My employer made us work short staffed on purpose!!

@nixxi76 (3191)
Canada
January 17, 2009 6:43pm CST
Usually on a nightshift we require four workers and a nurse in charge, but two nights ago we were short one worker. Our director of nursing told the day staff that we night workers can handle one short. Now to me this is very unfair because it's very difficult when there's one person short. It seems that they always make sure dayshift employees are fully staffed and if they are even one person short they will either try to call someone in to come and work, or make one of the nightshift employees stay and do overtime. I found out that they called someone to come in and work and the person agreed so they wrote her in for a nightshift. Suddenly the DON called her back and told her to forget it. I also found out that three other people offered to work it and she still wouldn't allow it because she said that nightshift could handle it. I really feel like people at my work hate the people who work on nightshift, and politics are taking over. Do you think this is fair?
2 people like this
8 responses
@Lakota12 (42600)
• United States
18 Jan 09
No not fair but seems like ever job thinks nightshift work is a breeze . FOr they think the pateints sleep of course they really dont all the time. But I guess ya have to deal withit in your own way. and most daytime workes put off things and leave the job for the night shift then when it isnt done they say oh tats the night shift for ya. When ya know you have done all ya can do. Also if ya short the head nurse should take up the slack
1 person likes this
@Lakota12 (42600)
• United States
19 Jan 09
I guess I am bold but I would point that out to them! and they really must be lazy if that is all they do. No wonder that calls go unaswered for a long time ringing if no on emans the phones! or helps to man them!
@nixxi76 (3191)
• Canada
19 Jan 09
Good point to bring up here Lakota. I completely forgot to add that in our handbook and what is suppose to happen when we are short staffed is that the head nurse is suppose to stay overtime for the next shift and help us out! The question is do any of the nurses actually do that? NOPE they don't nor do they lift a finger to helps us out either. God forbid if the head nurses had to answer a call light or do any of our duties for once. If it has nothing to do with handing out pills or treatments, they won't do anything otherwise. Thanks for your comment
• United States
18 Jan 09
this very unfair - and needs to be reported. i know that this would probably risk your job, so be careful... this would likely be a PR issue - day staff will always stay full, because this is the time when inspectors would show up, and when most family members would be visiting and raise complaints based on level of care. the problem of the economy and saving money within the facility is no excuse! if the night shift could handle it, the full staff would be shorter in the first place right? there are reasons that there are staff to patient ratios - there have been studies in the past that have shown that this number is necessary for the staff to attend to the patient needs in a timely and qualified manner.
1 person likes this
@nixxi76 (3191)
• Canada
19 Jan 09
I just feel like nightshift employees always take the brunt of things around work. There are many times when I use to work evening shifts and come in and see dayshift employees waiting to go home by just sitting around. Now if nightshift is sitting at the end of shift waiting to go home, then it's brought up and on every report it's heard about. So there is a lot of unfairness beside of what I originally wrote in my discussion. Thanks for your comment
• United States
18 Jan 09
I work for people with developmental disabilities they all three require total assistance and there is only two staff for them I feel they need three staff one for each due to their condition how can places like this get by with this staff we are talking about caring for the life of others.
1 person likes this
@nixxi76 (3191)
• Canada
19 Jan 09
I'm not sure how they get by. I know that if there's not the appropriate number of staff then the work has to be shortened and total care is not complete. When I got hired on at this nursing home, the minimum requirements for nightshift was four HCA's and one RN or LPN, so I'm not sure what's happening. Twice this week I had to work short and even a resident was asking me what was going on. I didn't know what to tell her except that if they needed anything, then just pull the call light. Thanks for your comment
@pau_79 (790)
• Philippines
18 Jan 09
Its not unusual in our country. I used to work in operation as well and nightshift only have skeletal force. I think maybe it bothers you coz its still new for you but eventually you will get used to it. The financial crisis is also one factor, saving up on staff is always a welcome idea for managers to save. In our countyr even electricity are watch ie turn off aircon unit when its 5 pm and lights as well. This is implemented even when staff are still working overtime. Dont let it get to you -though I understand how you feel but sometimes we need to understand that there might be a deeper explanation. As for fair its hard to say what is fair because in the end we will only believe what we want to. Goodluck with your work
@nixxi76 (3191)
• Canada
19 Jan 09
I think I was upset because I was not put in the other person's shoes that had to work short before. I just finished a stretch of seven nights and I had to work short twice out of that. I hope that never happens again lol Thanks for your comment
@lynnemg (4529)
• United States
18 Jan 09
I worked in a nursing home myself, on the day/evening shift. I don't know about the facility where you work, but I know where I worked, the day shift got the residents up, gave showers, did all the rehab programs and activities, plus served two meals, and the whole time, we made sure that all of our residents remained dry and clean. On the evening shift, we had one meal to serve, a couple of showers, snacks, and we got the residents changes and in bed. That left the night shift with no more than having to check, change, and answer call lights. If your facility works this way, I can understand why the DON believes that you should be able to work one short. Our night shift would complain if we asked them to help get up a few residents, but brag that they were able to sit at the desk most of the night. In a nursing home, the day shift workers normally have the brunt of the work. It is not that the other shifts are unappreciated, it is that in most cases, the night shift is much easier to work than the days shift. Not to mention, most of the time, visitors, or a State employee will walk in the building during the day rather than the night. If the State walked in during any given day and the facility was not fully staffed, there could be problems. Right now, with the economy the way it is, businesses, including nursing homes, are having to cut back to save money. Rather than being upset because you all have to do a little more work that night, be thankful that you have a job to go to.
