How Would You Handle This Situation

@syeryn (573)
United States
June 22, 2008 12:37pm CST
My best friend and I work for the same company in the same branch location. We were up for the same promotion which she received and I had no problem with her success in that promotion. I planned the party we held to celebrate her new role in the business. Sound like there is not a problem here right? I thought so too. One week later she calls me into her office to tell me that she has requested that I be transferred to a different branch because I pose too much competition to her ambitions. So I was transferred to a location that is a tremendous commute for me every day and creates quite a hardship for me. How would you handle this situation?
3 people like this
6 responses
@Elixiress (3878)
22 Jun 08
I would definitely talk to my best friend, well ex best friend after her recent behaviour. Ask her what her problem is and explain that the commute it awful and you would rather not be changed to that branch permanently. I would also express that although I had wanted the job, I am happy that she got it and that I am not trying steal her job off her or anything like that.
1 person likes this
@syeryn (573)
• United States
23 Jun 08
Unfortunately the transfer was permanent an non reversible as I was informed by our District Manager. He did not feel that my friend and I could continue to have a working relationship that was condusive to the success of the business if she remained insecure about my abilities. I got the old soft shoe about how I would excel in the new branch and all that, but it was just a puff of smoke up the old wazoo and I knew it. I guess I was just shocked that she would toss away a 15 years friendship for the sake of a few extra dollars each week. and, I thought I had communicated how happy I was for her when I planned a surprise party to celebrate her success. I guess she failed to get that memo though *wink*
1 person likes this
• United States
23 Jun 08
I'd go above your District Manager's head. File complaints against both of them and talk to a lawyer. If they had any questions about your competency to do your job they would have done something before transfering you. I am assuming that you don't have any warnings in your record, your boss hasn't spoken to you or reprimanded you. For you to be transfered out of the blue at the request of somebody who just got a promotion that you both were competeing for tells me that something is going on between the two of them.
1 person likes this
@syeryn (573)
• United States
23 Jun 08
Hi John Thanks for the support. I have no reprimands, verbal or written. In fact, just the opposite is true. I received several performance and service awards over the past two years. The decision on the promotion was so close that they finally used seniority to decide it because we were so equally qualified for the position. She had 11 days longer on the job that I did so they awarded it to her and I was perfectly okay with their decision. I just did not want to be transferred and be forced to face a commute of three hours a day and all the expense and hardships that go hand in hand with commuting to work. I offered two resolutions in mediation. 1. Transfer me back to my original location. 2. Transfer me to the location that is only a 45 minute commute instead of the three hour one. They were denied based on "need." They said the branch location that is further away from my home needed my services more than the others and that was their final disposition of mediation. It lasted 5 minutes. I gave a 30 day written notice of resignation and will be speaking to my family attorney about any possible recourse available to me.
1 person likes this
• United States
22 Jun 08
If it were me I'd say either I'm transfered back immedately or I'm quitting. Also I'd want to know who approved the transfer and why. And what his/her relationship with your friend is. I'd file complaints against everybody involved. When somebody does something like that they are no longer your friend.
1 person likes this
@KrauseHome (36448)
• United States
27 Oct 08
Wow!! This would be hard for me to take for sure. And to think that they were a Friend of yours before this as well. Sounds like they felt quite insecure and afraid you would somehow steal the job. I would be a little upset if it was me, and if it was a hardship to get back and forth to work, it would force me to start looking for another job as well. Hopefully thru this you both will learn something from it, and you will be a better person because of it.
@callarse1 (4783)
• United States
23 Jun 08
While your friend has a point, I think it was unfair for her to do that decision. For example, you competed for her in the job. I would assume that you would congratulate someone & move on. You would do your work the same & not compete with her. I'm not sure how you could anyway if she is the boss and you are just a worker. Yes, you are right. It's unfair because you have to drive father. I wonder why she didn't just volunteer to go to the other branch if she felt threatened? I was reading about what other people said on here, you should go to talk to someone if you don't like the commute to work. What she did was really unfair to you. Have a nice day. Pablo
• United States
23 Jun 08
Wow! That does put you in a tough spot. I don't know how to advise. I have been in similar situations where I was transferred to a spot against my better judgement with no hope of returning.
@Hatley (163781)
• Garden Grove, California
23 Jun 08
syeryn that best friend sounds rather treacherous to me, she gets the promotion then kicks you in the ribs, thats not' friendship thats oneupsmanship. I would go to the boss over both of you and talk to him or her and be very blunt, tell that boss that the transfer has cost you bigtime and is a hardship for you. ask for a transfer much closer or tell them that you can find another job that will pay better. but go talk to the boss.
@syeryn (573)
• United States
23 Jun 08
Hi Hatley It's pretty much a done deal at this point and I will find another position. Funny, I feel a greater loss at losing what I thought was a long term friendship than I do over the loss of my salary.