Have you ever thought about leaving your mate because of their mother?

@cream97 (29087)
United States
May 26, 2008 1:29pm CST
I have many times... I am tired of my husband's mom... She is trying to do everything to bring me down.. I have gotten to the point, where I don't want to see her anymore... But still she and her husband shows up unexpectedly at my house.. I hate when they do this, and never call. She comes over and act as if all is well between me and her, but on my end, it is not.. What should I do? I am totally perplexed with this situation..
15 people like this
47 responses
@nilzerous1 (2434)
• India
26 May 08
This is the tips you may find helpful. Whenever she appears, simply go out for shopping or anywhere you feel comfortable. Also let them know modestly that you do not like their presence much by body language. Hopefully, they will understand.
2 people like this
• India
26 May 08
I think that't the only only to get rid of them.
2 people like this
• United States
9 Jul 08
Those are really good tips! I had not considered doing anything like that. I don't have a mother in law situation to deal with, but I do have "friends" whom I don't care to deal with anymore. Thanks for the ideas.
@cream97 (29087)
• United States
26 May 08
Yes, I do give that off.. That is one of the reasons why they have not asked us to stay with us..
2 people like this
• United States
26 May 08
I have never called to tell family I was coming and no one ever calls me. We just don't do that. I love my in laws! They live right across the road from me. Even though they live right across the road sometimes I don't see them every week. I think you need to sit down with your husband and his parents and get everything straightened out. She may not know she is bothering you.
@cream97 (29087)
• United States
26 May 08
Oh trust me, she knows...
2 people like this
@limcyjain (3516)
• India
26 May 08
I too am facing a similar situation like yours and am fedup of my mother in law but i have never thought of leaving my husband as i love him dearly and he too tries his level best to make life comfortable for me. We do sometimes fight over because of his mother but at the end i love him dearly. I have now found a solution by ignoring my mother in law. I simply dont care what she is saying or doing and if she tries to create and issue then i am not going to take it lying down. I protest and she knows this very well so she now does not try to confront me.
@yvonne1968 (1063)
• United States
16 Jun 08
Actually the longest relationship i ever had ended because he was such a momma's boy and she was a total witch. They both smoked and he listened to every word she use to say. We could never go out and do anything or say anything without her butting in her 2 cents, even when we werent talking to her. I would want to go out bike riding and she would stick her nose in and say ohhh no you cant do that you need to stay here and clean up after me.. bla bla bla i was so glad to be rid of them both, they made me miserable.
1 person likes this
@cream97 (29087)
• United States
19 Jun 08
Yes, a relationship as this, is enough to want to get rid of someone.. I agree. I would not be happy at all in this myself.. He needs to speak up for himself, and not let his mom, dictate every thing that he does..
1 person likes this
@kezabelle (2974)
26 May 08
God no I wont give her the satisfaction of coming between us! The best thing you can do is ignore her make out that it doesnt bother you trust me it annoys my partners mother more than anything else I can do! As for the coming over dont answer the door for a few times and if she mentions it just nicely say oh we must have been out maybe you can ring next time save you wasting your time be polite and smile a lot might get your point across better than getting upset
2 people like this
@cream97 (29087)
• United States
26 May 08
I wish I could do this, but her husband is always with her, and plus my kids are always home, so that tends to make noise come from my home. Sometimes if she just comes over, i will go into another room..
2 people like this
@geeta100 (35)
• India
26 May 08
hello my mother is everything for me because she took me in that condition through which i am able to earn and make my own reputation. yes i am also agree that partner is also very useful but just you think thatyour mother is your partner since you was not able to walk.
• United States
30 May 08
I know it wil be hard but you have to tell your husband and most importantly your mother-in law how you feel.
1 person likes this
@checapricorn (16061)
• United States
9 Jul 08
I'm sorry that it's still happening cream..How about writing her a letter so you can express all what you feel deep inside, in that way, you will be healed too! and hopefully, she will realize how she is helping you to have a unhappy married life because of her!
