Which is worse dilemma

United States
October 1, 2008 5:45pm CST
My son used to bombard all of us with 'which is worse' kind of questions... stuff like "would you rather be stranded on a chunk of iceberg all alone in the Arctic Ocean, or have an army of red ants sting you?" Hehehehe, gawd, it was like NEITHER ONE THANK YOU! I was really glad when he got through that phase! I used to have a parrot that was soooo noisy! He wouldn't shut up! We would be sitting around in the living room trying to have a conversation and he would be laughing and talking along with us... he would be so loud that we would have to start talking louder to be heard, which of course only made him talk louder, and louder and LOUDER till we would have to take him out of the room, which would p!ss him off and he would start screeching and yelling. It was pretty annoying at the time but it was also very funny. I came across a 'which is worse' question (not one of my son's, hehehe) that went "which is worse... a parrot that won't talk or a parrot that won't shut up?" and I was reminded of how when a stranger would meet him for the first time and would ask if he talked, we'd be like YEAH! But could we get him to say one friggin' word?!?!?!?!?!? NO! So that has left me in a quandary and I cannot answer the question. I think I need more data. Maybe if I heard a few stories it would help me to decide… so, anyone ever had a talking bird that either talked too much or wouldn’t shut up?
3 people like this
5 responses
@SaintAnne (5453)
• United States
1 Oct 08
I am to Boyfriend what your son was to you. I am big on "Would You Rather's" and Boyfriend sometimes could not believe that I think up these scenarios. Plus, I don't know if you already know this but there is a board game for that. http://www.zobmondo.com/index.php I don't think I'll ever have a pet bird, especially a talking one. But my mom when she stayed with a friend in the Philippines during a vacation shared this story with us. Her friend's parrot knew how to say "Let's eat", "Are you going home now?" and "pretty girl" in the local dialect. It also knew how to do that "you're sexy" whistle. My mom always jumped when she heard the parrot say something because she thought it was a real person. Also, here are some links that may convince you to want your parrot to talk: http://news.bbc.co.uk/cbbcnews/hi/newsid_7510000/newsid_7518700/7518732.stm http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/21443309/
1 person likes this
• United States
2 Oct 08
Hahahaha! I knew you felt like family! No I did not know about this game! I love their website! I filled out the survey in the hopes of winning some of their games because for sure my son is getting one of these for Christmas!!! One day our bird was sitting on his perch in the living room. The front door was open except for the screen door. My brother was upstairs getting ready to vacuum his room when he heard 'chop chop chop chop', hehehe, it was really 'knock knock knock knock', but he thought one of us was in the kitchen prepping for dinner. The bird says "Hellloooo!" and my brother answers back "Helllloooo" then the bird says "Hellllooo" again and my brother answers the same, they go back and forth like this for a minute or so, then my brother says "Goodbye" and switches on the vacuum cleaner. Nobody ever answered the door to our landlord, who was already pretty perturbed with us as it was. He called us on the phone later ranting about standing there at our door with a bunch of lunatics yelling hello hello goodbye but nobody ever answering the door. We got kicked out of that house eventually, hehehe.
1 person likes this
• United States
2 Oct 08
PS: Great links btw!!! I know they are telling the truth too... no way our house would have burned down without that bird of ours waking us all up! That was really funny about the smoke alarm!! I bet the bird had been around burnt dinners with the smoke detector going off!
1 person likes this
@SaintAnne (5453)
• United States
2 Oct 08
I was laughing so hard just sampling the zobmondo site. Of course, I had to ask some of the questions to Boyfriend who after three disgusting dilemmas begged that I let him read his school book instead. Also, don't you think we could use their questions here on myLot and find out what the people here are really like? I do hope you get to win that game for your son. I like your hello goodbye story. Reminds me of the Target commercial. The landlord must have thought that you guys were mocking him as he waited at the door. I'm glad you enjoyed the fire alarm bird links as much as I did.
1 person likes this
@James72 (26790)
• Australia
2 Oct 08
I had a bird that used to imitate the doorbell, does this count? The little bugger used to provide me with around 50% of my daily exercise I reckon because I had to get up constantly to check if someone was at the door! He also used to imitate my car starting and would wolf whistle at my Grandma whenever she walked past his cage! lol. I have always loved birds for their personalities and think they can be more expressive than many other pets I have ever had. As for your bird with stage fright? Well given this event and all the screeching etc I am suprised you didn't lose the plot and add a whole new twist on the Thanksgiving meal!
1 person likes this
@James72 (26790)
• Australia
2 Oct 08
By the way, how the heck did this discussion end up being created in the CATS section??
1 person likes this
@James72 (26790)
• Australia
4 Oct 08
cockatiel - A small bird and a popular pet! Some can speak and they are great at imitating sounds also.
I have been bitten by a bird myself and would have to say it is one of the most painful things ever! This bird was a cockatiel and his name was Boris. I had a second one with him called Yeltsin! lol. I have attached a picture of a cockatiel because I think they are called different names in other countries..... He couldn't speak but used to imitate a number of different sounds. He was a biter too so he's lucky he didn't end up wall bound himself actually!
1 person likes this
• United States
4 Oct 08
This discussion ended up in the cats section because I figured a pet is a pet is a pet. In other words, I was too lazy to add 'talking birds' to my interests. What kind of a bird did you have? That sounds very cute, his imitating the doorbell and your car starting. And your grandmother must have been very flattered! Hehehehe. And while I never considered having him for Thanksgiving dinner I dreamed I flung him full force against the wall once! I guess he had really been annoying me. He got hold of my sisters finger one night and would not let go! He was vicious!
