Choosing a baby's name

November 25, 2008 1:34pm CST
Are you the one who chooses your own baby's name? Or have you ever been given an opportunity of choosing a name for the baby or babies before or after they are born? In my family, I am the one who always chooses the name to be given to my nephews and nieces before or on the day when they are born. Sometimes my brothers and sisters don't like it, so they have to change but only with my consent. When my second nephew was born, I told them already what name I had chosen for him, but then my sister in law's mother registered him to a different one. I was so angry why they didn't follow the name that I had chosen, because I didn't like it. So her mother had to go back to the registrar's office to change it to the one I had chosen. Do you think I am doing the right thing? Or am I offending their rights to give their own sons and daughters a name?
1 person likes this
27 responses
@carmela0210 (1591)
• Philippines
26 Nov 08
hey you should give your sisters and her husbnad do the honor to chose names for there child only you could make was to suggest, i just think thats the proper, but on my part my niece we named it not just me but also my other sisters, we were the one who choses her name, but with consent with my sister, or until they approves it!!good thing they liked it too!!happy lotting...
• Philippines
27 Nov 08
ohh ok!!heheheh, yeah next time!!lol, but really its always been a pleasure chossing names for the baby!!but we should always consider that its not our baby!!
26 Nov 08
Cheers, I was given this opportunity at first because I am the eldest in the family as their respect for me I being asked to name my eldest niece. But then I got carried away, and so on I am the one always choose their names. You're right, next time I will just suggest then they choose whatever they want. Anyway the kids loves their names I had chosen for them too. Blessings!
@roniroxas (10560)
• Philippines
25 Nov 08
wow... i wont let that happen to me. this are my children and i have the right to pick the name i wanted for them. i wont allow someoen to choose a name for my off springs. the name of my children are Justice now 17, Jury now 16, Judge 14 and Judiciary 12. i am the one who picked my childrens name and so as my other relatives they are the one who picked their childrens name. in my view yes you are offending their rights, if you want to choose names for their children then it is okay to give them suggestions but not force them on what name you wanted for their own children.
1 person likes this
@roniroxas (10560)
• Philippines
26 Nov 08
if they wanted your suggestion then you can still give names. but if they dont like it then just let them choose what they like. you dont have to get angry and be upset. thank you also that after this discussion you came to realize that doing that is not proper. thank you also for listening to our opinions. hugs
1 person likes this
26 Nov 08
Thanks for your opinion I appreciate it. Well, now I am starting to change my ruling in the family, maybe I have gone too far its about time for them to choose their own children's name now. After I had posted this discussion it really awaken me up. It was me who always to be followed in the family as they all respect me, but in this thing I might just change for the better not to choose their names anymore.
@ebsharer (5515)
• United States
26 Nov 08
My husband and I chose our daughters name. Many family members gave us there imput. We didn't know if we were having a boy or girl. We did the "suprise" thing. We had picked out Chase Edward for a boy. Chase being a "new" name and Edward being my husbands middle name. For a girl we had originally picked out Brooke but later decided that was too common. So we picked out a family name Luann. My great grandfather was Lou and my great grand mother was Ann Marie. So we put the names together to get Luann. I am SOO very happy we ended up with Luann as a name - it fits her prefectly. Some family memebers call her Lulu others call her Lu. Her cousin calls her Luie! No offence but I wouldn't let any one else name my child! That's MY right as the parent! I don't know why your family thinks its okay for you to name there kids but its not. You have to let them name there own children. Giving an opinion is fine but ultimatly it should be up to the parents!
1 person likes this
26 Nov 08
That's a lovely combination of names! Yes, I am glad that posting this discussion made me realised of the wrong thing I have done for my family, by offending their rights to name their own children. I will take everyone's good advice from here on mylot who share their best opinions for this discussion, it's helpful for me. Now it's time for them to decide for their own children's name. Thanks for sharing.
@ersmommy1 (12588)
• United States
25 Nov 08
We recently did this. My hubby and I are expecting our son via c-section Dec 10. My hubby picked several names. Then we ran the names past family members on both sides. The one most family members liked is the one we went with. But we chose the name. Yours is a different tradition I guess. But I couldn't conceive of letting anyone but my hubby and myself having final say in our childs name. Suggestions are fine. But I think the decision should be left to the parents. Each family does it differently.
