banana vs apple

Japan
July 28, 2008 4:24am CST
a new notion of keeping the doctor away by eating a banana a day versus an apple a day has been roaming around. since i'm from a tropical country, banana is more accessible and cheaper compared to apples. every after meal, banana would be considered as our dessert. it's good in our digestive system plus it helps us to deal with the increasing temp ranging from 30-40 celcius. but i'm working abroad now and it's the other way around here. bananas are more expensive and apple is cheaper. apple is rich in vit c so i hardly get sick.
8 people like this
20 responses
• Philippines
28 Jul 08
Aside from the ones you've mentioned, bananas like here in the Philippines are much fresher than apples which were of course come from outside the country. I love apples but for aformentioned reason, especially the red california apples are so expensive here, we would resort to other fruit. I am glad that our country has variety of fruits to choose from, I think that makes us lucky enough. At home, banana is very much loved fruit by my niece and that we often have one in the house. Often though, I make fruit salad that include avocado, mangoes.. apples and bananas... yummmy !
2 people like this
• Japan
31 Jan 09
a bit strange for fruit salad that includes mangoes and avocado. yeah, a tropical country that's rich in fruits. philippines is rich in so many ways.
@riocab08 (41)
• Philippines
28 Jul 08
i love apples.. and i like eating them because it brings back the 3mins i have lost in my life when i smoke..=]
2 people like this
• Philippines
28 Jul 08
here in our country the philippines banana is very cheap compared to apples (which is imported from either the us or china) so we hardly eat apple in a week. but we do eat a lot of banana especially if it is summer since banana is said to be good for the skin especially on summers. not only is banana good for one's health but it is also very nutritious.
2 people like this
• Japan
31 Jan 09
summer's coming in the philippines and it is good to eat bananas again since it is rich in potassium. it keeps you from being dizzy while the temp heats up.
• India
29 Jul 08
In india both fruits available, but some seasons apple prices will raise, but banana is all the time same price, may be some time it up down. So I mostly like to take banana.
• Japan
31 Jan 09
then banana it is. availability really takes a lot of favor in most of people. not to mention its price and freshness.
• Philippines
28 Jul 08
It would be great if you can have both a day. cause the benefits that you'll be getting from apple are different from the one that banana can give you. One of the people who responded here made a good research with comparison. So, to make our body healthy, eat banana and apple a day. just in case, one is not available, at least try to have ANY of the two. Health is wealth!
• Japan
31 Jan 09
i recommend banana and a glass of milk every morning if you want to shed some pounds. that'll be enough for breakfast. then by dinner an orand and an apple will do. i'm a vegetarian, what can i say.
@chrisone (99)
• Belgium
28 Jul 08
this is a matter of taste i guess :-) i like both and here in eblgium they are aboutt he same prize so i would choose them both and if mixed with some kiwi and exotic fruits ( like starfruit or ananas or smth ) they make an extreemly nice fruitsalad :-D.... yours trully chrisone
• Japan
31 Jan 09
i like old bananas in making banana muffins with lots of nuts. most of my apples were mixed with my other smoothies. it's fun making them especially in summer.
@diansinta (7544)
• Indonesia
29 Jul 08
Bananas - Bananas image
Hi there fulghum, Indeed that Bananas are more useful than an apple. Some books said eating i banana same like we eat of 2 apples. Bananas in Indonesia also very cheap. Almost every where we can see banana. At supermarket till traditional market. My dad love to eat banana.
• Japan
31 Jan 09
hi. you can have them both. apples are rich in vitamin c and it whitens your teeth because it fiber and acidic. bananas are rich in potassium that's good for digestion and cooling down.
@secretbear (19448)
• Philippines
24 Aug 08
hi fulghum! here in our country, banana is the equivalent of apple. the saying "an apple a day keeps the doctor away" is translated into "a banana a day, keeps the doctor away". ^__~ bananas have many nutritional values. its good for the heart, the skin, the digestive system, etc. i usually have one piece of banana for dessert everyday. i would have like to have an apple a day but apple is more expensive than banana! that's why it is a surprise to learn that apples are cheaper there. apples must be readily available there locally. they probably don't import apples like we do. and they probably import bananas that's why it is more expensive there than apples.
• Japan
31 Jan 09
hmm...i think i just said what you have said. so i guess, you agree with me. for all its worth, fruits are essential to our daily diet. so many benefits that it can actually makes your life enjoyable.
@Daffodil20 (1754)
• India
29 Jul 08
Aha !! you said it fulghum.I too strongly feel that having bananas everyday is posible than having apples because of the reasons very well explained by you.Plus the taste also is one big bonus.I simply loove bananas.yummy.we are still so similar to our ancestors as far as love for banana goes.lol
• Japan
31 Jan 09
well, thank you. but i cannot eat sloppy banana or a banana that is too ripe because it makes me vomit. i don't know why. instead i make them to banana muffins than eat them raw. plus it is more fun to eat them that way.