• United States
9 Jul 08
That might be a great help cream...Let's see what happen!
@cream97 (29087)
• United States
9 Jul 08
Yes, that is what, I plan to do. I was thinking about writing her a two page letter, letting her know how I feel and what I want from her.. I may do this soon.. Thanks for the enlightment!
@cream97 (29087)
• United States
9 Jul 08
Yes, let us see what happens.. I plan to give it to her, but, i don't want anyone reading but her..
@jcj_111776 (3216)
• Philippines
27 May 08
Hi cream. I'm sorry that you're having a difficult time with your mother-in-law. But if I were in your shoes....NO. I do have a very good relationhip with my own mother-in-law. And if things were the exact opposite, I won't give her the pleasure of seeing me defeated. I made a promise to spend my life with my husband, and if she will give me h*ll, then I'll return the favor, with a more respectful gesture. After all, she's the mother of my husband. You should try talking to your husband and explain to him the real deal between you and his mom. That not everything he sees is ok. I know, it's going to be a difficult situation for him but it's very important that he tries to be emotionally neutral. And if you feel that he's being neutral, and if you can, try to talk to your mother-in-law. With your husband, in the middle of it. Tell her what you feel about the situation and if you're deeply sure that she's giving you problems, then ask her directly WHY?If she has some issues, then she needs to lay them out in the open. So finally you'll have an idea why she's doing it to you. Just make 100% sure, that your husband is emotionally ready not to take any sides. Because that will worsen the situation. Goodluck and I do hope that things will turn out fine between the two of you.
• Philippines
27 May 08
My own sister-in-law went through a similar situation. But things were a lot worse. To the point where she and my mother ended up in an ugly, bitter and long argument. Fortunately, they have settled everything between them. There are days when the tension is felt but at least, they've been honest about what they both felt. It was rather not easy to listen and watch. Just expect the worst that can happen if you ever get the chance to talk to her. But still remain hopeful that maybe something good will come out of that conversation.
@cream97 (29087)
• United States
27 May 08
Thanks! I hope so too.. I will admit that she does have some issues that needs to be laid out on the table because, not admitting them is only going to make things much worser..
1 person likes this
@cream97 (29087)
• United States
27 May 08
Yes, if it is for the worst, then I know she just is not worth crying over... She does not deserve a wonderful daughter-in-law like me..
@julyteen (13252)
• Davao, Philippines
11 Jun 08
i've never been in such a situation yet. i hope i won't. but stories like that are so common and familiar. maybe the best way to treat that problem is to live with your husband away from his parents. but be patience with them still, after all, they are your husbands' parents and the grandparents of your children. it's still better to treat them nice.
1 person likes this
• United States
20 Jun 08
I can understand where you are coming from. My dad asked me once if I was going to let my MIL ruin my life and come between my husband and I. Was I going to let her ruin a wonderful marriage? I was to the point also of just being done because I knew she did not like me and I felt judged every time we went around his family. If he is a mammas boy or in with a tight knit family it is really hard on a wife to fit in and feel like part of the family. at least that was my case. Have you tried sitting down and talking to your MIL. I mean really talking to her. Have you tried to tell her how you feel? My MIL are slowly getting closer but I have tried to just talk to her and ask her advice. I have tried to let go of some of the resentment I have been hanging on to from past experiences (Hers and a past MIL that did me real bad) We are getting there but it has been a slow process for us. Adjusting to a new family can be very hard but it can be done with good communication and effort from all the people involved.
