Would you tell them?

@vicki2876 (5636)
Canada
March 18, 2008 8:00am CST
My daughter saw our neighbor's daughter smoking up in the woods yesterday. The girl is 16. The parents know she smokes cigarettes, drinks and is sexually active. Now a part of me figures they wouldn't care if she did drugs either. But I still see her a a little girl though at her age I was on my own. If it was my daughter I would want someone to tell me. So would you tell? Or mind your own business?
4 people like this
16 responses
@Darkwing (21583)
18 Mar 08
This is a difficult one. Part of me would want to tell the parents, but if, as you say, you don't think they care too much what she does, then maybe it would be better to befriend the daughter more, and invite her into your home, paying her attention. Ask your daughter to invite her back... protect her from the outside influences, and maybe she'll tell you why she is acting this way. My feeling is that she craves her parents' attention, and she's not getting it, so she's rebelling and doing things she feels might draw their attention, even if only in the form of punishment... it would show they cared something for her. My gut feeling is that she feels all alone in the world, she is battling with puberty and nobody's teaching her the right way to go. If she carries on the way she is, she's going to have a lousy adulthood. I would tend to ask her why she does all those things when she should be out having a "fun" time like all the other teenagers. I'd invite her to come to me if ever she has any problems regarding growing up, or with her parents... not to take her parents' place, but in order to gain her confidence. Somebody has to do that before she ends up in juvenile court, or a rehab centre. It makes me want to weep when I see this sort of thing going on. Thank goodness for my children, who have a lot of time for their kids. Brightest Blessings.
@vicki2876 (5636)
• Canada
18 Mar 08
Thanks so much for that observation. You may be right. Her father is a cop and both parents work and are very busy. I will try to do what I can here. I know she likes to be here. I am very involved with my children. That is one reason I want to do something because to let my children know that this is not okay for teens to do. Anyone for that matter. Having my children is the most wonderful blessing given to me. Thanks
1 person likes this
@Darkwing (21583)
18 Mar 08
You're quite welcome. I don't think you'll have too many problems with your own daughter, as she seems to be comfortable with telling you about her concerns for her friend. Also, now you've told me this friend's dad is a cop, I was wondering whether other kids taunt her, and call her a goody goody, giving her another reason to prove herself with them? Still, I think she craves adult attention and security, so it can't hurt for you to encourage her to your home whenever she feels the need to talk. Good luck.
2 people like this
@Darkwing (21583)
20 Mar 08
Ravenlady, thank you for your comments. I think it's more than likely that this girl is hanging around with a less than savoury crowd but if taken away from them, into her friend's home, so that she can build some trust with a well-meaning family, and have somebody to listen to her problems, rather than rebel by getting into all sorts of "bad" things, then she could see the light. If she's getting attention and is in company all the time she's in their home, their property should be safe, and also, I think that the daughter is able to communicate any misdemeanors to her Mum, if the friend tries to lead her astray. Granted, there is always a chance, when you try to help somebody, that it will backfire, but it's a risk you take, surely. I seem to live my life trying to help people, and certainly, things don't always work out, but nine times out of ten, I would say it does. It's all about decisions, and you hope against hope that you've made the right one... but there are no guarantees in life, my friend. If they abuse your help, then you cut the tie. Brightest Blessings and thanks once again, for your observations.
• United States
18 Mar 08
Yes I would tell them. But be prepared-- they may get defensive. I guess it would depend on what kind of relationship you have with them.Either way, if it were my child I would be grateful to have a caring neighbor and I would want to know!
2 people like this
@vicki2876 (5636)
• Canada
19 Mar 08
I am not very close to them. If it was a friend I sure would say something. But we only say hi kinda thing.
1 person likes this
• Italy
20 Mar 08
I think you would tell this to her parents, being soft, and saying that's just your opinion. Sometimes people don't like someone putting the nose in their business.
1 person likes this
@whywiki (6066)
• Canada
18 Mar 08
I wouldn't tell them. I don't think smoking pot is that big a deal. I think teen pregnancy is a lot worse that pot smoking. I think her parents probably already know the last thing they need to know is that everyone else knows. No I wouldn't tell.
