For those of you who are pro-choice, could you perform an abortion?

United States
June 16, 2008 9:08am CST
For those of you who are pro-choice, could you perform an abortion? Every woman has a has a right to a choice in our country. I am pro-life. I could never perform an abortion. What if the law says if you want an abortion, you have to perform one on another person and then that person will perform one on you. Sounds scary but if you want one, you should be able to give one. Why should a doctor be the one to give it? Imagine what the mind of a doctor is like after he has given thousands of abortions. All the women I have talked to after having an abortion, regret it. Many say they hear their baby crying at night.
5 people like this
5 responses
@suspenseful (40193)
• Canada
16 Jun 08
I would never be able to perform an abortion as I am pro life and thing all lives are sacred, but I doubt that many pro choice women would be able to. They are not close to the situation. They think it as the woman's right to choose, to kill her baby, and it does not affect them. If they were told that once they had an abortion (where they would be out like a light and did not see the parts of the baby coming out) that they were to perform an abortion on another (after the proper training) they would be unable to do it unless they were unfeeling. The doctor who performs thousands probably has hardened his heart and assumed that these babies would have grown up to be John Gacey's if they had lived, but a woman on seeing the baby on the operating table, would be moved by compassion and realize what she had done.
2 people like this
• United States
16 Jun 08
My sentiments exactly!!!
2 people like this
• United States
17 Jun 08
What happy little planet are you from??? In the real world you have to do hard things. Comparing a doctor who performs abortions to John Gacey is over the top! Perhaps instead of "hardening his heart" to the babies...he has OPENED his heart to the women who find themselves in a bad circumstance. Really the attempt to paint people who disagree with your own narrow mindset as evil speaks LOUDLY about your own ability to tolerate other's having the right to make their own decisions.
1 person likes this
• United States
16 Jun 08
I am pro-choice and the answer is "NO." I could not perform an abortion. Why? Because I don't have a medical degree and it's kind of hard to do surgery with no training. Most people make the mistake of assuming that people who are pro-choice are pro-abortion. They are not. What is the mental block pro-lifers have with understanding that pro-choice means just that? I believe that every woman has a right to make her own choices. That doesn't make me a surgeon anymore than being pro-life makes you a Pediatrician. One more thought: pro-choice is also about keeping abortion safe. Having your friends perform your abortion is what happens when there is no choice. Think about that.
1 person likes this
• United States
16 Jun 08
A first trimester fetus is not a baby. A first trimester fetus doesn't even have lungs. How can it take a last breath if it never had a first one? Surgery is surgery and only trained doctors should perform surgery. They don't even let medical students perform procedures on live people. Why should ignorant civilians be not allowed allowed but forced to do so?
1 person likes this
• United States
16 Jun 08
Pro-choice does not mean pro-abortion. Well, you know the old saying, "If you aren't for me, then you are against me." My point is not about getting an illegal abortion. My point is that if a woman wants to an abortion, she should see first hand what it is like to kill a baby. She should do it. A doctor could assist her...but she does the work....to see what it is like to see a baby killed...to see what it is like for a baby take his last breath during an abortion.
1 person likes this
• Germany
16 Jun 08
If i had the opportunity i probably would or could do it. I mean you put yourself in that situation, also its your choice to do so.
1 person likes this
@bonbon664 (3466)
• Canada
17 Jun 08
Ridiculous question. If I had a medical degree, I would perform a medical procedure. It doesn't matter what your stance on the issue, but, your question is a silly one.
@bonbon664 (3466)
• Canada
17 Jun 08
It's not murder! That's your opinion. Whether you like it or not, it's legal, and necessary in some cases.
• United States
17 Jun 08
Yet again, a first trimester fetus is not a baby. It's not bonbon's fault that her parents wanted children, so saying "nobody aborted you" is ridiculous and has nothing to do with anything. Also, it's your OPINION that abortion is murder. That is not fact. Not everyone agrees with you and no one is required to.
• United States
17 Jun 08
Silly? Ridiculous? Easy for you to say. Nobody aborted you. Sugar coat it by calling it a "medical procedure"....it's murder.
• United States
17 Jun 08
Back in the bad old days women did in fact perform abortions ON THEMSELVES and each other because no other option existed. Professional help wasn't available. It wasn't a solution obviously as abortions still exist. I think you have the erroneous impression that women are ignorant of what exactly they are doing by having an abortion. I think that is colossally insulting. The fact that women do know what is happening and still feel it would be the right thing to do should tell you something about the serious issue they are struggling with both with ending or keeping a pregnancy. Of course many women who have had an abortion regret it, that is a luxury/curse that choice brings with it. The opportunity to have hind site and regrets. Could I perform an abortion? With medical training and under circumstances that I felt justified it...you betcha.
• United States
17 Jun 08
Oh, how cold.
• United States
17 Jun 08
How very well said, Auntie Em!
• United States
17 Jun 08
How cold? Seems to me that you aren't really interested in asking a question about abortion. Seems to me all you are doing is posing an inflammatory statement and then insulting anyone who doesn't fall into line with your own way of thinking. How childish!
@spalladino (17891)
• United States
16 Jun 08
No doctor in the U.S. is forced to perform abortions, the doctors who perform them do so by choice and I assume they have no problems with it. I am pro-choice but that does not mean that I necessarily agree with abortion. I agree with a woman's right to decided what goes on with her own body and her right to have good medical care at all times. Your idea about forcing women to perform abortions on each other is abusive. Before you shoot back with "aborting is abusive to the fetus" I agree with you, it is. However, you know the old adage, two wrongs don't make a right, so using a legal procedure that you don't approve of as an excuse to abuse women is wrong.
1 person likes this
• United States
16 Jun 08
They have no problem doing it because they are numb. What if there were no doctors doing...? It is abusive to ask women to perform abortions on each other? Then isn't abusive to ask anyone to perform an abortion including a doctor? Babies are not high school frog experiments, but obviously they are treated as such. Then maybe instead of abortion, we could just have women who are responsible for their actions so they don't feel the need to kill a baby they consider to be a blob.
1 person likes this
• United States
17 Jun 08
Spa, you miss the point!