• United States
20 Jun 08
wow you are in a difficult place. Living with them had to be hard and now she isn't wanting to let you all go. she is used to being in your life so much that I think she is trying to hang on to that. My MIL has mentioned for us to come live up there by them. No thanks because not only would she be in our business the rest of the family would be also. I feel for you because I know if we lived closer I would be in just about the same boat. I think your husband is going to have to be the one to tell her. He can do it nicely but be firm. He needs to tell her that this is your home and while he appreciates the fact they have helped you all out in the past you all would like some privacy that comes with living on your own. He can explain that he loves them to visit but would appreciate a phone call before them coming over and maybe let them know that he would like the visits to be less frequent. maybe you all could arrange family dinner once a week so that she don't feel like you all are trying to push her completely out of your lives. I hope that you all can work through this and things get better for you.
@cream97 (29087)
• United States
20 Jun 08
Yes, I hope so too. But communication is the key here. His parents need to come up with this solution. They must be looking for me to say something, but I am not.. If they are bugged by my distance, then, they should offer this resolution. I agree with you.. If they have a problem with my space, then they should direct this to me, instead of my husband.. I don't know why they refuse to come to me. After all the conversations that I have had in the past with my mil were very open between me and her.. She knows that I am bold when it comes to my feelings.. I know that they can tell that I want my space, Oh and do I! I have it now, and they still come over without calling.. They come over and always expect to come into my house, even if they don't know my circumstances. This makes me mad.. I tell my husband about it, and now I notice that his dad calls more often.. I am not sure if he said anything about it to his parents. But I did notice a difference.. So, I am assuming he may could have had a talk with them about my limitations..
@cream97 (29087)
• United States
20 Jun 08
Yes, I will admit, that all of this does.. I have talked to my mil until there are no words left to say to her.. It is difficult. My situation is difficult. You see, I have lived with my in laws for 5 years. This has been very hard on me. Now that we have our own place, my husband and I with my kids, it is so much easier to not be around them. But I still think that they have a hard time of letting go even though we are all gone from the same house. They come around often, too much that is..
@jer31558 (3683)
• United States
26 May 08
No, I haven't. In fact, my wife's mother lives with us. As I have never been in your situation, I really do know what you should do. The only thing I could suggest is to perhaps seek some type of family counseling where everyone is there together if that is at all possible. I hope you get sorted out, because I can tell from your post how much you are troubled by your mil.
1 person likes this
@cream97 (29087)
• United States
26 May 08
Yes, I am troubled, but not to the point of going crazy... This is just a situation that needs to be dealt with...
1 person likes this
@borgborg (821)
• Philippines
28 May 08
i have not. you & your mother-in-law should have a good relationship at all times. coz she is the only person that knows your husband more than you do. try to find ways to win her heart. buy her gifts even if there is no occasion, treat her to dinner, or just spend time chitchatting with her when you do not have anything to do. it is also wise to talk about it with you husband. ask for help on how you can win his mother's heart. if all options are exhausted & you still cannot establish a good relationship with her, then let it go. you have done your part & since it did not work out, then it is not your fault. this time, just focus on your husband more & do not mind what she tells you or do to you.
@cream97 (29087)
• United States
28 May 08
When one party is putting in, the other party has to do the same thing.. My mil plays mind games... It is so much that you can only put up with..
@cream97 (29087)
• United States
29 May 08
I will try not to...
@borgborg (821)
• Philippines
29 May 08
i'm sorry to hear that. just do not give up that easily. :)
@freedomg (1684)
• United States
19 Jun 08
Oh man girl. I just don't have any advise for you here. I was seriously thinking of leaving my hubby at one point to get away from his mom. She does so much underhanded stuff that I can't even begin to list it. I thought I would try a last ditch effort and talk to the hubby about it and guess what ... she's p@sses him off too. Now we are doing great and are united in an effort to teach her to respect us and our home or leave. Right now we are not answering her phone calls as a way of letting her know that her last one had unacceptable comments in it. It's sort of a time out and they seam to work for a short while. We have all of her grandkids but one and she can only see him when we bring him to her. So we do have some control in this. As for your situation, well it does sound like there is a lack of respect there and you need to talk to your hubby and her. Though I don't suggest throwing out the man because of his mom, aqt least not just yet. Best of luck to you.
