Who is hotter? Carlisle or Edward?

Philippines
January 17, 2009 8:23am CST
I am a Twilight fan. I was done reading the saga until the Midnight Sun. In the movie, who do you think is hotter? Is it the ever supportive Carlisle? Or the Volvo owner, Edward?
2 people like this
8 responses
@megumiart (3781)
• United States
16 Mar 09
Definately Edaward, lol. Carlisle in the movie was totally not what I imaginged him to be.
1 person likes this
@mommyboo (13198)
• United States
22 Mar 09
I know.... he just didn't quite look right. If he was left with dark hair I think he would have looked a little more natural to me. Rosalie wasn't exactly what I expected either from the book, but Alice and Jasper were spot on.
@shanelli (20)
• Philippines
19 Jan 09
definitely edward...but i meant edward cullen as described in the book...sorry...i dont have anything against the actor who played the part but he doesnt look like the EDWARD CULLEN in my head...just like edward had said, Carlisle outshines him in many ways..but my loyalty and affection still remains with edward..lol..he is simply dazzling and magnificent...i fell in love with him...lol...my husband said im a hopeless case for ive read the breaking dawn for more than 10x and still reading it today...lol...
• Philippines
19 Jan 09
I have also a different Edward in my mind and heart. lol. But Robert Pattinson is played a good role of Edward. To some extent, I have seen the Edwardness in him as described in the book. Definitely, I prefer Edward over Carlisle. I love his cheesy lines. He makes me fall. lol
@tcs9423 (29)
• Macedonia
3 May 09
Edward is hotter ^_^ but carlise is cool too. Love his way of handling problems without panicking
@mommyboo (13198)
• United States
22 Mar 09
LOL! Well that would depend who you identify with more right, Esme or Bella . Since so far Stephenie has never written from Carlisle or Esme's perspective, I've got to choose Edward. A lot of what makes him hot to me has nothing to do with his physical attributes either
• United States
19 Jan 09
Edward is hotter if you are only taking looks into account but Carlisle is so gentle and caring, I think Carlisle would make a better husband personally. Edward is sweet too though, I definitely would not turn him down, lol. But if I could have either one I would choose Carlisle for his personality.
@Galena (9123)
18 Jan 09
to me, definitely Edward. this is without even considering the actors playing them in the film, because neither of them look like they did when I read them in my head.
@owstalaga (4561)
• Philippines
18 Jan 09
I like Carlisle better than Edward... i never really liked Robert Pattinson even in Harry Potter. He's just not my type. =) But him and "Bella" look good together so i guess he's okay. =)
• Philippines
17 Jan 09
of course ill edward!!!! hahah i love him! really!! although he has a shot wherein he doesnt look handsome but still all in all i really like him! cant wait for the eclipse!!!! OMG!!!!! the role of edward really suits Robert Pattinson! hahahha. anyway Carlisle is also handsome but ofcourse ill choose the younger one which is Edward! cheers!! im done reading the book! im just waiting for the movie to come. hope early this year hahaha if thats possible :D