@ersmommy1 (12588)
• United States
28 Jul 08
We like both. We eat both regularly. In fact had bananas this morning. So I guess we are covered. Better safe than sorry.
• Japan
31 Jan 09
good to hear. just had mine yesterday.
@vicky30 (4766)
• India
29 Jul 08
At our place bananas are cheaper than apples,so my family has bananas daily,we have apple once a while.
• Japan
31 Jan 09
a fruit a day is way much better than no fruit at all. :)
@kenzie45230 (3560)
• United States
29 Jul 08
I think what's really best is to have a variety of the kinds of fruits and vegetables available wherever you are located. I read not long ago that the best fruits and veggies are those you can buy locally and in season.
• Japan
31 Jan 09
yes, definitely. the fresher the better. i guess, that could be the reason why i buy foods from coop or farmers and they are cheap as well!
@benhilo (871)
• Tripoli, Libya
29 Jul 08
In Japan, most if not all fruits are expensive. It was when I lived there. I am also originally from the tropics. We grew up with a multitude of fruits that were readily available. Pears and apples were expensive. Now, like you I am away from home and apples are a lot cheaper. I have cut back on red meat now so that I may eat other types of fruit. I think it is very important for anyones diet. It helped me stay healthy as a child and continues to today. So keep eating fruits!
• Japan
31 Jan 09
i'd keep that in mind.
@magojordan (3252)
• Philippines
29 Jul 08
I think both fruits have their own health benefits. I love both fruits but I eat more bananas because apples here are very expensive. When I'm sick I eat more bananas because they are easier to eat than apples.
• Japan
31 Jan 09
yeah but did you know that eating apples can actually improve your smile. it helps to whiten your teeth!
29 Jul 08
For me the banana is the better of the two fruits,the banana is rich in potassium and when I have eaten my banana I will save the skin,then I cut the skin into small strips and then put it on to my garden,the potassiuom feeds the soil,so it has a dusl purpose,it is good to eat,and also good in a sandwich,then the skin is good compost to
• Lubbock, Texas
28 Jul 08
Both fruits are very important to health and contain very different nutrients. For overall digestive function (which, of course effects the entire body)plus the nutrition the apple is best, but the banana contains nutrients that absolutely essential to function of all the cells. The potassium is especially necessary to balance electrolytes and to keep the brain functioning properly. My best advice is to eat the fruits that are most readily available to you in their freshest form.
• Japan
31 Jan 09
the fresh thing is the best. we have apples here that when they are ripe enough have honeys. sweet and crunchy.
@dropofrain (1167)
• India
28 Jul 08
I think banana is a complete fruit containing all the essential vitamins and minerals. But the drawback of banana is that it has a lot of fat content in it. While apple, we all know should be included in the diet as it is also a nutritious fruit. But I think what you can do it eat banana and apple alternatively. This can educe your confusion also and keep you in budget also.
• Japan
31 Jan 09
yeah but fats that are good for our system. you can actually lose weight by eating banana for breakfast. just banana then you can eat whatever you want for the rest of the day.
• India
29 Jul 08
for me banana and apple are two good fruits which everyone should eat whenever there is a chance. As far as I am concerned there is not a lot of difference between the food values of both the fruits. Both are important at their respective places. In India both are readily available, whereas banana is available throughout the year, apple is seasonal. Our ancestors used to tell something about banana which I want to share that if we eat banana in the morning its benefit are like gold, if we eat it in the afternoon its benefits are like silver and if we eat it in the night it is just like a cow dung. Banana when not fully ripe is quite beneficial especially for young people, but for children they should be give ripen banana only. Apple as somebody mentioned is full of fibre is also a good food and a great appetiser and moreover having Vitamin C it protects from some common diseases like cold etc. So for me comparing banana and apple means comparing the benefits of cold weathere with hot weather. As opinions may differ but even after differences people should eat both of these fruit whenever available and encourage others to have one.
@dhevasena (144)
28 Jul 08
I like both fruits.. but guess it would have to be the bannana...
• Japan
31 Jan 09
i cannot make the day go without any fruits. i love them both!
@lixiaos77 (1030)
• Shijiazhuang, China
28 Jul 08
I can easily buy apple in low price, but i don't like fruit and i soldem eat them. I like to eat a lot vegetale, i believe vegetable can offer me all the nutrition that fruit can. But my mother, sister and wife like fruit, i often buy apples and peel apples for them. They believe fruit is indispensable, but they can't convince me because i am healthy all the time.
• Japan
31 Jan 09
there are some fruits that are sweet. i guess you can try them. plus you can love the scents that you can have while you peel them. i love fruits! have you tried making smoothies from fruits? you're gonna love them.