@cream97 (29087)
• United States
20 Jun 08
Thanks, this I will do... I distance myself away from her most of the time. Even when she comes to my home. I hate doing her like this, but I have to. My mil has a very bad habit of saying off the wall things when she gets me alone. I try to avoid her at all costs.. I don't want to be around silly mess at all.
1 person likes this
@cream97 (29087)
• United States
20 Jun 08
Yes, I will not give up my man because of her. If she does not want me to be happy, then she has herself to blame. She should have never laid down with her husband to make my husband. If her son was never born, then she would not have had to worry about me..
1 person likes this
• India
20 Jun 08
Oh cream! you can't bring her between your relation! Your husband is your life and everything ok. Try to ignore her to your best possibility ok. When you don't talk to how can she get a chance to trouble you yeh? Keep your head cool, when she comes to your place. When she complains to your husband try to explain to him how she behaves with you. I can understand her mentality, she is old and most old people are frustrated. She tries to take her frustration on you and more over generation gap is also one factor. Better don't give heed to her as long as your husband is good to you. Cheers cream! Believe in your self! Take Care!
1 person likes this
@cyberfluf (4996)
• Netherlands
9 Jul 08
This is a problem a lot of people experience, it's hard because she's an important member in the family of your husband and there is no way in parting with her unless your husband wants the same thing and you would have to ban her out of your life. I'm not sure that's the solution, especially if this would mean grandchildren growing up without (one of their) grandma's. The only thing that might help is making good agreements on certain things like calling before visiting. I don't know if this is managable with her but it's worth a try if you haven't tried this before.
@cyberfluf (4996)
• Netherlands
11 Jul 08
I guess some people really need things pointed out, but that can be really hard for the person who has to tell them.. good luck!
@cream97 (29087)
• United States
11 Jul 08
Yes, you are correct! Making this option would be perfect. But I haven't said anything to them. I was hoping that they would figure it out and that way, they can understand.
1 person likes this
@djmarion (4898)
• Philippines
20 Jun 08
no, my boyfriend's mom is a very nice old lady, refined and kind, actually his family are good people, they never treat me bad or indifferent so i have no reason to feel leaving him because of his family.
@cream97 (29087)
• United States
20 Jun 08
I know that my fil is kind of like that as well. On my last discussion, it may seem like I am getting smart. But honestly I was not. I was only lashing out at my mil.. i wish I had a family where there were no odd in laws, but I do know that there are good family in laws out there.
@checapricorn (16061)
• United States
27 May 08
Have you talked to your husband about it? Maybe he can help you in this issue. I understand your feeling since I have friends who have the same experienced with you. If that is something very annoying and you think, it is very hard to deal with her, why not moving to a place where they can't visit you often. My friend did that actually and she is more peaceful now, her husband also feel for her and knows what's the situation, but, I know doing that is hard especially if you got a stable job right now!
@cream97 (29087)
• United States
27 May 08
Yes, we have thought about moving to another town.. But not for the reasons where it concerns his mom... But I wish to move to another city, to get away from her. That way she can't just show up unexpectedly to my home... Her oldest daughter lives in another city... I know that she is happy, because she does not have to put up with her mom's or her mother-in-law mess.. If they give her any!
• United States
27 May 08
well, if it's the best and will you give peace of mind, I know your husband will support you. We just can't force ourselves to like the person who will never like us in return or just hard to be with..
@idowrite72 (2213)
• United States
9 Jul 08
Decide what is more important to you.......your love for your husband, or the discomfort his mother causes. I would advise you to do what I used to do with my kids and their friends. Tell your husband that he needs to say something to her or you will. If it is done that way it might be kinder and might seem that it is coming from him and not from you. If you are outspoken, which it doesn't seem you are (just like me) then go ahead and tell her what you think and how she bothers you. Tell her the things that she does at your home when she comes there and how it isn't going to be tolerated. You don't have to put up with it just because you are married to her son and if you haven't talked about it with your husband then that is the first thing that you should do. I think that I must have been lucky not to have known either of my ex's mothers.
