to laugh at the people who would try out and could not sing worth anything. But after I found out how they did the auditions I quit watching it. I feel bad for those people. The judges(before they see simon) keep putting these people through, getting their hopes up, just to be shot down by simon, paula and randy, because it makes good television. I think its really wrong.