Should a tenant have to work for their landlord?

United States
September 25, 2008 2:53pm CST
My family and I recently moved into a new apartment. It is not what you would call a great apartment. It is something of a slum. It isn't to bad, it's clean and in a fairly safe neighborhood. But it definitely is not without it's problems. We live in an apartment complex. Our bathroom toilet is not fastened down tight and wobbles. We have cracked windows, that were like that when we moved in. The kitchen ceiling leaks in a small spot when it rains; just to give a few examples of what I mean. So yeah, it is something of a slum. Those slight problems don't really bother us that much. We only moved into here because the rent is cheap which allows us to save up money faster toward a down payment to buy a house. There is a rent to own program here that doesn't care about your credit rating and in which we only need 4% down to buy a house. The only requirement after making the down payment is to keep your monthly payments up. What we do have a problem with is our landlord. During a discussion with the landlord my husband made the mistake of telling him (our landlord) that he (my husband) was good at fixing things and was experienced in maintenance, building construction/ remodel and repair. Since that time, every time a tenant or tenants need something fixed, the landlord calls us or comes over and practically demands that my husband go and fix whatever it is. Our landlord does not pay my husband for these chores, nor does he give us a reduction in our rent. In fact, he does not compensate my husband in any way for the work. After a few times my husband got sick of this and so he starting telling the landlord, "NO!" Well this did not please the landlord at all and he got upset and was very rude about it. My husband explained to the landlord that he works at his paying job 6 days a week and 12 hours a day for at least half the week, therefore he doesn't really have time to take on extra work for him, especially when he is not being compensated for said work. The landlord did not like that either and left in a huff. Well, the next thing we knew, our wonderful landlord had told every other tenant in the building that if they needed something fixed that they were to come knock on our door and tell my husband to fix it because it was my husband's job to do so! Now, at least every other day we have one of our neighbors knocking on our door begging to have this fixed or that fixed. We would move out, but we just got settled in here and there are not many places for rent in the area where we live so it would take a while to find another apartment anyway. Plus, as I already mentioned, we were only planning on being in this apartment on a short term basis to begin with since we are saving to buy a house. What is your thoughts on this? What would you do in this situation?
1 person likes this
7 responses
@shoeb000 (321)
• India
25 Sep 08
Surely not, a tenant pays the landlord in terms of cash, so there is no question of working for him in any form. But if there is a well established relation between landlord and tenant... the landlord is too helping and caring for tenants, then tenants can think about helping in few small works of landlord... but again its due to affection and its not a "MUST DO" kind of thing.
1 person likes this
• United States
26 Sep 08
Yes, I agree.
@pyewacket (43903)
• United States
25 Sep 08
First of all, I'm glad your husband told off the landlord, but now it seems he's retaliated by telling the other tenants that if they need repairs to knock on your door and get your husband to fix things. What your landlord is doing is illegal It's be one thing if your husband was the super of the building then yes he would be required to make repairs, but he isn't. Second, for instance our super IS compensated...the landlord not only pays him a small salary to be super but the super and his family live RENT free..Your landlord is doing neither. Are there any housing authorities you can contact? PM me...to tell me where you live...I might be able to do a search for you of places to contact to make a formal complaint...of course this could make things worse for you, but the law would be on your side
• United States
26 Sep 08
Our building does not even have a super. Our landlord is a slum lord and according to the other tenants, before we moved in, never bothered to even try to have anything fixed or repaired other then the minimum that he has to have done in order to keep the building up to code so he doesn't get in trouble with the housing authorities. Now that we live here and he has learned that my husband knows how to make many types of housing repairs, he (the landlord) seems to think it is ok to try to intimidate my husband into doing them in order to get the tenants off his (the landlord)butt! You are right that it is illegal. Of course if he was willing to compensate my husband, either by paying him or giving us a discount in rent, we might be willing to consider it. But since he isn't, we're not and we want him to stop harassing us and stop sending the other tenants to our door! I don't have any idea how to find out the contact info. for the local housing authority, but it is a good idea to get in touch with them and see what can be done. I will send you a pm, thanks.