2 people like this
• India
3 Oct 08
Well, I have had talking people that talked too much and wouldn't shut up! Give me a bird anytime. At least, they are amusing. And they don't misunderstand, read between the lines, fight, argue, and create an unholy mess with their words. So, give me a parrot anytime. Unfortunately, I have never had a parrot. Parrots would come to my garden to eat the beans of a particular flowering plant called "ratnagandhi." They only screeched; they never talked. There is a law against keeping "wild animals" as pets here. And a parrot comes under the "wild animal" category. :) Cheers and happy mylotting
1 person likes this
• India
4 Oct 08
My stupid ex husband brought a parrot once. It snipped off a bit of his finger, and he danced around in pain for quite sometime. A really wise bird! Selling parrots is against the law here. They belong to the wild and they are supposed to live in the wild. This silly fellow should have known it before he bought it from a man on the roadside. Besides, the parrots wings were clipped so that it could not fly. I took care of it till it grew its wings and let it escape. I felt sorry for the bird. It did not like me, but I could understand why it did not like me although I got frustrated at that time. And my stupid ex husband also caught a poor little love bird once. I don't know where he caught it, but he wanted me to cage it and "take care" of it. I let the little fellow escape, watched him fly to a bush outside, sit on the branch and sing for a while before he flew off and disappeared. I don't mind birds coming to me for a bit of something to eat, but they should be free. I don't believe in putting them in a cage and keeping them as pets. Why, I even used to feel sorry for my poor chickens. Even today, I can't eat chicken. Cheers!!
1 person likes this
• United States
7 Oct 08
I do not like keeping birds as pets either, unless it was like I said and they could come and go of their own volition. The same as my other pets.
1 person likes this
• United States
4 Oct 08
Well, my bird left scars on two people's faces and almost took my sister's finger off, so you might want to rethink that, hehehehe. Of course all parrots are not as unfriendly as he was, I think he was very p!ssed off at being taken out of the jungle! I know I would be!!! Plus, my brother said he had been abused. I would not want to have a parrot again unless it would be able to fly free and visit me when it wanted a free meal or something, or just wanted to say hi, hehehe.
1 person likes this
@drannhh (15219)
• United States
1 Oct 08
I never had a talking bird and never would have one, but I did have a parakeet once who liked to "sign" my letters for me by coming down from my shoulder and making a bite mark right between the "Sincerely" and my name. So he was expressive in a different manner, but still got to show off.
1 person likes this
• United States
2 Oct 08
I would never have another one either, unless I lived in the tropics where it could go or stay as it chose. They are very messy. I had a couple of finches once. My bf had made them a HUGE 6 ft tall and 6ft in diameter cage which we kept out on the balcony of our condo in Florida. We put a ficus tree in there and they made themselves a nest in it. Then one evening my boyfriend forgot to close the door of the cage after he fed them and I came out just in time to see them hop off the ledge and fly away. It broke my heart to watch their little bird bodies disappear into the horizon. I could not bring myself to close their door and my bf laughed at me for harboring the hope that they would return one day. The next morning I was awakened by finch song but I was so accustomed to it that I did not think anything about it at first, then it hit me!!!! I went racing out to the balcony and there they were hopping around on the floor of their cage eating dropped seeds!!! We named them Bill & Ted after that because we figured they had had an 'excellent adventure! Hehehehehe.
1 person likes this
• United States
7 Oct 08
Why does that not surprise me??
1 person likes this
@CJscott (4187)
• Portage La Prairie, Manitoba
19 Aug 09
My mom had a cockatiel once that wouldn't talk at all, though it was of the talking variety. Brother let it out one day...Boy did he get it, a $300 bird, and it just flew out the window one summer day, probably headed straight south, on account of the weather being to cold for it or pure instinct, mom made us scour the neighborhood, then the town....Gosh. But yea that is about all. The bird wasn't quite old enough to be talking yet anyways. It liked to bite me, cause I was the only one "stupid" enough to put it back when the door was open, it hated being in that cage.
• United States
19 Aug 09
I used to carry my Amazon up to the dirt bike track where I jogged every day. I would put him in the mulberry tree and let him climb around and eat mulberries. One day he was being a pain in the a$$ and refusing to come to me. I finally got tired of trying to coax him down and left him there. I went back the next morning figuring he'd be ready to come down now! Sure enough, he was. The next time that happened though, when I went out to get him the next morning he was gone... there was a pepsi can by the tree that had not been there before and the grass was all trampled. I figure what happened was a couple of kids were riding their bikes up to the track and he hollered "HELLLLOOO" down at them and they were hooked. Another time I had some finches that we kept in a huge 6X6 cage out on our balcony when we lived in Florida. We had a ficus tree in there and they even had a nest in the tree. One day my then boyfriend forgot to close the door on their cage and I walked out to the balcony just in time to see them fly off. I stood there and watched their little bodies disappear into the horizon. The next morning I awoke to finch song. It was so normal for me to hear that sound that it took me a minute to register that the finches were gone. I went out to the balcony feeling like I was in a dream or something, and there they were - hopping around the bottom of their cage looking for seeds! We named them Bill & Ted after that because we figured they had to have had an excellent adventure, hehehehe.