How do you punish your kids?

United States
November 1, 2006 1:03pm CST
I give mine spankings from time to time. Little slaps on the hand and such. They get put in time outs as well. What is the big deal? Why do I get stares when we're out and I slap my son on the hand for acting up? It's not like I punched him in the face.
5 responses
• United States
1 Nov 06
I punish my child by letting life teach him what he needs to learn. I focus on directing him into positive experiences and have found out that there is little need for corpral punishment. If I hit him, I teach him that violence is a solution. If I scream and yell, he can't learn how to communicate. Sometimes I falter. I snap at him. It is during those times that I teach him the best lesson of all. I sit him down and talk to him about how I am not perfect. That none of us are. He needs to know that I do not belong on a pedisol. I can teach him only what I know. The best lesson that I have learned is I need to ask myself what he wants and figure out how to teach him to get it without harming others. It is working out well so far.
2 people like this
• United States
1 Nov 06
Hitting your children does not teach that violence is a solution. I think you are wrong there.
1 person likes this
@meeoww (1174)
• United States
1 Nov 06
But the part about communication is right on the button. Spankings, done correctly, are not violent. We're not beating the kids up. Spankings only serve as a consequence. Several times I needed only to ask them.."Do you want to get spanked?" and that ended the poor behavior right there. Aloha!
2 people like this
@jenw06 (165)
• United States
1 Nov 06
I also feel that spankings do not promote a person violence. I was spanked when I was young am I voilent person no. I spank my kids if they need to be spanked, I don't do it in public. But all I have to do is look at them and they will freeze. Are my kids abused no, they are very happy, healthy children. Love me and I love them very much and they know that when they are discplined its for their own good.
1 person likes this
@meeoww (1174)
• United States
1 Nov 06
Oh, my family's kids (including my siblings & myself) were spanked when needed. Or stood in the corner. But now that they're in college, we've all done well in school and none have ever been in trouble at school or with the police. The kids are smart young adults with good judgement. Those that stare at you... Those are the same morons who don't reprimand their little monsters, send them to school as if the teachers were babysitters, then take away their authority of consequences. The same morons whose little monsters are running around, crawling all over the place, and disrupting shelves, yet they themselves are nowhere to be seen. I ADORE well mannered children, but we know that children will be children. Everyone has their own ideas of how to reprimand, I guess, but you sound like you're a good mommy to me! Aloha!
• United States
2 Nov 06
I agree, being an absentee parent is distructive. I also agree that someone can turn out to be a well mannered individual with class even if they were spanked as a child. I think where we disagree is on the issue of spanking as a necessity. I believe there are other methods that are just as effective that don't require it. My sons mother is borderline abusive with her spanking and corrective action she uses. You do not seem to be that way. What you have employed has returned a desired result. In the case of my son and his mother all I see is that she has the capacity to drive fear into him. He is left without the understanding of why. He only knows that his mother disapproves and lashes out physically. I am quite sure that the spanking you speak of is not one in the same.
1 person likes this
• United States
2 Nov 06
I let mine learn on their own. It is like the theory that they dont really know the stove it hot until they touch it and get burned. They will never touch the stove again after that. As for acting up in public, it is embarasing so i will bring lots of distractions, but if people are going to be rude about me bringing my kid in public it is their problem and they probablly dont have kids to understand just how they act.
1 person likes this
• United States
2 Nov 06
also, if i loose my temper cuz they're jsut driving me up a wall, i put them in bed and i take a nap or chillout. If a little physiical wakeup call is what they need so they dont hurt themselves is what they need then fine, but i learned that instead of a smack, simply giving them a distraction will steer them ina different direction and forget about what they were doing. Like my son like to try to roll off the changing table. i used to be so worried adn i would smack him on his butt to get him to stop. but then i felt bad about that and i tried something different. now we have a little game we play when he's on the table and doesnt try to crawl off anymore cuz he's too busy playing the game.
1 person likes this
@hariharan23 (1075)
• India
2 Nov 06
often by yelling at them
1 person likes this
• United States
2 Nov 06
Yelling as a form of punishment?
• United States
7 Nov 06
I am a yeller, I will admit to that, and I never realized what an impact it had on them. I have to admit I do have pretty good kids, and it is a matter of talking things out. I will give them a choice of punishment though. I like that idea! I have used time outs for punishment, sending them to their room, and taking things away, and grounding. We also do alot of talking.
1 person likes this
• United States
7 Nov 06
I am a yeller, I will admit to that, and I never realized what an impact it had on them. I have to admit I do have pretty good kids, and it is a matter of talking things out. I will give them a choice of punishment though. I like that idea! I have used time outs for punishment, sending them to their room, and taking things away, and grounding. We also do alot of talking.
1 person likes this
@RumDusk (299)
• United States
13 Nov 06
The reason you fill like that is because those that got their back side bet when they were little, said to them self " i'm not going to bet my kids." and they feel that no one else should either and it spreaded, so now when you spank your kids you feel you are doing wrong because other people say you are doing wrong. so those same people say you should take something from the child, that teaches them not to be bad or to do wrong. BULL i say. if you take from them when they do wrong all you doing it teach them is, to take from others because they dont like what was dont to them. they will end up in the lock up. I say spank them and put them in the room. so as they get older they will have learn that if you do wrong to others your freedom will bill taken away. ie locked up.