1 person likes this
@pyewacket (43903)
• United States
26 Sep 08
Okay just sent you a PM with a listing of a lot of places you might be able to contact with help with this. sheesh...slum landlords....think we have the same one? LOL...Our landlord has a lot of violations in all the buildings he owns too, and the jerk is a near millionaire...he has casino resorts all over the Greek isles, yet when he gets materials to upgrade any part of the buildings he gets cheap crap
• United States
26 Sep 08
Yep! That sounds a lot like our landlord. He owns the building I am in, another apartment complex just a couple blocks away, also rundown, he was recently bragging about owning some motel that he apparently recently sold for a bunch of money, plus several rental houses and other apartment buildings in another city, which I'm sure are also run down from what I've heard. My husband did do a couple of minor repair jobs for him the first couple times that he asked just to be nice without realizing that it would become a never ending demand. One of those jobs wasn't even in the building that we live in, it was for the one down the street. That one was fixing part of a floor and I went with him and helped him clean up when he did it. The supplies our landlord generously supplied to fix the floor? a very old/aged piece of osb board and some old tile that he had lieing around that not only did not match the tile that was already on the floor, it wasn't even the same size! also my husband had to use his own tools, most of which were not the best for the job!
@jillbeth (2705)
• United States
25 Sep 08
Your landlord has absolutely no right to expect your husband to do repairs, especially without some type of compensation! You may just have to politely explain the situation to your neighbors when they come knocking, and stand up to your landlord when he demands that your husband fix something! Don't let him take advantage of you, tell him if he expects to use your husband's talents then he will have to pay for them! He sounds like a really rotten landlord anyway, and I'm sure the rest of the tenants know it, so I hope you can save enough money soon to get out of there!
• United States
26 Sep 08
I hope it doesn't take us long to save too. The landlord is rotten, but then he's a slum lord so we sort of expected that to a point, but this one takes the cake!
@uath13 (8192)
• United States
25 Sep 08
I don't know about the laws in your area but around here the landlord is responsable for any & all repairs. Failure to do the proper repairs could get him in all kinds of trouble. I'd check your local laws out & see what can be done.
@uath13 (8192)
• United States
26 Sep 08
Ever considered making a business of it? Those other tenants might not come knocking if they had to pay for the repairs. If they still do at least you'd be making extra money at your price which might be convenient for the tenants & make more money for you to use to get out.
• United States
26 Sep 08
Landlords are responsible for repairs where I live too. He wouldn't get in trouble for the condition of the building in itself though, as it is "up to code". The things he is hassling my husband to fix are minor repairs, such as fixing hinges on closet doors and things like that. Still, these repairs are endless as one tenant or another always seems to need something done and the landlord still has no legal right to demand that my husband be one to do it, especially since he wants free labor. My husband is not the landlord's slave!
• United States
27 Sep 08
No I do not think tenants should work for their landlords unless the landlord is compensating the tenants for their work in some way. If you were getting a rent reduction or were getting a bit of pay for it than I would say that doing that kind of thing around the complex would be OK. However, since you're not getting compensation for it I'd think there should be someone about housing in your area that you can call to report a bad landlord. Housing would have to take care of it and make him change it. Since your husband is not an employee of the apartment building, he's not required to do anything and your landlord should not be telling other tenants to come to your apartment to get things fixed. Your landlord is just slacking on his duties and enjoys getting things done for free.
@relundad (2310)
• United States
25 Sep 08
I would put a note on the front door that says MAINTENANCE MAN DOES NOT LIVE HERE CONTACT LANDLORD AT (123)456-7890.
• United States
26 Sep 08
LOL! Good idea! I bet our landlord would really love that!
@jillmalitz (5131)
• United States
26 Sep 08
Your landlord is wrong. He should not ask a tenant to fix everything with out compensation. Just think of the liability. If your husband fixes something and something goes wrong who will be responsible? Who is going to be sued? Many situations require licensed electricians or plumbers, etc and should not be done by a professional. Sure your husband has the experience and many landlords tell tenants to fix a problem and send them the bill for reimbursement. But usually that is if a tenant fixes his own unit. I would worry about the liability for your husband.