Brooke White Contestant on American Idol

United States
April 30, 2008 1:18pm CST
What do you think Brooke's are for winning American Idol. How far do you think she will go? Do you like her voice? I do, even though her voice is not one of the strongest I like her voice because it is different. Sometimes she doesnt pick the right songs. She needs to pick some better for her. If should could do something to really shake the judges up that would be great.
2 people like this
5 responses
@Shaun72 (15959)
• Palatka, Florida
1 May 08
I know I will miss her now that she has gotten voted off of American Idol. I really liked her she was a really good singer. I guess other Americans didn't think so though. Her and David Archuleta were the two best singers to me on American Idol.
• United States
1 May 08
I think she was a better singer even though she did not have a powerful voice. I like David C. We will miss Brooke....
@KrauseHome (36448)
• United States
30 Apr 08
I Like Brooke, and personally I think out of the 5 left, she had better be #2, as overall she does offer a lot of originality, a lot of others have never shown. I think a lot of it from here will be Song Choice, and people's favorite. I wish she could have more help with Song choice to prove who she really is, and yes, she does need to shake it up some, and prove to America she deserves to be here. Personally, I am still Glad she is still here.
• United States
30 Apr 08
I am glad she is still their too. I wish I could call her up and give her a list of songs to sing each week.
• United States
30 Apr 08
Last night I only voted for her and David C. We shall see what happens tonight. I wanted Kristy Lee to at least make it to the final 4, but that didn't happen. I am not too happy that Syiesha and David A. are still in it, but what can you do?? I just watch and wait for the beginning of the next season, the opening auditions is the best part of the show. I'm patiently waiting for 'So You Think You Can Dance'. That's a great show.
• United States
30 Apr 08
I think Kristy Lee improved and got better each week. I think she could make a country album.
• United States
30 Apr 08
Brooke is one of my all around favorites- she has been from her audition. (Loved Michael Johns at his, too, but what can you do?) Will she win? I would be surprised, but when she sang that second song last night, I poked hubby and said "and THAT is why she is still in the top 5!" I think it will come down to the two Davids barring any shockers like when Michael left (one real shocker of the season and it had to be him?!?) and I hope Brooke is up there with them as the final three. To be honest I didn't even realize how much I wanted Brooke to stay until I burst out in a cheer when she was safe last week. Anyway, I am not one to really get vocal at the TV, but I was absolutely ecstatic (and surprised and relieved to be honest...lol).
• United States
30 Apr 08
I was ecstatic that she was safe too.... we'll see what happens, I dont think she will win either.
• Canada
30 Apr 08
To be honest, I am surprised that she is still in the competition. I think that she is good but I do not think that she will be known as one of the greats.
• United States
30 Apr 08
Yes she is good, but i guess you would not catergorize her voice as great, but different.