Is it ever more loving to end your childs life then to let them suffer(disease)

@gem4678 (220)
United States
August 29, 2008 12:03am CST
I saw an episode of Law and Order SVU once that really brought me to tears and I just couldn't figure out how I felt about it. A woman had a child who ended up being diagnosed with Tay Sachs I believe it was and her doctor gave her sleeping pills to crush up and feed her baby in her formula. I am a person who gets very emotional when I hear about someone hurting a child let alone there own, but this one got to me very differently. Even though I could never do it I could see (of course its a movie and made to be dramatic) that she truly did it for the child, so that she wouldn't suffer the very horrible, painful disease that would lead to her inevitable painful and extremely early death. But the real question is is what she did an understandable or forgivable thing, or was she completely wrong and had no right. I don't know that I could judge someone who would do this because I could never imagine knowing my child would go through such horror. I really hope this doesn't tern into a big angry discussion, just something that another post I read reminded me of.
1 person likes this
2 responses
@redkathy (3374)
• United States
29 Aug 08
I think that maybe it is understandable, but totally wrong. I don't believe we have the right to kill someone, much less a child. What if a miracle was supposed to happen? It couldn't because of a decision.
@gem4678 (220)
• United States
29 Aug 08
Thank you you bring up a very good point. In the show they did end up convicting her of murder, I just don't know if I would have been able to do that, even the prosecutors and cops had a hard time with it. I guess maybe I put a little too much into television shows sometimes, but I always look at them as if what if that really happened which makes me think a little too much sometimes I think. Would be a very difficult situation to find yourself in.
@redkathy (3374)
• United States
29 Aug 08
Law and Order is a very good show. I used to watch it late at night before going to sleep.
@dawnald (85135)
• Shingle Springs, California
29 Aug 08
right, wrong, I don't know but... understandable... nobody wants to see their child suffer.
@gem4678 (220)
• United States
29 Aug 08
Thanks for your comment, I don't know that anybody will really be able to say whether it is right or wrong I know I can't and it looks like you can't either, I just feel like sometimes these things need to be discussed if anything else it helps bring understanding and knowledge sometimes. Thanks again for commenting.