What do you think they would be doing if they didnt find the book of shadows??
@cinderella2007 (2662)
March 24, 2008 4:47am CST
Although i have throughly enjoyed Charmed and rate it 5 star, im just wondering what do you think they would be doing if theynever found the book of shadows??
Prue obviously wouldnt have died, they wouldnt have found Paige, maybe they would have met up with their dad Victor but would they have the relationship they have now as it was Pheobe who kept in contact with Victor in secret.
They would never had seen their mum and Grams, wouldnt need the grandfathers clock/windows fixing on a regular basis.
More importantly would Piper still have married Leo?
What do you think would they would be like if they werent witches?
1 person likes this
6 responses
@TempusTime (99)
• United States
28 Sep 08
I find it quite obvious, that even without the Book of Shadows, the sisters would have found out about their powers anyway. Think about it. Wouldn't Penny(their "grams"), or Patty(their mom) have appeared to let them know about their powers? And what about the elders, and the Angel of Destiny? They specifically told them that they needed to figure out their powers so that they could help save good, or evil would take over, so if they never figured out about their powers, wouldn't there be no show, and wouldn't the title be named something different other than Charmed? Because there is a reason that it was named Charmed in the first place...:)
@cinderella2007 (2662)
•
16 Oct 08
I think it would be interesting if they did a episode of how the sisters would be if they didn't find the Book of Shadows and also another episode showing the sisters 10 years later from when the show finished so that we know what happened to them all!!
@leegen (13)
• Philippines
7 Sep 08
i think if they didn't found the book of shadow they live a normal life like an ordinary people like us but eventhough they have a hard time i think they are happy because they made the most of what life has bring.they conquer their own fear,they even sacrifice their own happiness for the sake of others and i realy admire them because not all of us can sacrifice ourself for the sake of others.
@cinderella2007 (2662)
•
9 Sep 08
It would be interesting to find out what would have happened if they didnt find the book of shadows even if it was their destiny. Yes I agree with you, they did sacrifice their own happiness to save innocents and they are admirable as not every one is like that!!
Thanks for responding.
@twoey68 (13627)
• United States
5 Oct 08
I think Prue would have went on to open her own auction house since she is so driven when it came to work and married some powerful man. I think Piper would have went on to be a famous chef and seeing the love she and Leo shared I think they still would have met somehow and had a house full of kids. I think Pheobe would have gone into something like the gossip writer and married Cole and had some kids b/c she just adores kids. As for Paige, I think she would have spent her life searching for herself. BTW, I love this show.
[b]**AT PEACE WITHIN**
~~STAND STRONG IN YOUR BELIEFS~~[/b]
@irishidid (8688)
• United States
1 Aug 08
Pru would have ended up as a female wrestler
Piper would have become a librarian
Phoebe would have worked at Dairy Queen.
And Paige would have kicked some alien butt with her high power semi-auto peg leg!
@creative_genius (992)
•
4 Aug 08
I suspect if the Book of Shadows wasn't found then Piper wouldn't meet Leo and marry him. I think she would open her club and run it, she seems very business driven.
I suspect Phoebe would be a journalist as she seems to love a good gossip and I imagine Prue marrying someone rich and becoming a lady of leisure.
They would be the same people just without their magic powers, they's still be close as sisters I think. Is that imaginative enough?!
@cinderella2007 (2662)
•
7 Aug 08
Piper might have met Leo as you do see them as children playing together. Chasing each other round the house, at that time they did have their powers which were binded later until the release of the book of shadows.
I dont think they would have married though. She probably would have her club or restaurant as she is a chef!!
I thin Phoebe would have into journalism as she was an agony aunt and she loved that. Prue would probably meet have met someone hunky at the Auction place where she worked like mad!! As for Paige, who knows as we wouldnt have met her!!
That was very imaginative, didnt think you watched Charmed!!
@cinderella2007 (2662)
•
1 Aug 08
I know there would be no show but use your imagination. What would you like the girls to be doing if they didnt open the book of shadows?? Would they still get attacked by demons?? Would Pru go out with Andy?? Piper woud know Leo but would she still have married him?? He wouldnt be ble to tell her he is a whitelighter due to the fact tht they dont know about magic??
Thanks for responding.
