Are we eating too much?

@worthy (2413)
India
May 20, 2008 2:33am CST
Do you think that the present food shortage and price rise is because we are now eating too much and buying too much?? Do you agree? Or, is it because of some real defective management in distribution system,hoarding and corruption prevalent? If you found out that the real reason is over-eating,then would you seriously cut down on your food intake,so that other under-privileged people could get some food to eat? Do you care?
5 people like this
11 responses
@Aussies2007 (5336)
• Australia
20 May 08
Food shortage is usually caused by bad weather destroying the crops or preventing them growing due to lack of rain. This is the real scare about climate change. We have to grow food to feed 6.5 billion people every day. Just try to think of that for a minute. Our average consumption would be at least two pounds of food for each person. That's mean we have to produce 13 billion pounds of food every day in order to feed our ever growing population. If we have a major natural disaster over a major productive country... we are in big trouble. Some people eat too much... but they can only eat so much. And I don't think that it is the reason for any food shortage.
@worthy (2413)
• India
21 May 08
thanks to both of you for your valuable input.Aussies2007,like you,i too strongly believe that population growth must be controlled if we care for the future and next generation.
1 person likes this
• Australia
21 May 08
I actually read a couple of months ago that China would have a food shortage by 2020... as it is using its agricultural land for housing and industries. It has already taken 7 per cent of its agricultural land. As the population grows... you need more land to lodge them... and more land to feed them. People keep telling me that there is plenty of land. But half of the land is either no good for agriculture or not practical for housing.
2 people like this
21 May 08
I think its mearly beacuse a major percentage . that is India and china's peole are more finacilay strong and more people are now able to eat and go for other basic neccisites of life ...as compare to previous years. Now they if they want they may even wont want to export their agricultural products to other nations ( both developed and underdeveloped) , beacause teir oen home market is big .. they can sustain them selves with that only. So western countries and other nations should really need to start producing thie own ...rather gettng industrialized day by day and ruining the nevironment.
2 people like this
@aplaza (630)
• Netherlands
20 May 08
That really isn't likely. If prices rise so much here that I can't buy food then nobody is going to give me a meal regardless if you and your whole family ate less overall. Eating less won't infulence the price of things. The price you pay in a store for a product is made up of many components such as the cost to produce it, transport it, package it, tax etc etc. When you consider that transport for example will be influenced by how much gas/diesel costs and that in turn is traded in USD you'll realise that having a weak dollar is probably the cause of the higher prices. Although a little less corruption and better management is never a bad thing either.
@worthy (2413)
• India
21 May 08
very good points you have mentioned here aplaza responsible for the price hike. but don't you think a major factor which determines prices of commodities, is their demand and supply.if supply is proportionate to demand then there is no question of price rise.but here ,it seems that supply is lagging behind the demand of food stuffs,hence the shortage and price hike. of coarse the inflation has also a big part to play
1 person likes this
@aplaza (630)
• Netherlands
21 May 08
Supply and Demand is also a contributing factor. However I'm absolutely certain that if I ate less nobody but nobody would profit from it. It wouldn't mean that there would be more for the starving people in this world. Eating less would simply mean that I have an extra box of rice in my cupboard at the end of the year. Now don't get me wrong. The idea is commendable. I really think it would be a nice thing to do. It's just that as long as the dollar is weak, oil is traded in dollars and things like corruption are rampant that I don't see even one hungry person getting extra food if I ate less.
2 people like this
@worthy (2413)
• India
31 May 08
that is right.thanks for the additional inputs aplaza.hope something is done to rectify this situation.every living being should have the basic requirements -home,food and shelter atleast.