@jairgirl (2877)
• United States
21 Mar 08
great question, i guess it will depend if i know the mom and how close the parents relationship is to the child. sometimes parents do know and others think they dont so it becomes awkward when someone say something to the parents and suddenly be told they already knew. here is the thing, i dont have a child yet but i am hoping that once i have my own i want to make the relationship so open and loving and that my child will not have a problem telling me his/her deepest secret. i think in our society now, parents tend to neglect teh child and work so much and didnt even get a chance to REALLY know the kid. also, some i seen they are so judging bout their kids and that pushes the kid not to be open. my husband have this friend and his friend's daughter is more open to him than her mom it's all because the mom is always upset to her and always tells her what to do and not to do. teh kid complain that she is in the age that she needs to explore and it is normal and ok and the more you try to hide/cage your kid the more it will want to fly. i guess, we just have to be there for them and let them know the consequences of their action. then we dont have to worry or wonder what they are doing on our back and wonder what kind of kid we have. i know it is easier said than done but i am hoping that i can start to be a my kid's bestfriend when they were young so they know they can always count on mommy and daddy. just my two cents! takecare
@vicki2876 (5636)
• Canada
22 Mar 08
Thanks a lot for your opinion. I saw he dad at the store the other day and never said anything. So I won't likely later. Seems like they let her do anything already and she might do something to Jessica if I tell. I also hope that I will be close enough to my children that they can talk to me about this stuff too.
@jairgirl (2877)
• United States
23 Mar 08
you're very much welcome. yes, i think like you i will be very cautious to bout my actions coz i might endanger not only my daughters life but maybe all of us, who knows. i may do something about it if the other kid is open to me and give me the signal that she wants me to do something about it. anyway, that is really a hard thing, i for one, wouldnt want anybody minding my business, unless of course i need or ask for it. i really wish that you and your kid/s will have a better communication and trust, that's the best foundation in any relationship not only in parenting but in any relationship there is. takecare!
• United States
23 Mar 08
i would, but thats just because thats the type of person i am and it irritates me that people dont want to raise there kids better and want nothing but the best possible future.
1 person likes this
@vicki2876 (5636)
• Canada
25 Mar 08
I know I would want to know if it was my child but I also get frustrated at loose parenting.
@SViswan (12051)
• India
6 May 08
Tough one! I know the parents don't care....but I would want to know too if it was my daughter. I think I will tell....and then leave it at that. If they tell me that they don't want to hear about it...then I wouldn't tell them the next time I saw her doing something I thought was wrong.
@avonrep1 (1862)
• United States
19 Mar 08
Me, I am telling, why? In 2 years she will be a legal adult and that is plenty of time to mess up your life. Though I did that kind of stuff when I was that age, and I turned out alright
• Singapore
21 Mar 08
i'd tell the parents. it's for the kid's own good...
@palonghorn (5479)
• United States
19 Mar 08
Coming from a different point of view, yes, I'd tell them, that if they let their daughter smoke, fine, but keep her from doing it in the woods. This coming from a wildland firefighter, knowing that human carelessness causes most of the fires we fight. I would have a problem with my daughter doing any of those at that age, but obviously those parents don't care what she does, so on that note I would just let it go at 'she was seen smoking (not what) in the woods, and the safety issues and let them take it from there.
@gantwick (849)
• United States
21 Mar 08
I'd probably say something. Hearing it from you would be a lot less embarrassing than hearing it from somebody with a warrant (if it ever got that far).
• Philippines
19 Mar 08
It really depends on who that person is. I might tell her parents about her activities, but then, like you said, the parents are aware of it. If I am a parent and this is happening to my kid, I would want someone to tell me. I think it's helpful and would at least give me a chance to help out my kid.
@RangaF (81)
• Sri Lanka
19 Mar 08
This is a sensitive question....... If the parants are of your closer ones then i would definitly be telling the parants.... If they are not known to me by personally but if i know the parents, then also i would tel them coz she is 16 and doesn't know the world so much.... if she is more than 18 definitly i would not tell them but i would prevent my daughter from having a closer friendship with her....
• Australia
19 Mar 08
As what you're saying, parents of girl smoking knows she is doing such things and they just ignore the problem. I don't think they will care about the problem even you have gone to tell them. So, the own thing you can do is to tell your daughter not to get along with that girl smoking.
• United States
19 Mar 08
I would definitely tell her parents, if only to get it off my conscience. I mean, I know that these parents may not do anything about it, but they have the right to know what their little girl is doing. I would tell her parents right away, then no matter what happens, I know that I did my part.
• United States
19 Mar 08
Yea I hate it happened. But if she is already partaken in that. There is really nothing that you can do. Just make sure your girl is being taught the right thing. If you bring her up in the way she should go then you will be ok.