Would you cook seperate meals?

United States
July 21, 2008 4:32pm CST
My husband and I have never agreed on foods. He is not the least bit healthy, and won't touch a vegetable to save his life!! He is a typical steak and potato kind of guy. Me on the other hand.. I love vegetables, and my favorite meat is chicken, the rest I could take it or leave it for the most part. Now for the past 7 years I've created meals that will please everyone. I serve vegetables, and he just doesn't get them, or can pick them out. Whenever I wanted something that he wouldn't like, such as a tuna casserole, I've had to make him a seperate meal. Now, the problem is, I am trying to eat healthier. I want to eat far less red meat, and more poultry. He doesn't have a problem with that, except eventually he gets tired of it and wants red meat. I have tried substituting ground chicken or turkey for ground beef, but he just doesn't like it. So it looks like I'm going to have to make 2 seperate dinners. A healthy one for me and the kids (luckily they'll eat anything) and one for him that suites his tastes.
8 people like this
25 responses
• United States
21 Jul 08
you should tell him that he has the choice of cooking his own meals or eating the meals that you and your kids eat.
• United States
21 Jul 08
He doesn't get home until late at night, and that is far too late to be cooking meals. He will do it if he must, but it would be easier and less time consuming for me to cook something for him.
2 people like this
• United States
22 Jul 08
Congrats on your page one discussion! I know how hard you work on these discussions so it's nice when other Mylot members acknowledge that and help push your discussion to the top! As for the meals, I can relate to that! A couple years ago, my spouse had gotten into really bad eating habits. Then he got really sick and his blood pressure went up and he had to go onto salt restricted diet. Now he won't let himself have red meat. I wish that I could give you good advice on the veggies aspect. If he won't eat them, then he won't eat them. I have cooked meats on the Foreman grill with veggies and they all end up tasting like meat. Maybe he would like that. Men don't often like soup, some beef and lots of veggies. But you might try some kind of stew with carrots and potatoes. Puree some veggies and add to the broth. He won't know that he is eating veggies. My spouse is not that picky when it comes to eating chicken or fish cause those are healthy and he wants to live longer! But my daughter, who is four, doesn't like veggies, so sometimes I have to be sneaky and puree them into fruit juice. That way she gets an entire serving of veggies and she doesn't know it. Have you tried some kind of fruit/veggie pie? Or homemade pot pie? He wouldn't really be able to pick around all the veggies cause those are mostly veggie based with some meat. That might be a great way to get him to eat veggies. You might also try making pasta, which relies more on noodles and less on ground beef. He would still get his beef like he wants but have to eat the pasta to get full. I used to have to do that with my spouse. Best of luck. I'm sure things will work out for you!
1 person likes this
• United States
22 Jul 08
page one discussion - Your page one discussion
Here's the pic! I hope it uploads this time.
• United States
29 Jul 08
Sounds like you are doing fine with the meals. As long as he is getting a good variety every week I wouldn't worry too much. Once I heard some weight loss advice from a chef who had been overweight and lost lots of weight. He said, you have to take into account everything you eat for one full week. That is your total calorie intake. Not what you eat in any single day. I'm sure your hubby will eat better on some days, nutrition wise and on other days not so much! You know guys. They get set in their ways and that is OK too. As long as he's healthy. Mine is slowly but surely slipping back into his bad food ways though his blood pressure skyrockets! I worry about him! Thanks for best response!
• United States
22 Jul 08
LOL, and you had #1, wtg. I don't often pay attention to how well my discussions are doing, I guess I don't start them for that reason. I start them as a way of getting advice or something along those lines... Now, so far as your advice... He's not against chicken or pork or fish, and actually we've both come a long way. When we were first married I'd want NOTHING but chicken and he'd want NOTHING but beef. I've learned to prepare chicken so many different ways that he's much better about eating it, and I've learned to live with a few different beef meals, and actually do enjoy steak now. Certain veggies in certain meals he will eat. He's fine with peas and corn, and sometimes carrots depending on how they're made. He won't touch green beans or broccoli, which are a couple of the veggies we have frequently. He absolutely refuses to eat any sort of fruit or fruit juice. He will eat vegetables in some meals, like if I make fried rice he'll eat pretty much any vegetable in it. He will even eat kale if it's made in a particular soup he likes. Neither of us like pot pies. I have gotten him to eat cream of mushroom soup in certain meals, and he's even getting better about onion seasonings or onion soup mix, but won't eat cooked onions. I'm afraid of adding vegetables to certain meals, because I don't want him to hate it and not want to eat it at all. For that matter I don't want to hate it myself, lol.
