Traffic Lights - The cause of...........

November 13, 2008 7:50pm CST
I have this happy observation when the traffic lights are out in the village. First of all I wonder why there isn't any traffic about, then I realise it is because the light are out of order again. I appreciate there are points lights may be required, but I find the pattern repeats on local roads. Traffic lights out = no traffic. Any one else have these experiences or others involving stuff that is supposed to help but rather seem to hinder?
1 person likes this
5 responses
@BubblyIan (750)
14 Nov 08
well spotted you are correct! Traffic lights cause congestion. of course they do! Clearly when there are no lights, people will try and continue through the junction as soon as they can. With lights they cannot do that, they must wait for a green light. On large crossroads, usually only one section of the four will be allowed to move at a time. however many people want to take the first exit so do not need to use the whole crossroads and without lights can easily do so. Lights are NOT there to aid traffic flow they are there for 'safety' reasons. The congestion designers (sometimes known as town planners) believe that there is less of a chance of an accident at an intersection with lights than without. So it may be 'safer' to have lights, but it definitely is not quicker.
1 person likes this
14 Nov 08
Point definitely taken, on local roads I really do think sensor control should be th way forward. These lights are often out and we have not had any accidents at either of these points in the long time I have lived here. I like to bring up the point you have made when often a person turning that wouldn't be in the way of the traffic is also held for no reason. If there is no one able to cross your path there is no chance of an accident. Did you also know that they are trying to change the legal definition of accident to intended collision, might soon have to be much more careful when involved in something unintentional as you may well incriminal yourself in the future if this happens.
1 person likes this
14 Nov 08
It's great to hear your opinion, I like your forthright approach as well. Something that occured to me was that people study to become planners, but are studying something that doesn't work. Now I'm trying to fathom how things could get any better? lol! We have a little cross road down the road that has 5 exits, 2 of the roads are hardly used on the the two main areas were under lights control. Now tey have put lights at every road exit, I'd forgotton about it until I go stuck their earlier watching the tumbleweed in the wind. I know certain places they are really there because it the only safe option. Also those on big motoway junctions that none would pass without right of way otherwise. On a note about fines, Common Law & sense should prevail and be applied accordingly rather than fines just be sent automatically. We all have a right to expect so. Luckily I haven't come up against anything as such so far. I picked up on a quote about law in one of the responses, I think though they meant legality or legislation, law is a very different thing.
14 Nov 08
More govrnment 'knee-jerk' reaction to accidents. Rather than accepting that the design of the junction was wrong, they blame everyone else but themselves and introduce more laws. There is absolutely no evidence throughout history that punisghing people is the way to encourage law following! Rewaard and encouragement is better than threats. People obey laws if they are sensible. Traffic lights sensors are the ONLY way to control lights. Most are on fixed timings and are absurd in their settings! Linked lights are even more absurd and clearly show the lack of brain cells in the congestion designers! There should always be an option for the first exit to have its own turn lane to bypass lights - this is not rocket science but seems to baffle most of the congestion designers!
1 person likes this
@xfahctor (14118)
• Lancaster, New Hampshire
14 Nov 08
I don't actualy have any traffic lights in my town, or any of the surrounding ones either (REALLY small town). hmmm...perhaps people don't want to travel with out traffic control. Interesting way to control travel isn't it though.
1 person likes this
14 Nov 08
I often wonder in certain places if the action really is to control. I sometimes think sitting there waiting in 1st gear is that if I was moving it would probably cost me less. Less petrols required if you don't have to slow down, also less wear and tear on the car but not using lower gears. Perhaps it's to keep industry flowing rather than us? Definitely interesting.
14 Nov 08
Just another quick thought, I like the use of travel rather than drivers or vehicles.................
14 Nov 08
Just popped in to my mind, do people really know what they want? After all we've all spent too many years being told, rather than to think for ourselves and to know. Life shouldn't be this complicated affair, those that sit in positions of power make it so. Live, Love, Learn, Look out for one another!
@irisheyes (4370)
• United States
16 Nov 08
I long for the good old, simple traffic lights where red meant stop and green meant go. We now have these fancy dancy lights that still have red and green but are coupled with hands. You now need a green light accompanied by a thumbs up. Unless there is no turning traffic and you can make a run for it. You practically need a course to cross a street. We even have one light that chirps. The first time my friend and I ever heard it, we thought a bird was trapped in the newspaper box beside the light so we put some change in to release the poor little critter. Turns out it was the light. I've heard other people have done the smame thing. That news box must be a little gold mine. LOL
@ZephyrSun (7381)
• United States
14 Nov 08
So the traffic lights being out deters traffic? Not here, the drivers are suppose to just treat the intersection as if there were stop signs there. But, I live in a big city and nothing stops traffic, not even a blizzard.
1 person likes this
14 Nov 08
Hi there Yes, traffic lights here really do deter drivers from going through them in general. I'd say this mainly down to the love of fining people in the UK, everyone is trying their best to protect their pockets here. Big big cash cow for them, we also have far toooooo many speed cameras. Again where they are due, fair enough, but often they pepper the street frequently. Lots and lots of revenue!
@evanslf (484)
14 Nov 08
I have certainly had the experience that on a busy junction where there are numerous traffic lights, when these fail the traffic seems to flow more smoothly. I suspect the reason for this is that traffic 'self-regulates': by this I mean that people drive up to the junction and then move out broadly in turn, which keeps the traffic flowing. Traffic lights are of course essential on busy roads, but they can lead to 'inefficiencies' in traffic flow in that they can hold up a bunch of cars on the one hand whilst showing green on the other junction when there are no cars about - this leads to build up where the light is red and wastage of time as the cars at the red light can't go, but if there are no / few cars at the green light, then the traffic inefficiency is created. Hope this makes some kind of sense!
1 person likes this
14 Nov 08
The other thing I notice when stuck at a light is, that when it is green I'm not moving, but once the light has turned we move towards it? We have a few that are sensor controlled and I think on local roads it would be a good idea to implement these in many more places. I often sit at our small crossroads, being the only car waiting for the conseutive signal to get back to me and allow me to move in to the traffic free road. If I'd have ignored the lights often, not a soul would have know and I would have been on my way without another soul being infringed in the process. Makes me think of the phrase if a tree falls in the woods and no one is around to hear does it stll make a noise?