1 person likes this
25 Nov 08
Wow, congratulations! Is that your first baby? Anyway, maybe it's because I don't have my own baby, that's why I love choosing names for my nephews and nieces and as the eldest in the family they don't have a choice than to follow me so that I will not be mad to them. And I am the one who always have the final decision in my family. It's nothing to do with traditions because I haven't learnt it from our traditions. I learnt and did it my way.
25 Nov 08
What I meant is nothing to do with my country's tradition because I didn't learn it from there. But it has become a tradition in my own family.
• Philippines
26 Nov 08
well, if you are going to submit a baby it sould be unique. May name is not that unique because it ws my aunti who have cosen his/her name. I prefer old name for the name of my babies in the future.
1 person likes this
26 Nov 08
Yes, thanks a lot. Well, even if our name is unique or not it was given to us already so we just have to learn to like and love it. My name was'nt picked by own parents they said, it was the priest in the church who picked it during my christening day because the priest said, the name that my parents had chosen was too awful for me. So he had chosen a name for me and my parents have to take it too. I wanted to meet that priest who had chosen my name to give me a clue what is the meaning of it, but sadly he was gone.
@luminouz (32)
• United States
26 Nov 08
Hello. May I ask, why are you the one to choose the names? Is it due to tradition/custom? In my family, I have chosen a name for my cousin, and my God-daughter, Kamerin. However, these names were selected based on the parent's request for suggestion. I have named my owns son's, what I wanted to name them, even if I did ask suggestions, or anyone offered names, even their father. I feel that it's nice you're willing to do the job of choosing a name, as it is not as easy as it sounds. But, and I mean no disrespect, by getting angry that someone else has chosen a name (which wasn't specified if the grandmother/mother/father chose that name) is crossing the line. Also, for the parents needing your consent to change their own childs name. You stated yourself in a response you wouldn't want someone else to name YOUR own child. I feel, if the ask your opinion or help, by all means, give them your help and suggestions, but don't take it personal and get upset if they don't choose the name you suggest. Whatever the child's name is, he or she will be loved just the same as if their name was something else. Of course everyone wants their child's name to be meaningful, and whatever their names are, there's always meaning and reason behind it. Hope it works out better for you next time, have a great day.
26 Nov 08
Hi, thanks for asking. No, it's not the tradition of my country but it's made like a tradition in my family already as I am the one who is the provider of my family. Now, since I put this discussion and have good responses I have changed my mind to give them the chance or the right to name their own children. They all respect and obey my words and before they make a decision to their personal issue they will ask me first if it is right or wrong for them, mostly I have the final decision about everything for my family. I am thankful that there are real people who respond to this discussion as it helped me realised where I have gone too far for the rights of my own siblings.Blessings.
@anne12d (676)
• Philippines
26 Nov 08
Well, if they chooses you to give the name for their kid, that's fine. But of course dont expect that all of your relatives will choose the name you've chosen besides that's their kid's name. Give them choices, and put yourself to their shoes sometimes. Happy mylotting!
1 person likes this
26 Nov 08
Thanks for sharing your opinion, I appreciate it. Yes, I just realised it now, I should not have been angry when they registered my nephew to a different name than what I had chosen. It's alright now they all love his name anyway, so it made us all happy. Next time yes I will just give my suggestions to them so they will enjoy their parenting more.
@maroseqf (3657)
• Philippines
26 Nov 08
Really? That is great! I have many nephews and nieces but I didn't had the chance to suggest a name for them before they were born. I believe that it is already up to their parents. In my case, I was the one who came up with our son's name. I suggested it to my husband and he agreed to it.
1 person likes this
26 Nov 08
Yes, my brothers and sisters respected me and followed mostly everything what I say to them, I even have always the final decision for the family. Maybe that's where I was mistaken to lead them I shouldn't offend some of their rights especially as they are parents now, not like me. I can see the feeling of being an Aunt is different than being parents to your own child it's more happier I guess. Take good care.
