Your Thoughts On Banning

United States
April 9, 2008 10:19am CST
I would like to know your thoughts on book banning. Think for a moment. Are there books in your personal library that could be deemed threatening or offensive. I for one have some, and the thought that someone could persecute me for the books I own is a somber one. I suppose in some countries this could actually happen and probably does. Are we, as Americans, that far removed from a similar circumstance in our own country? The Spokesman
3 people like this
10 responses
@emeraldisle (13139)
• United States
9 Apr 08
Sadly as someone else already pointed out book banning does happen here in the USA. I know in my own state some counties won't allow certain authors to be placed in the school libraries. One such author is Judy Blume, who in my opinion writes some great young adult books, but some find her offensive. Book banning shouldn't happen. When we allow books to be banned we are allowing others to decide what is allowable. Once we do that they can easily move towards limiting far more. Where do we draw the line, who decides what is acceptable and what isn't? And if we do allow it to happen with books what will be next?
• United States
9 Apr 08
So true. To me, banning a book by Judy Blume seems absurd. If you don't want your daughter reading about a girl who gets her period or whatever, well, I don't even know how to respond to that. I think sometimes we as parents are threatened by what's out there because we haven't done our jobs.
2 people like this
@emeraldisle (13139)
• United States
10 Apr 08
Well those who want her banned do so because her books use such words as "menstruation" Heaven forbid we mention such things to our teenage daughters. To me she is a fantastic author who is great for young adults. I cannot understand people who feel the need to ban books. You don't want to read it? Fine, that's your choice but let me have the same choice.
1 person likes this
@tinkerick (1257)
• United States
9 Apr 08
I still am dumbfounded by how many books continue to be banned in the U.S. In a country that boasts freedom, we still try to control many aspects of that very freedom. Most of the control issues are derived out of fear. What exactly people fear kids (and adults) will get out of certain books, I'm not quite sure. But as previously pointed out, it should be up to the parents to direct what their children can and can't read. This extends into every genre and activity including internet access, TV watching, food, and video games. We as parents should be considered lazy if we demand the government (local, state or federal) to pass laws to control what our children encounter.
1 person likes this
• United States
9 Apr 08
Stephen King gave a lecture in Virginia some years ago and told students that they should find out which books had been banned and run, not walk, to their local bookstore and buy those very books. On the issue of parenting I certainly agree that parents are slack and lazy when it comes to raising their children.
@Ravenladyj (22904)
• United States
10 Apr 08
I think that book banning is absolutely insane..Like someone mentioned if you dont like the book or if you dont want your kids reading then DONT BUY OR BORROW IT..but to ban a book from EVERYONE is IMO WRONG...I know I own and/or have read several books that are "banned" or have been in the past and actually there are some titles that I'd love to buy that are on the ban list.
@eden32 (3973)
• United States
9 Apr 08
Books are banned in communities in the US constantly. Check out: http://www.ala.org/ala/oif/bannedbooksweek/bannedbooksweek.cfm . Some of the common 'offending books' are Tom Sawyer, Huck Finn, the Harry Potter series, To Kill a Mocking Bird, I Know Why the Caged Bird Sings by Maya Angelou, and Of Mice and Men. There's a list of 100 frequently challenged books on that site. Books should NEVER be banned or censored, ever. When I looked at the list of challenged & banned books, I was quite proud to realize I had about 75% of the books in question on my shelves.
1 person likes this
9 Apr 08
Most challenged book of 2006; "And Tango Makes Three." Two male penguins, one egg... I want that book! I really want that book! Oh that's it... I have a new ambition! To author a book and get it on that list! Thanks for the info eden32!
1 person likes this
• United States
9 Apr 08
And proud you should be. I totally agree, and, yes we do experience banning here although thank God no one is imprisoned for owning these books. At least I hope not. I posted this topic because, as a writer in my own right, I have a big problem with censorship. Great response, Eden.
1 person likes this
@michelyn (717)
• United States
9 Apr 08
Unfortunately, we are not that far removed. The banning of books is an atrocity and tramples on our right to freedom of speech. Our once democracy is becoming quite diluted with all the controls and laws being created to disallow more and more. People should be allowed to read whatever they choose to read and then be held accountable for their actions resulting from the reading and ONLY THEN! Reading should never be a crime. Reading is knowledge and a form of history even if it's fictional. Most authors resort to using environmental descriptions of current standards. Just because standards change and certain things become no longer politically correct is no reason to not allow people the knowledge of said things.
• United States
9 Apr 08
Your thoughtful response strikes at the ver heart of the discussion. After I posted the topic I began to think about books I possess that the government would probably label downright subversive. I wish to strongly state that I have no desire to engage in any type of criminal behavior on account of what I choose to read, but in this day and age our government has, as you said, diluted our democracy.
1 person likes this
• United States
9 Apr 08
I believe that individuals over the age of consent (18 in most of the U.S.) should be allowed to own, read, and loan to other consenting adults any book they choose. There are some books that are not appropriate for children, but I have never run across a book that I thought should be banned altogether. I believe people who are old enough to make their own decisions should be free to do so without any restrictions except where their decisions harm another person or living being. As far as banning books from schools, I believe teachers, administrators, parents, and school librarians should be jointly responsible for choosing what books are acceptable for what age groups.
• United States
9 Apr 08
See, there's the problem. While I agree strongly with what you said in the first part of your post I have to say that it is the schools,teachers,administrators,librarians,and parents who have failed by allowing personal agendas to get in the way of decision making. Let's say that an ultra-conserative, Bible Belt librarian in a small southern town has a problem with say, a book on Paganism. Said librarian then takes it upon herself to enforce her will on the community by having the book banned. No, these groups you mentioned have too much power in this realm. Great response. I'm tabbing it as best.
@Hatley (163781)
• Garden Grove, California
10 Apr 08
I certainly hope we are not closeto book banning as once thatis started all books will be banned for one reason or another. What Ihave in my personal library should be nobody's business but my own.I have a wide array of genres and read voraciously. I do not sell my books or give them away as they get read more than once by me if they are any good at all.My loves of authors are eclectic.
@lateesha (94)
10 Apr 08
well i dont really think so i mean all the books i no of they are great
10 Apr 08
Lots of books have been banned in the US as well as other countries. I think people should be free to read what they like. Clockwork Orange, Of Mice and Men and many other books were banned at some point. It is interesting that a lot of books which were banned ended up being very successful sellers. I studied Of Mice and Men at school!
@Elixiress (3878)
9 Apr 08
I don't have any books that I would deem threatening, but I think it is stupid to ban them, because it isn't as though books are forced on people. An individual has the choice to read a book and put a book down, fair enough threatening books should come with warning.