1 person likes this
@snowy22315 (169965)
• United States
21 Jul 08
That's sad. He is not setting a good example for the kids by eating all this unhelathy stuff. I would try to appeal to his better nature. Maybe also what you could do is like mix the beef and chicken and gradually phase out the beef. He probably wont notice if it's done over time. My dad wouldnt eat many things when my parents were first married. My mother gradually changed his habits over time and now he is almost normal in what he eats. Also, you could try getting a cookbook like decipetively delicious and sneek veggies into things.
1 person likes this
• United States
21 Jul 08
He does notice a difference in the ground beef, because for some reason when it's re-heated, it gets rock hard. He doesn't really eat junk food, but honestly he could live off macaroni and cheese. He's not setting any sort of example for the kids, because they never see him eat, he works while they're awake. And all my children are good eaters, so this isn't a problem. I cannot force him to like things. I've had him try things a few times, and continue to make him try different foods, but if he doesn't like it, I can't force him to eat it. I don't like the idea of decieving him into eating vegetables. I do cook vegetables into my food, and always tell them they're there. Sometimes he can eat it and not mind the vegetables, other times he will try it and not like it, so won't eat it.
@Hatley (163781)
• Garden Grove, California
22 Jul 08
snowy honestly he is on the path to a heartattack with all 'that redmeat do you really think you and he should let him] just keep eating that way, what does his doctor say, has he 'had a heart check up, one heart attack will probably change his way of eating but why let that happen, does his doctor] think he is wise to eat like that? surely your husband is ]not stupid and he must have heard that redmeatis not good for you,so why does he persist in this?
@saundyl (9783)
• Canada
21 Jul 08
It would drive me nuts to have to do that. I'd have a hard time cooking a meal for only him when I'm already making something else. I know my aunt does this for my cousin sometimes but most of the time she tells him now he can make his own meals because he wont eat what we do.
1 person likes this
@saundyl (9783)
• Canada
22 Jul 08
That makes sense. If its that late at night you must be having to warm food for him when he gets in. Why not make a bunch of meals and freeze them so you dont have to cook separate meals every night?
• United States
22 Jul 08
I've done that once or twice, but I should do it on a more frequent basis.
• United States
21 Jul 08
I guess I'm just used to it. He can't cook for himself because he doesn't get home until 9 or 10pm. That is too late to cook, and the clean up would end up being left until the morning.
1 person likes this
@guybrush (4658)
• Australia
22 Jul 08
I'm in the habit of cooking separate meals because my husband has always been a meat and potatoes man - he has a bad reaction to onions, and even onion powder in foods can make him ill. He won't eat rice, pasta, mushrooms, onions, capsicum, tomato, curries, stirfries, you name it. Therefore, I usually cooked something different for the children and I, and now that I only have one son at home, he and I have stirfries or pasta meals whilst my husband still has the good ol' meat and potatoes. I'm so used to it now I wouldn't know what it was like to cook one meal only!
1 person likes this
• United States
22 Jul 08
When I was younger I knew a single mom who was a vegetarian, and she would cook a pasta salad for herself, and hamburgers or hot dogs or something of the nature for the kids to eat. My husband's parents always made seperate meals too. His dad is diabetic, his sister is vegetarian, and he's the way he is. I actually think if he's parents didn't cater to him that way, that he'd have a wider range of foods he'd eat today.
@smile44 (167)
• United States
21 Jul 08
I agree that your husband should make his own dinner if he isn't going to eat what you make for yourself and the kids. I'm like your husband though, I'm a meat and potatoes person, although I prefer chicken to steak. However, I'll eat chicken any way that it is prepared and eat veggies or potatoes or whatever else with it. Why don't you try and compromise somehow? Maybe red meat on the weekends or something and something else during the week. Make enough meat on the weekends that he can have leftovers for a day or two if he needs it.
• United States
21 Jul 08
He's not able to make his own seperate meals due to the hours that he works. He's gone from 7am till 8pm at the earliest, sometimes 9 or 10pm. Then to come home and have to cook for himself? Yikes! We have been compromising all along... but it seems to still be unhealthy to me. I want healthier meals, which he won't always eat.