@idcoder (382)
• India
26 Nov 08
naah...this is something good and if others parents dnt like thy may suggest some other names...the birth of a new one in the family is something to be happy about..everyone can come up with some name and then throw chits to decide..
1 person likes this
26 Nov 08
Yes, it happened when my very first nephew was born, his mother have not chosen a name yet, so his mother asked her husband what name to be given to their boy. And too much happiness they both feel as a first time parents, they just asked me to give their child a name as a respect to me as well. Then later on, her husband's family came and suggested a name I told them it's too late I had chosen one already and it's registered, so they just stared at me. Anyway they all love the baby and his name.
@neozero (171)
• Malaysia
26 Nov 08
Of course you are not doing the right thing. Have you ever considered the feeling of the child parents. A name is very important to a person. The parent will have to call tehir name for the rest of either person life ends. You can force ppl to use a name they dont really like. If I was your brother in law you might have been slapped for peing possesive. Let to respect the boundaries that you should not cross.
1 person likes this
26 Nov 08
Yes, you're right! I agree with you wholeheartedly, I got carried away with my ownself at that moment that's why I was disappointed when they didn't register the baby to the name I have chosen because I were the first one who was being asked to name the baby, and I thought they agreed with it but then her mother have another name for him and registered him. It's alright now, his name was changed to the name I have chosen and everybody is happy as they accept it, I just felt guilty for what I have done to my sister in law's mother. Thanks for sharing.
• China
26 Nov 08
My daughter's name is chosen by a fortuneteller. In China, many parents choosing their children's name pay attention to their birthday horoscope, because they hope the children have a happpy life in the future. we always care whether the names are pleasant to hear or meaningful.
1 person likes this
26 Nov 08
Oh wow, that's lovely! Actually, I had chosen my niece's second name from a chinese horoscope and dictionary, I just love how it is being pronounce and it's very meaningful. I got this idea from my research of sweet and special names for babies. Now her name suits her and they all love it, not because of the meaning but of how it's being pronounced when they call her, it's sweet!
• United States
25 Nov 08
I am the one who chose my daughters name and I'll be the one to pick any of my future children's names. My ex and I were still together when I had my daughter, so of course he had input, but I'll be damned if anyone put biological parents will be dictating the name of my children. I picked my daughter's name because since I was 7 years old I had been saying I wanted twin girls named Destiny and Trinity. Well I only had one girl, so she got the name Trinity. I was NOT going to budge from that name. My mom sort of gave my daughter her middle name, because she suggested it, and I loved it. But no one tried to TELL me what my daughter's name was going to be. I probably would have laughed, and when I realized they were serious I would have smacked them.
1 person likes this
26 Nov 08
It must be a great feeling to name your own children is it? I think so, because even they are not my kids I felt great because of the honor that I am the one who had chosen their names. Now, I am changing for the better I will only suggest to their parents and if they will not accept it, it's alright I have had my turn already. It made me happy and it's a nice feeling being an Aunt, but they all call me Mommy. Thanks for sharing!
• United States
25 Nov 08
yes you not doing the right thing and i think you offending their right to give their sons or their daughters a name. first of all you took advantage of them. you should be happy they let you give name their first sons. i think it is a privilege.do not abuse.
1 person likes this
25 Nov 08
I know it's an honor to name a child and I am very proud that my siblings asked me to name their children. Now I am thinking it's about time that the time is right to let them name their own children. Although it would be great if they ask me to choose again, but if they don't I will understand. Thanks for sharing its helpful.
• Indonesia
26 Nov 08
choosing a baby name can be very easy or difficult because involve our family. Just like you. But it can be easy, if you name your baby bay yourself. Because the baby is yours. But you can allow them to give a name but the decision is your. Happy naming?
1 person likes this
26 Nov 08
Cheers, I am very happy naming them! Even they are not my own kids, I just love kids as like as they are my own. I know it's a different feeling when you have a child on your own than just love them as your own. I have'nt had a baby on my own but would love one but it seems it impossible for me, and now I just love the children as if they were mine.
