dhoni or gilchrist

Even i will say that my favourite wicket keeper is Gilchrist as he is a better keeper and batsman. Overall is better cricketeer . Lets not take anything away from Dhoni even he is a good cricketeer but he has a long way to go to compete with Gili.

well i should say that would be gilchrist with just 2 points ahead of his hard hitting.....

One of the best wicket keeper is Gilchrist.He is uncomparable.I dont think Dhoni has achieved even half of the ability and capability and the keeping perfection of Adam.Dhoni sometimes bats well.But we can rely entirely on him.I must admit that Adam too has failed in some matches.But he is more reliable than Dhoni.

I go for Gilly too...His immense talent can be justified through hisrecord and definitely Dhoni is nothing in comparison with Gilly...Moreover Gilly's sportsmanship just overcomes everything else...Well for Dhoni he has a long way to go.....

Obviously Gilchrist. Dhoni has a long way to go before he can become like Gilchrist. Both have nearly similar ways of batting, i.e both attack and it's always good to have a wicket-keep in a team who can bat really well like these guys.

Gilchrist is a Class-act. Dhoni is a Mass-act.

My favourite wicket keeper is Gilchrist .He has a wide range of attacking shots and has the more technically perfect batting compared to Dhoni.Gilchrist is very consistent in his attacking style of batting.But Dhoni has sacrificed attacking style of batting after taking the captaincy.Gilly is really a gentleman cricketer.All the best to Gilly and Dhoni.

Dhoni only ( true patriotic ). Plus he has been striving to improve wicket keeping. Batting, of course, has been forte right from the day one. If one is looking for class, then Adam is the front runner. For Dhoni, early days of crowning him as Captain has gained him more confidence. He is really onto the business and better days for India can be seen.

Adam Gilchrist is more competent and best wicket keeper than dhoni. I like gilchrist's play and he is consistent player pkc3000