1 person likes this
@cutepenguin (6431)
• Canada
22 Jul 08
This is an interesting situation. I can understand that because your husband gets home late, that you would want to cook for him, but maybe he'd be more flexible if he were aware of the amount of work? My husband makes his own meal when he comes home late because he will sometimes feel like eating something in particular, and it's easier for us if he just puts it together himself. At any rate, can't you make a healthy meal like fish/chicken/ veggies/whatever, and then throw a little steak or other beef as a sort of a side. So that it's like you are all eating the same meal, but your husband is just eating more.
• United States
22 Jul 08
Actually it's not only about his hours, it's partially because when he cooks for himself, it won't be at all healthy. He has no problem doing so, but I'd rather he eat something healthy.
• United States
21 Jul 08
Your husband sounds a lot like my BF, except perhaps even more picky. My BF doesn't like cooked vegitables either except for potatoes and corn. I have coaxed him into liking rice and eating a salad once in awhile. Thankfully, he will eat raw carrots and broccoli, he just hates "mushy" veggies. As for the meals, he will eat chicken, pork and some fish, so I don't usually have to cook a whole differnt meal, but I will make different sides for us or I will add an extra vegitable to mine and he'll have a larger portion of potatos. But if I wanted to make stew or lasanga or something (he also hates all tomato-based products) the I will usually fix him his own meal. I don't mind doing it, because he isn't the type who would complain if he had to make his own meal. I just know that "his own meal" could well be just a piece of meat with no sides at all, so I want to at least get some vegetable matter into him, so I fix it if I can.
@Hatley (163781)
• Garden Grove, California
22 Jul 08
just a thought, if he likes juices why not let him v8 juice and he would get some veggies in it that way, my husband loved v8 juice so much, and sometimes carrot juice and he liked veggies in stews that he made himself.He did not like a lot of veggies but he liked carrots and potatoes and onions in a beef stew.
• United States
22 Jul 08
Hatley- he doesn't like juice or V8 at all.
• United States
21 Jul 08
That is generally what I do as well. I just wish he'd eat more vegetables.
1 person likes this
@Wyldrose (1216)
• United States
22 Jul 08
The only time we cook separatley is when we make something that calls for jalapenos or anything hot and spicy. My husband loves hot/spicy food and I can't tolerate it. Like when we make our okra and tomato dish, I will make separate pans of it because I like the regualar tomatoes and he likes the Ro-tel tomatoes in his cause they are hot. I'm sure, though, in your case, that it can be very frustrating cooking two separate meals all the time. With my husband and I it's only a few certain ones. He does most of the cooking by the way, just because he is better than I am..lol..
• United States
22 Jul 08
It really has yet to be frustrating, because I just give in and make only the dishes he likes, then add vegetables on the side. I'd just like to phase out to healthier meals, in which case I may find I'm making seperate meals more frequently.
@GreenMoo (11834)
28 Jul 08
You'll have to excuse me, as I've not read all the responses to this as yet so I don't know if anyone has suggested it. But how about cooking double portions of a meal for yourself one night, then for your husband the next night, and freezing the extra. You'll have to cook an extra couple at the start otherwise you'll be eating the same thing two nights in a row, but soon you'll have a good selection so will just have to cook one meal and reheat another. It might make your life easier. As to your original question, I don't think I would personally cook two seperate meals. I hate cooking at the best of times, so I think I'd go to all that bother. One meal, take it or leave it!
• United States
28 Jul 08
That's not a bad idea. I haven't tried that. Actually what I'm doing now is just trying to adjust my husband's eating habits. He was so proud of himself on Saturday. I made chicken noodle soup with carrots and celery. Normally he has no problem with vegetables in soup, he can either pick around them or just deal with it as it will taste like the soup. Well as I said, he was very proud of himself, and told me he had 3 bowls of soup.. and actually purposely picked out extra carrots because he liked them so much!