1 person likes this
@subha12 (18441)
• India
20 May 08
i do not think we are eating yoo much. actually there are many factors for this situation. they say 1. there has not been any incraese in productuion for long,whereas the demand increases. 2. many food grains are used as alternatic=ve fuels 3,mainly the population growth
2 people like this
@worthy (2413)
• India
21 May 08
demand vs supply.that's so right.yes,the alarming rate of population growth has a lot to do with increased demand and shortage of supplies.Land is not growing..we must remember that
1 person likes this
@lorelai (1558)
• Italy
30 May 08
very interesting discussion. I don't think that people eat too much...well some do but I doubt that's the reason that prices got so high. I think that there's someone who wants to earn a lot of money and is sitting on the top of the chaing. I actually think that THEY rised prices so much only because they can. I know this big chane of food whose owner is really but really rich, he has shops in didfferent bgger towns and what he does when he opens the shop in some smaller town is to buy the small shops that were there before him, or he starts selling them stuff so more or less every shop is his in that town and people have to buy from him. So he can decde about the prices. In a bigger town, although its a same chane, same things cost much less than in the smaller town. Then, during the summer, when there are many tourists in this little town I am telling you about, he rise the prices for at lest 15% to 20% and he does it because he owns most of the shops in the town so he can set the price as high as he wants. I hope that I have prooved my theory with the example I gave. If 1l of milk cost 80 cents or even less during the winter why then if you go to that town on 1st July you are going to pay for the same liter of milk at least $1.20 and on 1 September the milk will go back to 80 cents? He does that only because he knows that he can and that people will still buy in his shop rather than drive for several miles to get to another town, a bigger one. And even if people go to a different town to buy food they won't go every day, so they will still buy some of the stuff in his shops.
2 people like this
@worthy (2413)
• India
31 May 08
o yes,lorelai,you have mentioned a very pertinent point.so many new points come up about we don't have much idea too.thanks lorelai
1 person likes this
@anujain75 (1059)
• India
20 May 08
The fact is people of some country eats five times than an Indian.Rise in price of esse tial commodities depends on many factor. Lower crop production.Some timme due to lower crop production the demand supply ratio cannot meet.So that the price of the crops rises. Artificial crisis. This done by storing the food in ware houses to rise the price of the commodites when the price of commodity rises then they sell. Importing the food in high price to meet the demand.
@worthy (2413)
• India
21 May 08
thanks anujain for mentioning such important factors.you are so right
1 person likes this
@figjam00 (1445)
• India
20 May 08
The comments made by George W Bush created quite a stir among Indians that Indians eat to much and this causes increse in the global food prices. Well statistically this can be biter fact but the reason is something else. The distribution system in India is very much biased as supply side is owned by the previlage ones. The thing is I don't care all I need is food that fills my tummy.
2 people like this
@worthy (2413)
• India
21 May 08
i too was stirred by this comment,no doubt. you are so honest in saying that you need food to fill your tummy,but we can save a little for others if it really helps.thanks for your good answer figjam
1 person likes this
@raghwagh (1527)
• India
2 Jun 08
Are you making this statement in response to the statement made by Bush recently, thin I think this is a foolish statment. In some countries food is wasted like nothing. India is now growing and becoming more strong and developed and I think this should not hurt others. Eating toomuch or less is not in ones hands. If one is hungry he eats what he can affort and digest. Obvioudly people dont eat just for fun. It is based on requirement and availability.
1 person likes this
@worthy (2413)
• India
13 Jun 08
i agree.thanks for a very good answer
@apsara60 (6610)
• Israel
30 May 08
I don't think food shortage is due to over eating of people. If people are buying more food, indirectly the money is in flow and this round and round flow of money in the market helps economy and does not harm anyone. Yes hoarding and corruption surely can be the reason for this. Let me tell you I am already eating less now a days as I want to loose weight. I don't know about others, but I am definitely not wasting any food. Of course I do care and wish every body had enough to eat.
1 person likes this
@worthy (2413)
• India
31 May 08
Its heartening to know there are so many people around who care for the so called-lesser people.thanks for the good answer apsara
1 person likes this
@rb200406 (1824)
• India
30 May 08
The reason is partly correct.Actually there i no control .Rich are buying everything with high cost & wasting it also .But many poor people are not able to purchase them.Also the population increase is also one of the main reason.
1 person likes this
@worthy (2413)
• India
31 May 08
That is right rb.good points.thanks for responding friend
1 person likes this
@Deea48 (1166)
• United States
11 Jun 08
Well I think the cost is more related to the extreme cost of gas which is having a trickel down effect. At least that is the case for here in the USA. I think it has alot to do with the miss management of our goverment that we are now in the deep trouble we are in. Someone is getting very rich and it is not the regular guy thats for sure.
1 person likes this
@worthy (2413)
• India
13 Jun 08
that's for sure indeed.the general public is certainly not the one.
@deepakde (156)
• India
10 Jun 08
Yes i agree with ur statement . if i buying some .it so expensive
1 person likes this
@worthy (2413)
• India
13 Jun 08
yes deepak,prices have risen very high.even the basic necessities are also going out of reach for the under privileged and hard for the common public.