@cream97 (29087)
• United States
9 Jul 08
Yes, I am outspoken when it comes to my mil. I am too outspoken. I have had many arguments with her , more than I could name.. I just have ran out of words with her.. So, I just distance myself away from her. That way, I won't have to put up with her mess. It is hard. But this is the way she has made it to be. If she had to be a better mil than none of this would have ever happened. She is the cause of what is the out come of this relationship between me and her. I am so sorry...
@newtondak (3946)
• United States
27 May 08
Hubby needs to have a nice discussion with his mom about respecting your time and space - if he chooses not to, then take it upon yourself to make your position known.
@newtondak (3946)
• United States
27 May 08
It IS his concern because it is HIS mother! I think I'd tell him that he can either deal with it - since she's HIS mother - or you'll make the decision that you and your family will not have contact with them. Some relatives are just "toxic" and will forever wreck havoc (sp?) with your life. Sometimes you just have to not include the in your lives - it's not that you don't love and care about them and their welfare - it's just that they bring too much grief into your life.
@cream97 (29087)
• United States
27 May 08
Yes, that is what I found myself doing since he won't be the MAN to handle this.. It is a shame that my issues are none of his concern when it comes to his mother..
@lvaldean (1612)
• United States
27 May 08
What does your husband say about the situation? This is really the first question that needs to be asked. If he is letting his mother behave in a manner that is making you unhappy than that is one source of the problem right there. She is his mother and it is his responsibility to deal with. From your post it sounds like this has gone on for quite a while now. She can't be unaware that her behavior is bothering you, thus it is purposeful. Was she like this before you married? How long have you been with your husband? There are a few things that you can do, none of them are a guarantee fix but they might get the point across. 1. Talk to your husband and ask that he speak to your MIL about boundaries. Make certain that you establish these with him first so that whatever he tells her is what you want, you won't get a "do over". 2. Failing option 1, do it yourself. Invite her alone, to lunch. Tell her what she is doing that bothers you and how it is affecting your relationship with her son. Tell her that you need for it to stop and give her some new "rules" by which to play. Tell her clearly that you will not be leaving anytime soon so she and you must learn to get along but if she wants continued contact she must play nicely. If one of the boundaries is not showing up uninvited there are a few remedies. 1. Don't invite her to stay. If they show up around dinner time explain there is only enough for your immediate family and thank them for coming as you show them out the door. 2. If visits are randomly spaced tell her that you were on the way out to run errands. Pack everyone up and leave. Thank her for coming as you show her out the door. 3. If it is over a weekend tell she and her husband that it is a work / cleaning weekend and that you don't have the time to entertain. Invite them to assist you in a top-to-bottom house cleaning / yard cleaning exercise so that it will go faster and you will have time to visit later. For this one to work you have to keep a list of really bad jobs (grout scrubbing, garage cleaning, weed pulling, composte spreading) handy that you are able to quickly pull out. Those are three that can work. But really the best is for you and your husband together to talk to her.
@cream97 (29087)
• United States
27 May 08
Thanks! I will try these steps to take in dealing with her. If she does not correct this attitude with me, then I will have to show her the door out of my life!
@lvaldean (1612)
• United States
27 May 08
Difficult to do of course as long as you are married to your current husband. Personally I would not give my MIL the satisfaction of knowing that she gets to me. I have a MIL who ocassionally gets under my skin, but never directly. It is a difficult situation, always. If your husband doesn't support your position even more difficult. You cannot ask him to choose. In truth he already has, he married you. However, he doesn't want to lose his mother through his choice and you don't want to lose your marriage through his inaction or her bad behavior. Sometimes it is just a matter of telling someone that they are acting badly. Other times they already know it and then it is a different issue altogether.