@tessah (6617)
• United States
22 Jul 08
ive done it. still do it. it isnt so much really making seperate meals entirely.. just tossing a steak or a burger into the mix along with the other things im fixing as well. side dishes are still pretty much the same. like you said.. he doesnt like veggies so he doesnt take any or he picks them out of what hes eating, so it isnt all that much difference in the cooking really. as far as the caseroles go.. some he likes some he doesnt.. and with the ones he doesnt like.. you make something else for him. alot of people are of the standard that whoever does the cookng mandates what the other eats.. and the other should just eat whats put in front of them and deal.. i dont agree with that. youre being considerate of his wants at the same time of tending to yer own as well. thats what a PARTNERSHIP.. and im sure if he was to cook on occaision, he wouldnt prepare something you disliked just to fulfill his own wants and not be considerate of yers by telling you to eat it or starve.
@tessah (6617)
• United States
22 Jul 08
its the same here.. cept for im the picky one LOL and when he cooks on the weekends, he decides.. but is always considerate of my tastes same as i am with his.
• United States
22 Jul 08
I do the grocery shopping. He cooks on his 2 days off during the week, and I will choose a meal for those days that he can prepare. It is usually something that requires grilling, or one of his more favorite meals. So all in all I do choose all the meals, but I take his tastes into consideration when I do so, and most of the time I will just eat whatever he wants because I'm less picky than he is.
@walijo2008 (4644)
• United States
22 Jul 08
Nope, I will not cook separate meals, why make more work for yourself. My husband eats whatever is on the table, he doesn't care what it is, as long as its food..lol. I think it depends on how you were raised, he said when he was little, they had to eat whatever their mom made for them whether they liked it or not, it was either eat it or be hungry. Thats how it was in my house also, my grandma never cooked twice, if we didn't like what we were having it was too bad, we learned to like it. I think thats the problem with all these picky kids these days, they don't know whats good for them. I have a couple nephews that are so picky when they eat, if they don't like the looks of it, they won't eat it, they won't even try it, to see if they would like it. My sister which is their mom, is the same way, so thats why they're like that. She cooks what they like, and thats what their used to, and if its anything different, they won't touch it, it aggravates me when they're over here and they act like that. Thats why I say, its probably the way your husband was brought up, maybe his mother cooked special meals for him, because he didn't like what everybody else was eating. If thats the case, I'm sorry to say theres not much you can do to change it, he's the way he is because he was raised that way. My husband's boss is that way, he don't like certain things, and he's not eating them, and his kids are the same way, his wife has to cook extra so everybody will be happy. She told me that when he was little thats how his mom did him, she made him whatever he wanted, not what she wanted to make, but what he wanted her to make. It just goes in a circle I guess. And I guess thats why my husband and I aren't picky because of the way we were brought up. Hope that made sense....have a good day
• United States
22 Jul 08
It does make sense, and it's the darn truth too. His parents were too lazy to cook normal meals, or force him to eat foods he didn't want to. He's actually come a long way since I've known him. I've gotten him to eat a few new foods, and I keep trying every day. I will serve him a small bit of vegetable and tell him to try it. Most times he will take a small bite, and claim he still doesn't like it, but sometimes he'll flat out refuse. Last night I actually got him to take 2 bites of carrots that he claimed he didn't like. He still said he didn't like them, but at least he had a bit of carrot.
@bombshell (11256)
• Germany
22 Jul 08
i also cook separate meals but very seldom.i cook separate if the lunch is chicken. coz i dont eat chicken i cook what i like to eat like rice and vegtables.
1 person likes this
@bryanna4 (49)
• United States
22 Jul 08
thats crazy to cook two seperate meals. not only is it costly but your kids are more likely to develop bad eating habits. my husband is the same way but, i cook dinner and try to make a healthy meat and a few sides that he likes and at least one veggie. then we try to go out to eat once a week if we are able and he gets his fried chicken, steak, or what ever he is in the mood for. i just want my children to learn good eating habits.
• United States
22 Jul 08
Going out to eat is far more costly than preparing a second meal at home. And my kids are not developing any bad habits, in fact they are excellent eaters.
@underdogtoo (9579)
• Philippines
22 Jul 08
Meals can be a problem when someone else wants something different. I used to be a vegetarian and if there was no vegetarian meal prepared for me I would just go on a fast which they did not like so I usually had my own vegetarian meal prepared. I am not picky about my food so they prepare something that others also like (vegetarian) and that solves a lot of problems when meals are prepared.
• United States
22 Jul 08
Why couldn't you prepare your own meal? If I was in your home I would have let you fast, sounds like you were just trying to get your own way, and obviously it worked.
