Never drink while eating ?

@ronnyb (6113)
Jamaica
December 12, 2008 7:52am CST
My mother and grandmother are always imploring me not to drink while eating .I have always thought this was an ettiquette issue.However lately I am wondering if there could be an health issues involved . What are your views ?
5 people like this
9 responses
• India
12 Dec 08
Acctually your mother and grand mother think you may not eat more if you drink water not only your mother and grand mother almost everyone's mother and grandmother say the same because care for us the most but i think it's a bad idea because drinking water in the middle of our meals makes us easy to eat food with out any intrecptions
3 people like this
@ronnyb (6113)
• Jamaica
12 Dec 08
Ok I see the point you are making .Water is likely to fill our stomachs leaving little space for anything else.
2 people like this
@reinydawn (11643)
• United States
13 Dec 08
My sister-in-law had the gastric bypass surgery to help her control her weight. She said that one of the things they tell you is not to drink anything before during or after a meal. The liquid will speed up the digestion process by merely flushing the food through your system before your body has a chance to break it down and get the nutrients out. It's kinda like wasting your food. Also, it makes you feel fuller so you stop eating, but you are hungry again sooner.
2 people like this
@reinydawn (11643)
• United States
16 Dec 08
I know people who will drink a lot of water before they eat so that they are full and wont eat as much. They figure it's a good way to diet, but aparently not.
@ronnyb (6113)
• Jamaica
16 Dec 08
I didnt know about the the liquid flushing your system ,thanks for that but what I do know is that I usually feel full when I eat and drink at the same time. Thank for your response
1 person likes this
• India
12 Dec 08
My mother is telling the same thing to me.It is better to drink water after or before eating.
2 people like this
@ronnyb (6113)
• Jamaica
13 Dec 08
but is it esay though to follow their advice though I really try but as soon as I start eating ,I want something to drink
• Lubbock, Texas
12 Dec 08
I found this at http://dorischua.com/2008/06/25/drinking-at-meal-times-to-be-avoided/ It has become a habit for most of us to drink with our daily meals. Do you know that drinking freely during meal times can be harmful? Not only does it encourage hasty eating, but dilutes the gastric juice, and thus lessens the activity. The food should be chewed until sufficiently moistened by saliva to allow it to be swallowed. When large quantities of fluid are taken into the stomach, digestion does not begin until a considerable portion of the fluid has been absorbed. If cold foods or drinks are taken with the meal, such as ice-cream, ice-water, iced milk or tea, the stomach is chilled, and a long delay in the digestive process is occasioned. So take it easy with your drinks during meal times to aid healthy digestion. The Asian cultures especially Chinese also say that cold drinks should not be taken after a meal. Only warm drinks. This helps your stomach acids dissolve fat and process cholesterol preventing high cholesterol, obesity, clogged arteries.
@ronnyb (6113)
• Jamaica
15 Dec 08
I think i have heard this very statement too,thanks for the scientific explanation
@Yori88 (1465)
• Philippines
12 Dec 08
In my own opinion the reason why I was not allowed to drink water before eating when I was a kid is because I will get full immediately and lose my appetite. My parents always warn me to eat first and just drink water after eating or finishing the food. My question though during those days is what if I get full and I need water to clear my throat? Should they still forbid me to drink water? Today I usually drink water in the middle of my eating time because I enjoy the food I eat and I always want to feel satisfied. There are some chances where I drink beverage first especially if it is a juice before eating my meals because I am thirsty more than hungry. And with that I could still eat a lot, contrary to what others believe that you will get full if you drink first before eating.
2 people like this
• Lubbock, Texas
16 Dec 08
Small drinks during a meal are permitted if necessary, but you shouldn't take a bite of food, then take a big gulp of liquid. Many people teach their children this way because they want them to get in the habit of chewing their food well and eating slowly to digest it properly. They may not know the scientific reason, but that is the way they've been taught and they believe that's the right way.
@Theresaaiza (10487)
• Australia
13 Dec 08
that's especially harmful because we need a concentrated gastric juice to digest the food but water dilutes that. imagine mixing grease and water together. waht happens? that's what happens inside if we dilute the gastric juices.
2 people like this
@ronnyb (6113)
• Jamaica
8 Feb 10
This is exactly what most persons who dont support the eat and drink theory say .Thanks for your response
@Theresaaiza (10487)
• Australia
9 Feb 10
HI ronny, actually it's not just a theory. It's a scientific fact.
@kellys3ps (3723)
• United States
12 Dec 08
Actually doctors say that drinking water aids in digestion.
1 person likes this
@Theresaaiza (10487)
• Australia
13 Dec 08
...yes, but at the right timing. It should be done at 1-hour gaps before and after eating. The total amount of water in a day should be 8 to 10 glasses or 2 -3 liters and must be done in between meals and again, at i-hour gaps.
1 person likes this
@Beruang (1309)
• Malaysia
12 Dec 08
I have read aboout a few researches that mentioned that it is better not to drink while we are eating. Many years ago I used to drink and eat at the same time especially when I am at a party. However, a few years back, not only that I read about it on those researches but also I was told by many people that it is not a good practice to eat and drink at the same time. All of them are telling me that I should eat my meal first until I am fully done with that. Then it is recommended to just take a five minutes break and themn only we should go for the drinks... However, if you are choking, I would suggest that you forget about the rules and go for the drink straight away as that would be safer for you. Cheers!
• China
12 Dec 08
oh,yes,heath is very important for us.we'd better keep the good habit on daily life. i enjoy eat fresh fruit ,vegetable,and another thing is do some sport,have a good sleep .well,keep heathy
2 people like this