child spanking

India
August 1, 2008 5:00am CST
Do you spank your children? I know lot of towns and cities here where it's ok to do that to your children if they are not obedient. But I read that it's banned in certain countries. How you do discipline your children in such places if they are not obedient? And what's your personal opinion of spanking?
1 person likes this
3 responses
@mandykaren (2040)
1 Aug 08
hitting children was banned here long ago and i can understand the reasons.. You hit a child for being naughty and then if still naughty, what you do.. hit the child even harder? you see that is what happens, where do you stop? it can get out of hand and also a child grows up thinking its ok to hurt others, i seen where when a child is playing with a doll, and its quite frightening. she be hitting her doll REALLY hard saying you bad girl, because she thought it was normal as her mum would do it to her. And obviously a child looks up to their parents.. I do not agree with hitting a child.. child needs to feel safe and loved.. Shouting can do just as good or to take privilege away but not to inflict pain on child. That way you teaching child about life.. if bad or do wrong at a job can loose it, similar to loosing a privilege. My step father used to hit us, REALLY hard, and i later find out that his mum used to hit him.. I seen documentary, was a chat show of parents that hit their children to the extent that it was almost abuse, looked into the past of these parents and they had also been through it with their parents.. It becomes a mental thing, how you are bought up to believe that violence is ok I am strongly against hitting children.. you know, its more upsetting for a child if him/her sees that their mum or dad is very disappointed in their behavior especially if you always showed love and warmth..
2 people like this
• India
1 Aug 08
"you know, its more upsetting for a child if him/her sees that their mum or dad is very disappointed in their behavior especially if you always showed love and warmth..." This point is revealing. I was wondering if hitting the child has come to be considered as bad because of certain social conditions. In the place where I grew up as a kid I find it really hard for parents to discipline their children. Parents ask child to do something and the child just runs away to play with friends... situation like that is really annoying for parents. I may be wrong, but I felt that children tend to be more naughty where there are 30-40 friends. I don't find children having that in cities, but in a village all the children are friends, whether at school or at home. It seems to me that research programmes are mostly concentrated on city raised children and therefore for such children hitting really damages them. But if research programmes are conducted even for children raised in village setting that would be relevant because the social conditions is village is really different from that of cities. By this I am not advocating spanking. I was rather trying to ask if the principle of not spanking children is relevant for all. Blessings!
1 person likes this
• India
3 Aug 08
I am neither a father nor a mother so I have not experienced parenting...Not really experienced how a child can become naughty or how to train them. But I can understand that it's better to train them up lovingly than 'spankingly' (hmmm, I'm coining a new word:-) )By the way I'm rating you as well as give you BR. Blessings!
5 Aug 08
thankyou so much.. good word, spankingly what about caringly lovingly take care
@bamakelly (5191)
• United States
1 Aug 08
I don't have a habit of spanking my son. I usually use words to try to pacify or help my son when he is being a bit insolent or disobedient. I know that some places condone this and some places don't like it. Some people like to abide with the bible in stating that if you spare the rod, you spoil the child. I think it depends on individuals what they want to practice as long as there is no abuse.
• India
3 Aug 08
Your son is really good if he gets the point without the rod. I think most children will get the point that way. Blessings!
• United States
12 Aug 08
I am not a parent yet, but in a way I believe in spankings when it is appropriate, but I wouldn't spank my child. I just believe there are other ways of disciplining your children.
• India
14 Aug 08
oh, thanks for commenting.