Honest OIL MAN ? Huckster for WIND POWER?

United States
July 9, 2008 9:42am CST
T.Boone Pickens. Is he an oil man in all honesty urging America to go in a wiser direction? Or is this merely hucksterism for wind power? Read this and help me decide. http://online.wsj.com/article/SB121556087828237463.html?mod=djemEditorialPage So, what do you say? He is 80 and already a billionaire. Would or couldn't he have pure motives? Should we listen to T. Boone Pickens?
2 people like this
4 responses
@Destiny007 (5805)
• United States
9 Jul 08
I don't believe in the viability of wind power because it is not dependable, steady, or consistent. I read an article awhile back detailing why wind power was not a good alternative which detailed several problems associated with it. Part of the problem was that the wind doesn't always produce power, another was the power levels are not steady, another is that there is no way to store the excess power on a windy day, and then there was that the power fluctuations could be damaging to utility equipment and home appliances. I don't think we should listen blindly to anyone, instead we should make our own decisions based on our own research and information.
3 people like this
• United States
9 Jul 08
I think wind power could be viable, but not with the current system. Wind power needs to be part of a dc system with massive storage capacity. The power grid can never be compatible with that.
2 people like this
@speakeasy (4171)
• United States
9 Jul 08
Whether you want to listen to him or not depends on you. However, even though he is an "oil man"; I cannot believe that he has not diversified and wind, solar, and natural gas would all be areas that he would be familiar with. Wind power, as it stands today, is capable of taking the "load" off the power plants during peak hours (daylight hours). I live in a windy area and with a few exceptions the pattern of wind is that it is very still and calm in the early morning until the sun has been up for a couple of hours; then, wind starts to blow and it continues throughout the day until the earth has cooled down after dark. Storm fronts are obviously the exception to the rule. If we had more wind farms generating electricity it would reduce the cost of electricity during peak times and reduce the amount of fuel needed to produce a steady supply of electricity. This is not a bad thing. However, the best bet for using wind power to produce reliable 24/7 energy is the "contained tornado" plant which you mentioned earlier in a previous post. It will take time to get these plants built, proven, and on-line; but, they have the potential to provide reliable electrity 24/7. Wind power has great potential; but, we need to work on better ways to harness it. If we could harness, collect, and store the energy generated in a SINGLE Cat 2 hurricane; we would have enough electrical energy to supply the entire United States with electricity for an ENTIRE YEAR. That is a lot of energy; but, right now we do not have the means to take advantage of it. We definately need more research on wind power. I would also like to point out that T. Boone Pickens is actually promoting the use of natural gas as a fuel for automobiles. Some individuals, companies, and even local governments are already doing that and they are saving money.
• United States
9 Jul 08
If you ever talk to a mechanic who works on those vehicals running on natural gas he'll tell you it burns incredibly clean with the oil looking like new for a very long time. The engines last longer as a result, too.
1 person likes this
• United States
10 Jul 08
LadyLuna, On the surface this sounds like a great idea. However, as to feasibility, you have taken this to the point we need to talk to an engineer unless I spent a day or two or even more reading up on it all, and consulting with an engineer. That's too much work for a mylot post. That said, I will say it appears like a good idea that solves the main problem with wind power. We could look up the name of the guy doing that sustained tornado research and see what he says about adding nuclear power to the mix.
1 person likes this
@speakeasy (4171)
• United States
9 Jul 08
I know, my father used to have one that had been converted to natural gas. Almost any vehicle can be converted to natural gas for a very reasonable cost. BUT, like a lot of the alternate fuel vehicles on the road today, they do have a major limitation. A lack of "natural gas" stations. If you have places in your area that sell natural gas for vehicles, you are fine as long as you do not go too far away. But, a cross country trip or vacation can become very difficult logistically speaking. AND, if you do run out of natural gas while you are driving down the road, you can't get someone to deliver a "gallon or two" from your motor club or road service the way you can with gasoline. What we need is for a major company to establish a network of natural gas stations across the country or add natural gas to their regular gas stations. Then, this would be a much more practical fuel option.
1 person likes this
@gewcew23 (8007)
• United States
9 Jul 08
T.Boone Pickens is a great guy, and can do whatever he wants to do with his money. He can build all the wind mills, but that will not lower the price of oil by one cent. Unless electricity is being made by oil wind power has no effect on gas. T.Boone Pickens is using his position as a powerful oilman and the raising price of gas to convience you to make your local politicans support taxes on coal power plants. It is what it is, and T.Boone Pickens is a businessman. He need you to buy his electricity and not from some coal powered plant. We should not listen to him for one minute, which is about how long his commericals are on Fox News that he is running. Think about why is he running it on a Conservative news channel. Why not some channel that is proud to be green. Because he is using his oilmen to sell Republicans on the "greatness" of wind power. Of course it his wind power.
1 person likes this
• United States
9 Jul 08
Your position makes sense to me. Even if Pickens does not need the money, why should we expect he has changed in anyway in his old age?
1 person likes this
@lvaldean (1612)
• United States
10 Jul 08
Interesting fella Mr. Pickens. Some very valid points and scary numbers. I don't know enough about wind power to comment, but I have to believe that there is some validity to its use. Mr. Pickens has indeed been around for a long time and likely knows a bit more than just oil. I would love to see more natural gas cars available to the general public. I have worked with some clients that have converted their fleets successfully and saved.
• United States
10 Jul 08
Natural gas autos and wind mills both sound good to me. I've looked into wind mills and unfortunately we have too little wind for one to be more than a novelty, darn it.
1 person likes this