My Adventures in Incense
By craftcatcher
@craftcatcher (3699)
United States
February 14, 2008 2:41pm CST
For those of you who answered my thread on incense several months ago here's my follow up on all the developments since that thread.
First let me say that after I posted that thread I did a considerable amount of research. It was quite an eye opener! Almost all incense sold around the world is made with a number of synthetic chemicals and burn accelerators, some of which are mildly (and for the more sensitive folks out there, not so mildly) toxic to humans. For those of you who complained that incense gave you headaches, there's the reason why.
Since my original idea was to make incense for religious, ritual, spiritual, aromatherapy or meditative purposes, I decided to narrow my research to strictly 100% natural ingredients such as woods, resins, herbs, florals, spices, oils and fruits. I found some incredible recipes, some of which were near 1,000 yrs old.
I managed to find small quantities of a few ingredients, enough to make several test batches. Making incense sticks or cones by hand is not an easy task. Grinding up the raw resins in a mortar & pestle is very hard work. With my Fibromyalgia and arthritis it gets very painful as well. I tried using a coffee grinder but that tended to heat up the resins and turn them into a cement like sticky mess. If I'd had a large pepper mill or something similar for grinding it would have been much easier.
I must say that the difference between 100% natural incense and the synthetically scented versions you buy at your local store is like night and day. True sandalwood, frankincense, Dragon's Blood, patchouli, does not smell like the synthetic perfumes we are all used to smelling. It smells, for lack of a better term, natural. Not sweet or thick but earthy. I now understand why a few of these things were considered to be more valuable than gold and only fit as gifts to the Gods in ancient times.
So, after researching suppliers for a wide variety of these ingredients. I'm very sorry to say that I had to abandon the idea of making it in sufficient quantity to sell it. Most of the ingredients are prohibitively expensive to buy or import in smaller quantities. I would have to buy in huge mass quantities to get the price down to something remotely reasonable for retail purposes. Even buying in large quantities you are vulnerable to the pricing whims of the suppliers. Prices fluctuate drastically for some of these raw ingredients. Most cannot be or are not produced in the USA because the plants and trees from which they originate do not grow here. Most grow in Asia, India, The Middle East or Africa.
There is of course a few alternatives which are less expensive, USA made and still 100% natural, but unfortunately they just didn't pass the test for me. They tended to smell like a campfire or charcoal briquettes. Fine for outdoor use but not so great inside the house. The other alternatives such as resin burning on makko and rice ash or charcoal disks are great but again, didn't pass the test for me. I enjoy the combinations of the resins and other ingredients left to mix and mingle together with the woods to create something unique to every batch. It's sort of like making spaghetti sauce, it's always better the second day.
I still make it in small quantities for my own use. I don't think I could ever go back to using artificially scented sticks. I'm officially spoiled by the "real thing". It was a good idea while it lasted. Thanks to several of my myLot friends who asked for an update. I really appreciate your interest.
1 person likes this
7 responses
@Lakota12 (42600)
• United States
15 Feb 08
well I want to welcome you back been along time since you have been here.
and sorry your venture didnt turn out the way you would have liked it would be nice to but good incence . I am wondering if you can find the real good pine oil that they used to put in bath oil to bath in I just loved that scent but they done make it that way any more and non e of the pine scents that I have smelled never comes close to that pine oil I used to use in the old wash tub I bathed in as a kid.
getting back to you .
I was so hoping you could make a go of this I for one would have liked to bought some from you.
well looks like its a no go hugs
1 person likes this

@Lakota12 (42600)
• United States
16 Feb 08
your so welcome.
I was a kid and my grandma would put this oil in the bath water it had a real deep pine smell so soothing.
When I get my check I am going to send for some of this and see I Sure hope it smells the same thanks.
So glad you are back talk to ya later hugs
@craftcatcher (3699)
• United States
15 Feb 08
Hi Lakota! Thanks for the welcome back.. I missed you all!
Do you remember the name of the pine bath oil product you used to use? I found one that uses genuine spruce oil. It might be similar. Here's the link to the page. http://www.smallflower.com/kneipp/spruce-bath-oil-100-ml-bath-oil.html
I look forward to talking with you again, now that I'm back. Take care :D

@lexus54 (3572)
• Singapore
15 Feb 08
Thank you for this update, which I am sure has educational value for those who use or are interested in incense. It makes an interesting read although I do not use incense in my home. I regret to learn that due to cost reasons, this potential business of making and retailing incense from natural ingredients has to be shelved. Perhaps you can explore other interests that you enjoy indulging in, and turn them into a money making venture. I wish you every success in this endeavor.
1 person likes this
@craftcatcher (3699)
• United States
15 Feb 08
Thanks, glad you found it interesting. I'm always exploring new projects, crafts and hobbies. Hopefully one of these days I'll land on something that will be lucrative.
Take care :D
@Darkwing (21583)
•
14 Feb 08
Wow, you have been busy with this my friend. Thank you for the update. It's a pity everything is so expensive, but wouldn't you think that natural resources would come cheaper... geeez, but some people are greedy.
It sounds very time-consuming too, which would knock down your profits some, because nobody is going to pay the absolute earth for them... not enough to cover all your time AND the expensive ingredients, so I can understand how you have to somewhat reluctantly, give up.
As you say, it was a brilliant idea while it lasted, but there's only so much you can do in a day. I look forward to reading about your next project. :)
Brightest Blessings.
@craftcatcher (3699)
• United States
14 Feb 08
Thanks Darkwing! I always seem to find new projects.. one of these days one might actually turn out to make me some money instead of just spending it.. LOL
But it makes for new adventures and learning all sorts of new things. I would be so depressed if I didn't learn something new on a regular basis.
@craftcatcher (3699)
• United States
14 Feb 08
Thanks so much! Yes artifically scented incense does bother a lot of people. It can cause coughing, sneezing, burning eyes, headaches, even skin rashes! Just awful stuff with all those chemicals in it.
I wish it had worked out but now I'm looking forward to finding new projects.
@craftcatcher (3699)
• United States
14 Feb 08
Hello Ann! Good to see you too. I missed you and many of my friends on myLot. I'm afraid I had no choice but to disappear for a while, bit of a stalker problem. Yeesh that wasn't pleasant.
Thanks so much for your response. I'm looking forward to more excellent discussions with you!
@beautyqueen26 (16030)
• United States
2 Jul 08
I had no idea there were so many
kinds of incense. I didn't know that
they were synthetic, either.
I used to sell incense at one of my
online shops and I didn't even know it
was synthetic! That's so terrible of me.
I will be more informed next time.
I'm a very craft oriented person
so I could definitely get on board with the
idea of making small batches of the real thing
for myself!
Thanks for all your amazing ideas and information.