@Hatley (163781)
• Garden Grove, California
22 Jul 08
katsmeow tell hubby if he wants special separate meals hire a short order cook as you are only cooking one meal, a healthy meal that just might make him live longer, so if he wants to eat a lot of red meat and get a ton of cholesterol and have a heart attack, why hop right to it, theres the kitchen mister.and use just those words that might make him pause and rethink his diet. he surely does not want to court a heart attack? Dont give 'in to him as its his health too thats on the line, tell him red meat is proven to load the system with cholesterol which will clog his arteries and lead to a heart attack.he needs his veggies and his fruit and lean chicken and fish tell him this . yell it make him listen tell him you do not want to become a widow!
• United States
22 Jul 08
We can't afford to hire a cook, I don't have a problem cooking him a seperate meal. He doesn't have a problem eating chicken and pork, and I doubt he's unhealthy. He's just picky, as are millions of other people in the world. Also, nobody should ever treat their husband that way. Yelling will not make a person listen, it will make them want to walk away from you. I could never be rude to my husband the way you are suggesting I be. I hope you can learn that lesson as well.
• United States
22 Jul 08
I make one and if they do not like it they fend for themselves! If I were in your situation I might since he is your hard working man! Best to keep him happy!
• United States
22 Jul 08
Thank you... If he worked normal hours, yeah he could cook for himself. Problem is, when he cooks for himself it's macaroni and cheese or ramen noodles. At least if I prepare a second meal it is something healthier than that.
@inia_54 (175)
• Malaysia
22 Jul 08
Well, when come to eating most mums have to tolerate the family taste buds. My husband is the other way around. He wants food with lots of vegetables. And my son does not like vegetables and another son does not like fish cook in dish, but wants it fry. So when every one is around, I will cook several dishes according to their liking but they can still sit down together and enjoy the food. However, now they are seldom at home so I only got to do it once a while.
• United States
22 Jul 08
I think when children are younger you need to not cater to their wishes, and eventually they will learn to eat what they are served. My oldest used to be picky, but grew out of it because I wouldn't cater to his wishes. But your kids are older now, so none of that matters anymore.
@pukaprat2 (442)
• United States
22 Jul 08
you need to tell him you are not his personal chef. and what is made for dinner is for dinner. i know it kind of puts it as u are the parent and he is the child but if you have kids what kind of example is he setting for them? or you can tell him to start cooking his own meals. i know this much- if my husband pulled that crap with me- he would making his own dinner. or if you think that is not the role for a wife- which my mother thinks, then make a set schedual for dinner and one day is for you the next for him. etc. etc. sometimes i notice that the role of the husband thinks that he is in charge, yet it is the wifes role to keep the house going as well as work. there is just too much put on a women sometimes. and with a picky husband like that i would start to treat him like a child. because to me that is the way it sounds. he has taken advantage of you and that to me is unacceptable. men need to pick up some slack.
• United States
22 Jul 08
My husband has never once assumed he is in charge, and if you read through some of the other responses (this is my own fault for not putting it in the original post) you'd see that he works about 60 hours a week, rarely with a day off, and gets home well past bed time. The children are not learning any bad habits from him, they are all excellent eaters who devour anything put in front of them. Considering I am home all day and he is not, I figure yes I am his personal chef. If he cooks for himself it will be even less healthy than what I prepare, because after his long day at work he does not want to cook a full meal and will eat nothing but cereal if I do not have a meal prepared for him. Also, I could never be as rude to him as you are suggesting. A marriage is a partnership, not a parent/child relationship. He is not taking advantage of me at all! I am doing this for him because I'm a loving wife, and it is MY choice to do so.
@gncd68 (18)
• United States
22 Jul 08
No way!!!!! I am not the best cook, I do the best I can. I had to self teach myself to cook and I'm not horrible at it or the greatest. But my husband is extremely picky and I am not going to treat him any differently then myself and my kids. If he doesn't like it, he can go to his MOMMIES and eat. It's too hard trying to please everyone in the house, especially when the Mother (in most cases) is the primary person to fix the meals.
• United States
22 Jul 08
I enjoy cooking most of the time. Many times I will create something for him on the weekend, such as macaroni and cheese or a hamburger helper meal and he can reheat it throughout the week when he doesn't like what we have.