Should Chantal have won instead of Saleisha? (cycle 9)

Chantal - Chantal is the runner-up for Americas Next Top Model (9)
New Zealand
August 26, 2008 2:01am CST
Although Saleisha was better and had more potential, she worked on Tyra's show before and she had experience before she came. I didn't think it was fair on everyone else, otherwise, Chantal would have won.
1 person likes this
5 responses
• United States
21 Sep 08
I think Saleisha was the best model and that she definately deserved to win. I also did like Heather. I thought she took amazing photos, and Lisa too. But at no point did I really think that chantal deserved to win. Her photos were never really that great. I don't think any of her photos stood out as much as Saliesha's. There have been other models with some experiece on the shows before.
• United States
11 Sep 08
Heather should have won. Saleisha was in the bottom two at least five times.
@youless (112123)
• Guangzhou, China
3 Sep 08
Compare to Saleisha, I like Chantal much more. But perhaps Saleisha was much more confident and therefore she performed better than Chantal. This is why she won it at last. I love China
@agcurtis (41)
• United States
5 Sep 08
No Chantel should not have won. Her runway performance was horrible, and Saleisha was the better model hands down. FYI, Saleisha did not work on Tyra's show before, she participated in T-Zone, to build up her self-esteem, as the camp is designed to do. As Tyra stated in the beginning of the cycle, she was going to be hard on Saleisha because of the training she received in T-Zone.
@marisriel (1156)
• Philippines
31 Aug 08
Although I liked Chantal better when it comes to looks, Saleisha outweighed her on the last modeling task. Saleisha really carried her self very well that time so her victory was expected.