1 person likes this
@nixxi76 (3191)
• Canada
18 Jan 09
I am thankful that I have a job to go to but I would appreciate it if other shifts would be as appreciated towards us as they are the dayshift employees. On nightshifts we have to do the stocking of breifs, clean wheelchairs, do three wetchecks, answer call bells and usually those call bells range from about 30 to 50 per night because there are many residents that don't sleep at all. Five o'clock we have to start dressing people and that usually goes on until seven. I am one of those who dress extra people and even get them out of bed in the mornings so that I will be appreciated so we are not actually sitting around at night because we have no time to. I don't believe the economy has anything to do with this matter because health care is always going to be a huge need in any community and it's not like we don't have extras that will work because at least four people were willing to work the DON just didn't let them and for other reasons than thinking that we could handle it, I'm sure it's because the dayshift employees are her favorites. The nightshift nurse had a good point. He said that he was going to test the waters at work by telling the DON that he couldn't work nights anymore and he was going to have to switch to days. He mentioned this which makes sense... do you think any of those other shift nurses would actually be happy to take all the nights that he does? NOPE! They wouldn't be able to handle it and I think that goes for the HCA's as well. He said that people should just quit complaining about nightshifts. Thanks for your comment
@nigenh (167)
• India
18 Jan 09
this looks unfair, why dnt you talk to someone who is at the top of the ladder, i mean someone who is in the higher post, might be a notice to them can solve this problem. If this doesn't come handy you better change the job if you are not able to put up with or change the shift.
1 person likes this
@nixxi76 (3191)
• Canada
19 Jan 09
I feel that I do my best work on nightshift or evening. The only reason I do so many nights is because it fits in my family life with my son's age and being able to be here at home during the day or evening times. I don't see why the budget that everyone is talking about can be a problem because the owner charges the same every month for these rooms and nothing that we are doing is changing. To me health care is never going to have a problem when it comes down to the economy and how crappy it is because it's so much in high demand and there's always going to be sick elders. Thanks for your comment
@KrauseHome (36448)
• United States
18 Jan 09
Well personally I think due to the $$ situation a lot of jobs are starting to become like this. They feel it is better to be Short than have to call in someone else and possibly have to pay overtime as well. In a lot of ways I can see the meaning for this, but when it tends to start cutting into Customer Service, etc. in the workplace as well, it makes you wonder. All I can say is do the Best you can, and hope for a change to happen sometime in the future for you as well.
1 person likes this
@nixxi76 (3191)
• Canada
18 Jan 09
When it comes to the residents nothing else should matter so my employer says. It's true about them not wanting to pay extra but four is the minimum requirement so it wasn't like they were going out of their budget. Also if you only have half the staff on one side of the building then only half the work technically gets done and then there's more work for the precious dayshift. How can that possibly be proper care for the residents? If my work keeps this up, the residents are going to start complaining and before you know it, we're going to need another extra person on top of the four working because the families are going to complain. We are short again tonight and I knew this from thursday night and I"m sure my supervisor did too. She had the time to get someone in to work tonight but she didn't so this is the second time in one week where it's been short on nights. Thanks for your comment
@Sissygrl (10912)
• Canada
18 Jan 09
It certainly doesn't seem fair to me no.. I have had a lot of different jobs in my life none of which i have taken too seriously.. it seems though that as long as one person is happy, there will always be someone unhappy, about the situation. . Not saying that your being negative about it, you have a right to be upset, you have another workload of a missing staff, but i bet the person paying the nurses are happy because they dont have to pay the wages of a nurse for that night. . nothing in life is fair, but we gotta keep living. . it sucks.. but what can you do eh nixxi ? push forward.. i'd come help you if i could.
1 person likes this
@nixxi76 (3191)
• Canada
18 Jan 09
Thanks sissygrl, that makes me feel a heck of a lot better that I still have hope with this nonsense at work and that I"m not the only one feeling badly about it. Honestly it seems like there's going to be a war breaking out at my work and that the shifts are all against each other. I don't want to feel like I"m on a battlefield, I just want to go to work and work lol. You're right about one thing though, as long as one person is happy then someone else will be unhappy. Thanks for your comment