Did you know that nursery rhymes are more violent than TV shows by up to 10X!

Philippines
November 14, 2008 9:30pm CST
I have learned that traditional nursery rhymes have far more violent scenes than TV shows! A research team in England discovered that an hour of listening to nursery rhymes exposes a child to 10 times more violent scenes than an hour of watching pre-9p.m. programs on British TV. The researchers analyzed violence in more than 25 popular rhymes and in five UK TV channels for two weeks. The findings? There were almost five violent scenes per hour of TV viewing compared to 52 per hour of listening to nursery rhymes. Although the study approach was tongue-in-cheek, the researchers said it still shows that it is too simplistic to blame television alone for children's violent behavior. Examples of vicious rhymes are: humpty dumpty - nasty head injuries from fall, jack and jill - double hillside fall tragedy, simple simon - tongue and finger injuries and thrown to the ground by a cow, six in a bed - repeated bedtime tumbles, and rock-a-bye baby - cradle crashes to the ground from a great height.
2 responses
@luneliza (197)
21 Dec 08
I can understand the problem. I have a site with nursery rhymes and I'm trying to make them as harmless as possible. The truth is that I have one that mentions an "electric chair" and I've been wondering for a while whether to take it out or not. I find the poem quite funny, it is the object in itself and its significance that puts chills on my back. I keep thinking that there are kids that don't know what an electric chair is and it would disturb them to find out. Could you help me with an advice? Would you let your child read this poem or not? http://funnyrhymes.blogspot.com/2008/04/once-i-had-strange-nightmare.html
@yuna15 (2706)
• Philippines
15 Nov 08
This is really good information and very much interesting. It does make a lot of sense though because the nursery was put into a context into what children could easily understand. Whereas regular movies, children mostly does not understand this things. Parents would still need to properly guide children when watching nursery rhymes.