They didn't let him eat!!!

United States
August 20, 2008 4:47pm CST
Ok, I might be being an overreactive mom right now, but I am really upset with my son's school. this was his third day in preschool and he did not eat anything all day. When I picked him up from school the school counelor told me she wasn't sure if he had gotten to eat or not because he had been sent to her during lunch because he would not sit down and be quiet during lunch time. Now I understand that he had to get in trouble for not listening, but it doesn't seem right that he was not allowed to eat anything. the only thing missing from his lunch box was a chocolate pudding. Am i overreacting or was it wrong of them to not allow him to eat?
2 people like this
5 responses
@Trace86 (5030)
• United States
20 Aug 08
I can see where you would be concerned that your son didn't eat. Everybody should have the opportunity to eat lunch. I just wonder if they warned him that if he didn't behave that he would be sent away and not get to eat his lunch at all. If they warned him and he still chose to misbehave, it is his own fault and choice that he didn't eat today. Missing one meal won't hurt him. Also, maybe he will learn that he needs to behave during lunch if he wants to be able to eat it. I am sure that they tried to get him to settle enough to eat. You should reinforce in the morning that he needs to listen to the teachers and behave so he can have fun at school and eat his lunch with the other kids.
• United States
26 Aug 08
I can see where you are coming from, but my son is not used to a school setting, he has been kept at home for the past 3 years with just his sister to play with and the neighbor kids, but he isn't used ot the routine of school yet. I agree that if he was acting wrong he should have been taken out of the lunch room, but they should have let him eat when they took him to the counselors office. My son is very hiper, and easily excited and seeing how this was his 3rd day of school and he was still getting to know the other kids, I don't think they should have been this harsh with him.
@alpram96 (95)
• United States
23 Aug 08
I don't think you are overacting at all. Most states have codes that daycares have to follow and feeding the child (whether they bring their own food or its provided for them) is usually one of the statues they have to follow. You are not allowed to withhold food as a form of punishment I would speak to the director the next time you take your son to daycare.
• United States
26 Aug 08
He is actually in kindergarten and I am looking into what their policies are to see how I should handle this. Of course I have to get the teachers side of the story today when i go see her.
• India
22 Aug 08
You are not over reacting, rather I wish my mom had acted with such concern. One of my most bitter memories of childhood is about a day in std I. I was 6yrs then and new to proper school and its rules (before std I, I was in pre-school)…I did not even recognize the principal for who she was when she came visiting our class that day and merrily I opened my lunch-box and popped something in though it was not lunch time. As punishment, I was told to stand outside the class and detained after school and my mom called to take me and listen to what an undisciplined, unruly child I was. I understood my mom’s confusion in not defending her child in front of the principal, but back home the least she could have done to assuage my hurt self was to help me overcome this trauma by being nice and not spanking me black and blue for embarrassing her. Schools often have this twisted way of disciplining a child and even if you cant always take it up with the teacher, tell your child at home that you are always with him/her. Forcing a child to skip lunch as a punishment is a very perverted and twisted way of forcing a child to fall in line…sooner or later that child will no longer love to go back to the teachers.
• United States
26 Aug 08
my mom was completely opposite of yours. she was always embarassing me because she faught my school for everything that she didn't agree with which was about every other week. Looking back on it i am so grateful for all she did for me and i can just hope that i am as good as she was. my son loves going to school, he has wanted to go for 3 years now and i hope that he doesn't get made to hate it by their treatment.
@foxyfire33 (10005)
• United States
22 Aug 08
There are betteer ways to punish misbehavior than by taking away lunch time! He should have been sent to the counselor's office with lunch box in hand. I think you should contact the head of the school and find out what the policy is and then you'll be better able to decide what to do from there.
• United States
26 Aug 08
I hadn't thought about checking the policy. I went to school in another state and I have been thinking that the rules would be the same here. thank you for the advice.
@auntiedis (165)
• United States
21 Aug 08
Um no, I don't think you're being overreactive. You should definitely march back down there and demand a better explanation than "I'm not sure if he ate". It's their responsibility to make sure our children are taken care of in our absence, and that includes them eating lunch! Perhaps all he wanted was the pudding though, so it may be best to ask your son's side of the story too.
• United States
26 Aug 08
I asked my son after he calmed down (he is really hiper when he gets home because he is not used to being outside of the house without us for so long). He just said that he was taken to the counselor because he called another kid a name. I am meeting with his teacher today to discuss his first week. She had sent me a message saying he got into trouble but she allowed him time to eat later. I'm not sure if they gave him some different food, or if he just chose not to eat, tat's one of the things i will find out today. he has come home every day starving, he is used to eating when he is hungry and not having ot wait, hopefully this week will be better.