Did u feel sorry for snape?

India
June 22, 2008 3:54am CST
IN the last book harry potter and the deathly hollows how did u feel when u come to know that all the time snape has been protecting harry potter from voldemort. did u expect the lovestory between lily potter and snape? did u expect that snape has been a good person?
2 people like this
8 responses
• United States
22 Jun 08
I felt very bad for him. That was so unexpected (for me anyway). He was like a triple lol. Thats messed up how harry's father used to pick him.
1 person likes this
• United States
22 Jun 08
triple agent* pick on him*
1 person likes this
@shinta (22)
• Indonesia
23 Jun 08
I have already guessed it since i read the 6th book.Well, actually he's not a bad person, he's already protecting Harry since in the first book.
22 Jun 08
Well he is neurotic and has a lot of hangups, so in a way, yeah.
1 person likes this
@suprema (297)
• Philippines
22 Jun 08
Of course! All throughout his life only a few people knew what he really was doing. If everyone thought I was evil (but it's really the opposite) and I couldn't inform them of the truth, I'd be miserable. Yes, I believed there was something about Lily in Snape's hate for James. But throughout the course of the books, I wasn't really sure, until the end, if Snape was good or not.
@joliefille (3690)
• Philippines
22 Jun 08
I kinda felt that Snape really liked Lily. He's such a confused guy. I actually cried when I read that part in the last book. It's so heartbreaking.
1 person likes this
@cncoke (439)
• China
22 Jun 08
No,I think he is a good man. We often misunderstand his life.He is poor
1 person likes this
• United States
23 Jun 08
My daughter and I debated Snape's character since the fifth book, The Order of the Phoenix. Of course, it was always a hope that Snape was a tragic character that was inherently good and protective of Harry, but J.K. Rowling led her readers down so many paths, it was difficult to know, truly know, if Snape was going to be this tragic character or if he was the snake Rowling tried to paint him to be. Upon reading the last book, I, too, cried when Snape was indeed the tragic character, but also the most in-depth of all the characters in the series. Even Harry and Draco didn't have the depth of Snape. I have to admit, Harry's constant teenage sulking got to be a bit over the top for a while, and Dumbledore's "double life" didn't compare to Snape's characterization. When my daughter and I both finished the last book, she called me and said, "I told you so! I told you so!" I laughed and told her she was right. Harry Potter will probably go down in literary history as one of the best classical series that should be required reading. Witchcraft and Wizardry nothwithstanding, this is a classic tale of good vs. evil personified. I am so happy I was able to get on the bandwagon of these books when they were published.
@ayenacsi (910)
• Philippines
23 Aug 08
Somehow I wasn't surprised because I knew that Dumbledore had his reasons for trusting Snape. Now about Snape and Lily, that one I didn't expect! Somehow I felt sorry for Snape.