@lilybug (21107)
• United States
25 Nov 08
No, I do not think you are doing the right thing. I think that the parents of the child are the only ones who have the right to choose the child's name. I would be very upset if someone went behind my back and changed the name I had given my child. As you stated above it is not a tradition just something you decided to do. So, I guess when you have a child of your own someone else gets to name it?
1 person likes this
25 Nov 08
No, I don't want somebody else to name my own baby, but I just love this opportunity of choosing names because they always follow what I had chosen. But you're right it's unfair for them, so far I just have three nephews and two nieces who were being called by the name which I had chosen for them. And there's another one coming soon, I will have to think about it. Thanks for sharing.
• United States
25 Nov 08
You can only offend them if they don't want you to name their children- I will admit that it seems odd that a sibiling is naming their nieces and nephews but each family has their own way of doing things and if that works for you then keep it up. To each his own. My husband and I named our children- of course everyone in the family had input that we listened to but in the end it was our decision. Both of our boys have family names and that is just right for us. Good luck to you and your family and happy baby naming!
25 Nov 08
Cheers! You made me smile when you said happy baby naming, yes I love naming babies! It seems like my siblings are very fertile and that's why they gave birth every year. there were three babies being born within this year only, and I named them all. I told them to do a family planning to control themselves from making lots of babies but it seems it didn't work for them though.
@zeethegr8 (785)
• India
25 Nov 08
Choosing a baby's name can be a lot of responsibility and nowadays, many of us are searching for the Internet or looking up to the library books for names. Everyone wants a unique and the few or a meaningful name for the new-born. It is always better for the parents to choose their own baby's name, as it provides satisfaction and also sense of completion of responsibility.
1 person likes this
25 Nov 08
Oh my, I must be too selfish having done it! I felt guilty of myself now, because this might be the thing that my sisters and brothers had missed in their parenting when I took over the rights in choosing their own baby's name. Maybe it's time to give them their rights back, I am thinking about it now. Thanks a lot for opening my eyes to see the right thing.
@hellcord (673)
• Romania
25 Nov 08
Bleh, I would never let my mother choose my sons' and daughters' names, but as was said before, must be a different tradition in your country :D The way I see it, there are 2 things that one MUST do before choosing a name for a child before it is born: 1. Get HIGH as never before. Eat Mushrooms, DMT, go to the Amazonian Jungle and have the strongest Shaman prepare the strongest brew, and have the mother of all travels, and that will give you the best name ever. 2. If it is a boy, one MUST check out this list: http://tinyurl.com/22hxk8 The manliest names in the world. With this knowledge, I am confident that I will be able to give just AWESOME names, to any children, male female animal or alien, that I may have in this life
1 person likes this
25 Nov 08
It's not a tradition in my country, but it's like a tradition in my own family. The person who is the main provider for the family is always asked to name the next child born, because I had been a provider for many years it's always fallen on me to name their children. And I love it as I love them so much! Thanks sharing the tips, and happy mylotting.
@hildas (3031)
25 Nov 08
I suppose it could be nice to help someone else choose from this tough decission, but I named all my childre myself. I did listen to my family and kept their ideas in mind. I think offering suggestions and all agreeing on a name is best though. My daughter just had a new baby and I hated the name she picked for him. My husband did not like it and he told her. She thought about it, but decided to stick with the name and got him registered. It was really hard at first to call him this awful name. Now we have got used to it and it actually does suit him.
25 Nov 08
Oh I see! Yes, that's one of the reasons too why I am the one who always picked their names because I don't want them to call their kids with an awful name, I like their names to be unique, special and meaningful. But I think I should give them a chance next time, I had a chosen name already but now I changed my mind I might just suggest it to them and let them decide. Thanks for sharing!
25 Nov 08
Unique names are the best, If your going to choose a babies name don't be afraid to open up your horizon, or you can call him yahoo and thats his/her University tuition fee paid loolz
1 person likes this
25 Nov 08
Wow, you made me smile! Yes I just love to be the one who will always chooses the name for them. I even had a name chosen already for my next nephew to be born next month, I don't know if my sister and brother in law would like it, I didn't tell them yet. Because I don't want them to change their minds right now. But most of the names I had given to them are meaningful. Thanks for sharing.